Skip to main content

Max Schrems warns Privacy Shield deal between U.S. and Europe will fail

Max Schrems, the Austrian privacy advocate and thorn in the side of tech companies, has stated that the newly-passed Privacy Shield will likely fail.

Privacy Shield is a new agreement between the U.S. and the EU that allows for legally protected data transfers across the Atlantic. It was officially passed by a vote last Friday and is expected to be formally announced tomorrow. It replaces the old agreement Safe Harbor, which was ruled invalid last year by the European Court of Justice in a case taken by Schrems.

Recommended Videos

The new agreement has been divisive. Schrems told Fortune that he does not expect it will last long. “It’s the same as Safe Harbor with a couple of additions, and it’s going to fail like the one before,” he said.

The main issue with Safe Harbor is U.S. bulk surveillance that impacts EU citizens’ data once it is transferred Stateside. One of the new additions includes an authority that will be set up by the U.S. to investigate any claims by EU citizens over surveillance or data privacy abuse. But critics of Privacy Shield note that these new provisions don’t address surveillance in any meaningful way.

It remains to be seen if the European Court of Justice will allow Privacy Shield to commence or if it will be struck down like its predecessor.

With this uncertainty in mind, Schrems believes that corporations and internet companies will be reluctant to sign up to the agreement immediately, in case it falls apart.

Vera Jourova, the EU’s justice commissioner, thinks otherwise, stating last week that Privacy Shield has “ruled out indiscriminate mass surveillance of European citizens’ data”.

She has one major supporter already — Microsoft. John Frank, the company’s vice president of EU government affairs, wrote that the agreement was an “important achievement for the privacy rights” or Europeans and that Microsoft will be signing up ASAP.

Jourova reiterated at a parliamentary hearing today that Privacy Shield comes with a suspension clause that can be triggered if U.S. companies or the government do not keep up their end of the arrangement. Privacy Shield will be also subject to an annual review, which will give critics an opportunity to voice concerns.

Last week four countries – Austria, Bulgaria, Croatia, and Slovenia – abstained from the vote. According to Jourova, the countries are willing to give the agreement a year but are keen to reassess it.

This approach too has been criticized. David Martin Ruiz, a digital policy lawyer in Brussels, tweeted that the general attitude toward the agreement is to just give it a chance rather than work out a new agreement now.

Jonathan Keane
Jonathan is a freelance technology journalist living in Dublin, Ireland. He's previously written for publications and sites…
The robot takeover comes another step closer — at Amazon
An Amazon robot working inside one of the company's warehouses.

Amazon is close to having more robots operating inside its warehouses than humans after the e-commerce giant announced this week that it now has more than a million robots working at its facilities around the world.

Over the years, Amazon has spent billions of dollars on the development and deployment of warehouse-based robots, which handle an array of tasks once performed by human workers.

Read more
This Lenovo ThinkPad laptop is over $1,400 off — hurry while stocks last!
The Lenovo ThinkPad T14 Gen 5 Intel laptop on a white background.

Now's an excellent time to take advantage of laptop deals from Lenovo, which has slashed the prices of a wide range of devices for its Black Friday in July sale. Lenovo's ThinkPad laptops are up to 45% off, and here's one of the most interesting offers available with such a discount — the Lenovo ThinkPad T14 Gen 5 at $1,440 off its estimated value of $3,199, so you'll only have to pay $1,759. That's an excellent price for this fantastic productivity tool, but you're going to have to push forward with your purchase as soon as possible because stocks may run out at any moment.

BUY NOW

Read more
Early Prime Day deal: Samsung’s 27-inch Odyssey G3 at its annual low price
Samsung Odyssey G3 gaming monitor on desk with keyboard and headset.

If you're ready to upgrade your monitor, this Samsung deal over at Amazon just might be your best bet. The 27-inch version of Samsung's Odyssey G3 is $130 right now, a full $100 off its regular $230 price and its lowest price of the year. It's a part of early Prime Day deals and a good sampling of what we can expect for the shopping holiday, which officially lands on July 8th. Tap the button below to see it for yourself or keep reading to see why we like this deal and why this should be your next monitor.

Buy Now

Read more