RealNetworks’ Antitrust Claims Over RealDVD Dismissed


Back in 2008, Real Networks promised to usher in a new era in digital entertainment with RealDVD, which claimed to offer 100 percent legal copying of DVDs for personal use so owners could enjoy them on their PCs, portable media devices, and other digital technology. Of course, it took Hollywood—in the form of the MPAA—only a short time to slam a lawsuit on RealNetworks claiming RealDVD amounted to little more than “StealDVD,” and a court quickly granted and upheld an injunction preventing the software from being sold. RealNetworks has been continuing to pursue the case in court, and had filed counterclaims that, by preventing RealDVD from getting to market, the MPAA had engaged in anticompetitive practices. Last week, Judge Marilyn Patel dismissed that claim, saying Real Networks had no one to blame but itself for the studios coming after the product, and that Hollywood studios had every right to join forces to fight it.

In a nutshell, RealDVD purported to work by not only copying a DVD’s digital content, but also by preserving the CSS encryption used to protect a DVD from clandestine copying—and adding another level of protection on top of that to be even more secure. Real Networks had hoped to skate through the complex DVD Copy Control Association licensing on a loophole opened by Kaliedescape, which enabled their high-end home theater products to make a copy of a DVD (with CSS encryption) for storage on a local hard drive. When the studios sued to block sales of RealDVD, Real Networks countersued, arguing the studios working together to suppress RealDVD amounted to an illegal cartel and a violation of antitrust law.

Instead, Judge Patel ruled that the studios had the right to work together towards a common legal outcome under the Noerr-Pennington doctrine, established by the Supreme Court in the late 1960s and early 1970s—the doctrine holds that companies working to advocate enforcement of passage of legislation are immune from antitrust violations, even if those laws would have anticompetitive effects. Patel also ruled that the only damages Real Networks has suffered from the RealDVD effort have been as the result of its own actions: first trying to publish illegal software, then protracting the dispute through legal action.

At this point,Real Networks might choose to engage in further appeals, but the company is still barred from selling RealDVD and apparently cannot argue that the software is legal, or that Hollywood studios engaged in illegal conduct to keep it from market. It appears Real Networks’ efforts to bring RealDVD to market are at an end.

Home Theater

The best movies on Netflix in February, from 'Buster Scruggs’ to 'Roma'

Save yourself from hours wasted scrolling through Netflix's massive library by checking out our picks for the streamer's best movies available right now, whether you're into explosive action, witty humor, or anything else.
Home Theater

The best Dolby Atmos movies for your home theater sound as good as they look

If you've got your hands on some sweet Dolby Atmos gear, the next step is to find films that take advantage of it. These are our picks in several genres for the best Dolby Atmos movies currently available on Blu-ray and streaming services.

Among hundreds of choices, these are the best 25 SNES games of all time

The Super Nintendo Entertainment System might be the greatest game console ever made, but what are the best titles for the system? Here are our picks for the best SNES games.
Movies & TV

'Prime'-time TV: Here are the best shows on Amazon Prime right now

There's more to Amazon Prime than free two-day shipping, including access to a number of phenomenal shows at no extra cost. To make the sifting easier, here are our favorite shows currently streaming on Amazon Prime.

Dodge the biggest laptop-buying mistakes with these handy tips

Buying a new laptop is exciting, but you need to watch your footing. There are a number of pitfalls you need to avoid and we're here to help. Check out these top-10 laptop buying mistakes and how to avoid them.

Great PC speakers don't need to break the bank. These are our favorites

Not sure which PC speakers work best with your computer? Here are the best computer speakers on the market, whether you're working with a tight budget or looking to rattle your workstation with top-of-the-line audio components.

The rumors were true. Nvidia’s 1660 Ti GPU, a $280 powerhouse, has arrived

Nvidia has officially launched the GTX 1660 Ti, its next-generation, Turing-based GPU. It promises to deliver all the performance and efficiency for all modern games, but without stepping into the high price range of the RTX series. 

Confused about RSS? Don't be. Here's what it is and how to use it

What is an RSS feed, anyway? This traditional method of following online news is still plenty useful. Let's take a look at what RSS means, and what advantages it has in today's busy world.

Everything you need to know about routers, modems, combos, and mesh networks

Modem vs. router: what's the difference? We explain their functions so you can better diagnose any issues prior to contacting technical support. We also talk about a few variants you'll see offered by ISPs and retailers.

Metro Exodus update brings DLSS improvements to Nvidia RTX 20-series PCs

Having issues in Metro Exodus? A February 21 update for the title recently delivered enhancements to Nvidia’s deep learning supersampling feature and other fixes for low-specced PCs. 

Limited-time sale knocks $500 off the price of the Razer Blade Pro 17

Looking for an ultra-powerful laptop for yourself or someone else? You're in for some luck. Razer is running a sale on some of its best gaming laptops, cutting down pricing on the Razer Blade 15 and the Razer Blade Pro 17. 
Emerging Tech

Engineer turns his old Apple lle into an wheeled robot, and even gives it a sword

How do you give new life to a 30-year-old computer? Software engineer Mike Kohn found a way by transforming his old Apple IIe into a wheeled robot. Check it out in all its 1980s glory.

Want to play as Iron Man or Waluigi in GTA V? Our favorite mods make it possible

Grand Theft Auto V is best on the PC for many reasons, and modifications may be the most important. You can cause riots, spawn unique cars, and play as a cop with just a few extra files.

Does the GTX 1660 Ti's leaner design make it a better GPU than the RTX 2060?

Nvidia's GTX 1660 Ti is a new Turing GPU without ray tracing or DLSS, but how does it compare to its RTX brethren? We pit the 1660 Ti versus the RTX 2060 to find out in this comparison.