Skip to main content

Paul Thurrott on Surface brand: ‘Microsoft, you’re f@#$ing up.’

Consumers have had issues with Microsoft’s Surface Book and Surface Pro 4 (not to mention previous Surface devices) ever since the devices first launched. Despite persistent forum posts and requests for Microsoft to open up on the issue, the tech giant hasn’t stepped forward. Rather, it has kept silent, presumably hoping for the storm clouds to quietly pass by its borders. But that strategy might backfire when one of the arguably most well known Microsoft-focused journalists in the world points it out to everyone and tells the company to get its act together.

Paul Thurrott has over 20 years of industry experience and is the News Director for the Petri IT Knowledgebase. In a recent post on his own website, he let the world know he’s not happy with Microsoft’s way of handling things. He’s calling it Surfacegate.

Recommended Videos

The Surface Book and Surface Pro 4 are two of Microsoft’s leading brand devices. They’re marketed as the cutting edge of technology and the ultimate way to enjoy Windows 10. But faulty software and an overall silent treatment from support has them making short on that promise. In the words of the Thurrott: “Microsoft, you’re f@#$ing up. Big time.”

Arguments for the poor treatment of the situation are largely dependent on Apple’s situation back in 2010. The Antennagate predicament left people with interrupted phone calls for holding their devices incorrectly. Design took precedence over functionality, and users got the short end of the stick. But Apple was open with its consumers, publicly acknowledging the problem and offering a “let’s meet halfway” solution. For those that don’t remember, this consisted of a protective case that made it harder for fingers to make an electrical connection between the phone’s two external antennas.

Microsoft hasn’t been nearly as open or productive. Aside from the occasional patches that have come through, consumers have no way of knowing when or how their particular issues will be dealt with. Reported issues include (but are not limited to) displays that won’t start after the system is put to sleep and slow boot issues when the compatible keyboard is attached. With a high price tag comes high responsibility, and consumers should be able to rely on hardware upon purchase.

Towards the end of his post, Thurrott brings down the hammer. “These are beautiful and expensive devices. But our faith is shaken.” One of the industry’s biggest names in Microsoft reporting has spoken, and we are listening. If nothing else, perhaps Microsoft wants to avoid living with the measly legend of “Surfacegate.”

Dan Isacsson
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Being a gamer since the age of three, Dan took an interest in mobile gaming back in 2009. Since then he's been digging ever…
Don’t buy the Surface Laptop Go 3 — here’s what you should get instead
Microsoft Surface Laptop Go 3 front view showing display and keyboard.

As a former marketing professional and a laptop reviewer, I often find myself surprised and sometimes confused by the decisions companies make when launching a laptop. An example is when a company introduces just one or two configurations that may not meet the needs of a range of users and, as a result, starts a laptop off on the wrong foot. In that case, I can at least understand the complexity of manufacturing and component sourcing. Although I'll mention a lack of options in a review, I won't necessarily ding a laptop because of it.

Some mistakes, though, are harder to overlook. That's how I feel about Microsoft's Surface Laptop Go 3, which the company introduced at a significantly higher price than its predecessors. The laptop, which is designed and configured like a budget machine, starts at $800 and runs up to $1,000. Those are midrange prices, but the Surface just can't compete against many midrange laptops.
$800 is too much
Asus Zenbook 14 OLED Mark Coppock / Digital Trends

Read more
Everything Microsoft didn’t announce at its 2023 Surface event
Microsoft showing off the new Surface laptop Go 3 at its September event.

Microsoft unveiled several new products during its 2023 Surface event. We got lots of updates about Windows Copilot and other AI-driven software upgrades, as well as plenty of hardware, including the Surface Laptop Studio 2 and the Surface Laptop Go 3.

While a lot of our early predictions came true during the Microsoft September event, there are still a few things that were noticeably missing from this year's lineup. Here's what Microsoft could have announced, but didn't.
Surface Pro 10

Read more
Should you buy the Surface Laptop Studio or wait for the Surface Laptop Studio 2?
The Surface Laptop Studio 2 on a white table.

Announced during the Microsoft September event, the Surface Laptop Studio 2 joins a growing family of Surface devices. Equipped with all the same flexibility we'd expect from the best 2-in-1 laptops, the Studio 2 may look very similar to the previous version, but it's a lot more different than it seems at a glance.

How does the new version compare to Microsoft's original Laptop Studio? Below, we'll take you on a deep dive into these two devices and help you make your pick if you're trying to choose between them. Make sure to read our Surface Laptop Studio 2 review, as well.
Pricing and availability

Read more