Ballmer’s out. Now who’s in, and how are they going to fix Microsoft?

steve ballmer steps down can microsoft now step up oped header

Friday’s news from Microsoft announcing Steve Ballmer’s retirement as CEO was certainly a whopper. A Ballmer-less Microsoft is hard to believe, if for no other reason than the CEO’s strange force of personality. No matter the pitfall or setback, he has always responded with determination, leaving us to wonder if anything short of the apocalypse could oust him.

Then, out of nowhere, he goes and announces his plans to step down as CEO within the next 12 months. While Ballmer may not have earned as much respect as Bill Gates, his 13-year tenure is impressive, his departure leaves a massive power vacuum and will force Microsoft to find a new face for the company. Is this a good omen, or is the captain abandoning his sinking ship?

Ballmer’s troubled legacy

News of the departure saw an immediate positive response from Wall Street, spurring Microsoft’s stock to rise 9 percent in pre-market trading before leveling out around a 6 percent gain in the morning. Though stockholders should hardly be considered tech gurus, their response sends an obvious message: they didn’t like Steve Ballmer.

Let’s address the obvious rumor first: Bill Gates is not going to return.

And who can blame them? Named CEO in 2000, Ballmer shared power with Bill Gates until 2008 when Gates finally stepped entirely out of day-to-day operations. Microsoft’s existence since then has been difficult, to say the least. Besides missing out on both smartphones and tablets, the company failed to make progress with Zune before the MP3 market died out, botched the transition to touch with Windows 8, mangled the messaging of the Xbox One, and struggled to become the dominant player in cloud services. Perhaps the only thing that went well was the launch of Windows 7, a project already well underway before Gates left the building.

Determining the exact reason why Ballmer so thoroughly stumbled is difficult. He’s a tight-lipped leader, and when he does speak out, though famous for his outbursts of enthusiasm at company keynotes, his words are sometimes hard to follow and seem out of touch with the industry. Perhaps the problem is a simple lack of direction. He knows how to promote and sell Microsoft products, but that’s a lot different from leading the development of new ones.

Why now?

The list of botched projects under Ballmer’s reign is large, yet such issues are nothing new. Having had full control for six of his 13 years as CEO, Ballmer’s attitude and capabilities shouldn’t have proven a surprise to Microsoft’s board. Fans of Microsoft products adopted a sort of embittered attitude years ago as they realized Microsoft’s unwillingness to respond to criticism. Is everyone on the board oblivious to the company’s woes?

Is this a good omen, or is the captain abandoning his sinking ship?

Maybe. Bill Gates sits on the board as chairman and undoubtedly greatly sways its opinions, which makes his recent comments worrying. As recently as May of this year, Gates said that iPad and Android users are frustrated because they “can’t type, can’t create documents, they don’t have Office there.” There’s every reason to think Gates doesn’t understand why tablets have caught on, and there’s on question that his say has a huge influence on Microsoft’s board of directors.

Besides Gates, the board also includes Ballmer himself, the heads and former heads of several banks and capital groups, the president and CEO of hardware manufacturer Seagate, the CEO of Virtual Instruments, and a college president. This is not the kind of crew that’s going to turn the ship around and sail for new waters, so while the board may understand Microsoft has its share of challenge, they also probably take comfort in the company’s consistent profitability and see no reason to take risks.


Ballmer stated in an interview with ZDNet that leaving was his own decision, and there’s little reason to doubt what he says. Later in the same interview, he goes on to state “we have kicked off…a new wave.” In other words, Microsoft’s reorganization is part of a new leadership paradigm. Ballmer helped put together the company’s new structure, but that structure may not have been designed to have him at the head. In a sense, he seems to be working on his legacy; if the restructure works, some of the criticism directed at him might be relieved.

Who might be next?

The exciting news is not Ballmer’s retirement, but that Microsoft will have a new CEO in 12 months or less. Whoever steps into the position will be faced with an immense challenge, but will also have at his or her disposal a massively profitable corporation with impressive R&D resources. The right person could turn the company back into a force to be reckoned with.

On paper, Microsoft seems to be filled with strong choices for a replacement.

Let’s address the obvious rumor first: Bill Gates is not going to return. He is very involved in his charity and even blasted Google in a recent interview, saying the company’s efforts to bring Wi-Fi to the third world “are not going to uplift the poor.” Gates retired because he felt a different calling, and whatever influence he desires can be exercised through his role as chairman of Microsoft’s board.

Julie Larson-Green, current Executive Vice President and head of Devices and Studios, could be a good pick. She campaigned for the ribbon interface that made its way to Office 2007 and lead planning for Windows 7, giving her an excellent recent track record. Larson-Green also has a background in programming, holds a Master’s degree in software engineering, and started at Microsoft by helping with development of Visual C++.

Another strong candidate is Satya Nadella, Executive Vice President and leader of the Cloud and Enterprise group. Cloud services are very important to Microsoft’s long-term success, and Nadella, like Larson-Green, has plenty of real-world experience to back up his management credentials. The Wall Street Journal says Ballmer may be pointing at Nadella as his chosen successor.

While this pair has the strongest credentials and share long ties with Microsoft, all of the company’s Executive Vice Presidents have extensive experience, making them potential (if less likely) candidates. And there’s the possibility of new blood coming to the business. Choosing a new CEO from outside the company would seem out of character for Microsoft’s conservative board, but a convincing personality gunning for the top spot might be able to argue an outsider’s perspective is needed.

The future just became brighter

Business Insider’s Jay Yarow, in a contrarian take on Ballmer’s departure, stated “Before investors get too excited however, they should realize that Microsoft’s board isn’t changing.” In other words, replacing the CEO may not matter if the same board is in charge of selecting a new candidate.

The exciting news is not Ballmer’s retirement, but that Microsoft will have a new CEO in 12 months or less.

Yarow has a point, but I think he underestimates the talent currently inside Microsoft. Ballmer always felt like a strange choice because, while he’d been with the company for decades, he lacked any engineering expertise. Both top choices within the company, Larson-Green and Nadella, do not share that flaw.

Even a somewhat less experienced pick, like Terry Myerson, current head of Operating Systems, and former head of Windows Phone, is more familiar with managing a team of engineers. How a person will perform as CEO is hard to predict before he or she steps into that role. On paper, Microsoft seems to be filled with strong choices.

There is always the possibility that Microsoft’s board will botch the job entirely and pick someone else with credentials that lean towards sales rather than engineering. But Gates, who will have substantial say in choosing a successor, probably won’t let the board make the same mistake twice. 

(Image Credit: Jesus Gorrti/Wikimedia Commons)

Product Review

Can the Samsung Space Monitor save you from your cluttered desk?

High-concept monitors can sometimes over-complicate thing. Samsung's Space Monitor, however, tries to fix that problem by lifting the monitor off and away from your desk.

Amazon drops killer deals on certified refurbished MacBook Pros for today only

Amazon is offering discounts of up to $320 off on four refurbished 2018 MacBook Pros as part of its current Deal of the Day promotion. Interested customers can snag two different MacBook Pros with 256GB of SSD storage for $1,330 each.

The Dell XPS 13 headlines the best laptop deals for May 2019

Whether you need a new laptop for school or work or you're just doing some post-holiday shopping, we have you covered: These are the best laptop deals going right now, from discounted MacBooks to on-the-go gaming PCs.

HP drops killer deals on laptops with up to $1,300 off for Memorial Day Weekend

HP is currently dropping prices on Spectre x360, Envy, Pavilion, and Omen laptops during its Memorial Day event. So if you're in dire need of a new laptop, the latest holiday savings may be exactly what you're looking for.

Keep your kids safe online with these great parental control tools

The internet can be a dangerous place, especially for your loved ones. Check out our selection of the best free parental control software for Windows and MacOS, so you can monitor your child and block unsavory sites.

These external drives have speed, durability, and storage space to spare

Whether you want an external storage drive that is fast, portable, or comes with a ton of storage, these are the best external hard drives available today. They all come with great features and competitive pricing.

Best Memorial Day sales 2019: Amazon, Best Buy, and Walmart drop discounts

If you're looking to save big on some shiny new stuff for Memorial Day 2019, we've gathered everything you need to know into one place. Find out where to save the most money before the summer hits its stride.

The 2019 ThinkPad lineup is robust. Here's how to pick the right one for you

Be it the X series, the T series, E series, it can be tough to find the best Lenovo laptop that is right for you. To help, we'll break down all the options available to make your choice a more informed one.

Here’s how to watch AMD reveal its new Ryzen chips at Computex

AMD will be holding a pre-Computex keynote on May 27 to announce its new line of 3rd-generation Ryzen processors and accompanying Radeon Navi graphics cards. Here's how to watch the keynote live wherever you are in the world.

Should you buy a MacBook Pro or a Razer Blade Stealth? We'll help you decide

Laptop head to heads are a great way to see which one might be the right one for you. Our latest sees the Razer Blade Stealth (2019) vs. MacBook Pro in a fight to see which one deserves to be your next laptop.

AMD's latest Navi graphics cards are incoming. Here's what to expect

AMD's Navi graphics cards could be available as soon as July 2019 — as long as it's not delayed by stock problems. Billed as a successor to Polaris, Navi promises to deliver better performance to consoles like Sony's PlayStation 5.

Ryzen 3000 chips will pack a punch, and could be launched as early as July

AMD's upcoming Ryzen 3000 generation of CPUs could be the most powerful processors we've ever seen, with higher core counts, greater clock speeds, and competitive pricing. Here's what we know so far.

Want to watch Netflix in bed or browse the web? We have a tablet for everyone

There’s so much choice when shopping for a new tablet that it can be hard to pick the right one. From iPads to Android, these are our picks for the best tablets you can buy right now whatever your budget.

The best Amazon Prime Day 2019 deals: Everything you need to know

Amazon Prime Day 2019 is still a few months off, but it's never too early to start preparing. We've been taking a look at the best discounts from previous Prime Days to give you our predictions of what to expect this year.