RealNetworks’ Antitrust Claims Over RealDVD Dismissed


Back in 2008, Real Networks promised to usher in a new era in digital entertainment with RealDVD, which claimed to offer 100 percent legal copying of DVDs for personal use so owners could enjoy them on their PCs, portable media devices, and other digital technology. Of course, it took Hollywood—in the form of the MPAA—only a short time to slam a lawsuit on RealNetworks claiming RealDVD amounted to little more than “StealDVD,” and a court quickly granted and upheld an injunction preventing the software from being sold. RealNetworks has been continuing to pursue the case in court, and had filed counterclaims that, by preventing RealDVD from getting to market, the MPAA had engaged in anticompetitive practices. Last week, Judge Marilyn Patel dismissed that claim, saying Real Networks had no one to blame but itself for the studios coming after the product, and that Hollywood studios had every right to join forces to fight it.

In a nutshell, RealDVD purported to work by not only copying a DVD’s digital content, but also by preserving the CSS encryption used to protect a DVD from clandestine copying—and adding another level of protection on top of that to be even more secure. Real Networks had hoped to skate through the complex DVD Copy Control Association licensing on a loophole opened by Kaliedescape, which enabled their high-end home theater products to make a copy of a DVD (with CSS encryption) for storage on a local hard drive. When the studios sued to block sales of RealDVD, Real Networks countersued, arguing the studios working together to suppress RealDVD amounted to an illegal cartel and a violation of antitrust law.

Instead, Judge Patel ruled that the studios had the right to work together towards a common legal outcome under the Noerr-Pennington doctrine, established by the Supreme Court in the late 1960s and early 1970s—the doctrine holds that companies working to advocate enforcement of passage of legislation are immune from antitrust violations, even if those laws would have anticompetitive effects. Patel also ruled that the only damages Real Networks has suffered from the RealDVD effort have been as the result of its own actions: first trying to publish illegal software, then protracting the dispute through legal action.

At this point,Real Networks might choose to engage in further appeals, but the company is still barred from selling RealDVD and apparently cannot argue that the software is legal, or that Hollywood studios engaged in illegal conduct to keep it from market. It appears Real Networks’ efforts to bring RealDVD to market are at an end.


Chinese court upholds Qualcomm's complaint that Apple infringed on two patents

Apple is following the FTC's lead and has sued Qualcomm for a massive $1 billion in the U.S., $145 million in China, and also in the U.K., claiming the company charged onerous royalties for its patented tech.
Home Theater

The best movies on Netflix in December, from 'Buster Scruggs’ to endangered cats

Save yourself from hours wasted scrolling through Netflix's massive library by checking out our picks for the streamer's best movies available right now, whether you're into explosive action, witty humor, or anything else.

Windows 10 user activity logs are sent to Microsoft despite users opting out

Windows 10 Privacy settings may not be enough to stop PCs from releasing user activity data to Microsoft. Users discovered that opting out of having their data sent to Microsoft does little to prevent it from being released.

Intel's discrete graphics will be called 'Xe,' IGP gets Adapative Sync next year

Intel has officially dubbed its discrete graphics product Intel Xe, and the company also provided details about its Gen11 IGP. The latter will include adaptive sync support and will arrive in 2019.

Intel answers Qualcomm's new PC processors by pairing Core and Atom in 'Foveros'

Intel has announced a new packaging technology called 'Foveros' that makes it easier for the company to place multiple chips together on one package. That includes chips based on different Intel architectures, like Core and Atom.

Razer’s classic DeathAdder Elite gaming mouse drops to $40 on Amazon

If you're looking to pick up a new gaming mouse for the holidays, Amazon has you covered with this great deal on the classic Razer DeathAdder Elite gaming mouse with customizable buttons, RGB lighting, and a 16,000 DPI optical sensor.

Firefox 64 helps keep your numerous tabs under control

Mozilla officially launched Firefox 64 by placing new features into the laps of its users including new tab management abilities, intelligent suggestions, and a task manager for keeping Firefox's power consumption under control.

Intel's dedicated GPU is not far off -- here's what we know

Did you hear? Intel is working on a dedicated graphics card. It's called Arctic Sound and though we don't know a lot about it, we know that Intel has some ex-AMD Radeon graphics engineers developing it.

Here's our guide to how to charge your laptop using a USB-C cable

Charging via USB-C is a great way to power up your laptop. It only takes one cable and you can use the same one for data as well as power -- perfect for new devices with limited port options.

Apple MacBook Air vs. Microsoft Surface Pro 6

The MacBook Air was updated with more contemporary components and a more modern design, but is that enough to compete with standouts like Microsoft's Surface Pro 6 detachable tablet?

Installing fonts in Windows 10 is quick and easy -- just follow these steps

Want to know how to install fonts in Windows 10? Here's our guide on two easy ways to get the job done, no matter how many you want to add to your existing catalog, plus instructions for deleting fonts.

Email take-backsies! Gmail's unsend feature is one of its best

Everyone has sent a message they wish they could take back. How great would it be if you could undo that impulsive email? If you're a Gmail user, you can. Here's how to recall an email in Gmail.

These laptop makers produce the most reliable, quality hardware today

If you want to buy your next laptop based around a specific brand, it helps to know which the best brands of laptops are. This list will give you a good grounding in the most reliable, quality laptop manufacturers today.

Here's why 64-bit (not 32-bit) dominates modern computing

Today's computing world isn't the same as it once was. With 64-bit processors and operating systems replacing the older 32-bit designs, we look at what 32-bit vs. 64-bit really means for you.