Skip to main content

How the Heartbleed bug works, as explained by a Web comic

Sometimes, the easiest way to explain a concept to someone is with the use of illustrations, or cartoons. Xkcd.com attempts to do just that with this simple comic, where it tells a short story of a hacker talking to a server, who uses the Heartbleed exploit to trick the server into leaking more information it’s supposed to, until it begins to divulges sensitive data.

First, check the comic out below.

heartbleed_explanation
Image used with permission by copyright holder

First the girl asks the server to indicate whether it’s still online by telling it to say “Potato,” and indicates the length of the word. The server responds with “Potato,” while withholding all of the information surrounding “Potato,” written out in a lighter hue in the server’s speech bubbles. The hacker then asks the server to repeat the same task, but instead replaces “Potato” with “Bird,” and indicates the length of the word. The server complies.

Recommended Videos

Then, the hacker asks the server to say “Hat,” but instead of noting that it’s a three-character word, she states that it’s 500 letters long. The server responds not only by saying “Hat,” but also by leaking out the information around the word. By doing so, it reveals sensitive server information, including a “master key,” which the hacker begins to jot down.

This is a basic explanation of how the Heartbleed bug works. The Heartbleed bug is a flaw in the OpenSSL method of data encryption used by many of the world’s websites, which was actually put into the code accidentally by a programmer roughly two years ago.

OpenSSL contains a function known as a heartbeat option. With it, while a person is visiting a website that encrypts data using OpenSSL, his computer periodically sends and receives messages to check whether both his PC and the server on the other end are both still connected. The Heartbleed bug allows hackers to send trick heartbeat messages, like the one pictured in the comic above, which can fool a site’s server into relaying data that’s stored in its RAM — including sensitive information such as usernames, passwords, credit card numbers, emails, and more. This is the part of the flaw that the Xkcd comic illustrates.

What do you think? Sound off in the comments below.

Konrad Krawczyk
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Konrad covers desktops, laptops, tablets, sports tech and subjects in between for Digital Trends. Prior to joining DT, he…
6 security settings I always change on a new Windows PC
The Windows Security app in Windows 11.

It's tempting to jump straight into personalizing a new Windows 11 PC — apps, wallpaper, the works. I've been there. There's just something about tweaking a new machine that makes it feel like yours. But before the fun starts, I always take some time to lock down the security settings. It's a small effort that pays off with peace of mind, especially with so many online threats lurking out there. After all, nothing kills the excitement of a new PC faster than running into a virus or security scare.

Here are the settings I change every time I get a new Windows 11 PC — and why they matter.

Read more
It’s not your imagination — ChatGPT models actually do hallucinate more now
Deep Research option for ChatGPT.

OpenAI released a paper last week detailing various internal tests and findings about its o3 and o4-mini models. The main differences between these newer models and the first versions of ChatGPT we saw in 2023 are their advanced reasoning and multimodal capabilities. o3 and o4-mini can generate images, search the web, automate tasks, remember old conversations, and solve complex problems. However, it seems these improvements have also brought unexpected side effects.

What do the tests say?

Read more
Ray-Ban Meta Glasses are my favorite AI gadget, and they keep getting better
Ray-Ban Meta Glasses worn by Prakhar Khanna.

Meta announced its Ray-Ban AI Glasses in October 2023, and while the company hasn’t launched a successor yet, it has steadily expanded the feature set, turning them into my favorite AI gadget. These are all quality-of-life upgrades that would ideally be released with the next-gen product. But Meta has announced the expansion of Ray-Ban Meta Glasses to more regions and new Meta AI features rolling out starting this week.

I bought a pair of Headliner Meta Ray-Bans in January 2024, and they’ve been my travel companion ever since. It's not because I can record videos while on the go, but because they are the first AI device that doesn’t scream AI. The ambient presence of tech is what makes them special, and they’re only improving, even after 18 months since launch.

Read more