Five generations of Intel HD Graphics tested

three generations intel hd graphics tested gaming feat

Intel’s introduction of the first modern Core processor in 2008 was a major change in direction, and not just because of its break away from the Netburst architecture which powered Pentium 4. The company also made a pledge to take graphics performance seriously, and it made good on that promise. When the first Intel HD Graphics showed up in 2010 alongside the new Core mobile chips, it more than doubled performance over the preceding Intel Graphics Media Accelerator.

Six years later, Intel’s crusade for improved integrated graphics continues. Each new generation of Core brings a much bigger boost in graphics performance than per-core processor performance. But these impressive gains have occurred in the face of more demanding games and ever increasing display resolution. Over the past six years, laptops have leaped from a typical resolution of 1,024 x 768 to 1080p — and premium models even push 4K.

To find out what this means for real-world performance, we rounded up ten different versions of Intel HD graphics spanning five generations listed from oldest to newest: HD 4000, 4200, 4600, 5500, 6000, HD 520, HD 530, HD 540, HD 620, and UHD 620. How far has Intel come? And how far does it have left to go?

The hardware

We used a variety of hardware to perform this test. A MacBook Air running Boot Camp with fully updated Intel graphics drivers served as our stand-in for third-generation Core processors with Intel HD 4000.

Intel NUC Core i5 NUCi5RYK mini PC review scale hand
Bill Roberson/Digital Trends

Next up we have the fourth-generation chips, represented by the Acer Aspire Switch 11 and Zotac Zbox Oi520, which offer Intel HD 4200 and 4400, respectively. The latter is particularly important, as it’s the most common IGP from the outgoing family. Most Intel-powered notebooks sold over the last year have an HD 4400 inside.

Dell’s XPS 13 (2015) and Intel’s NUC with Core i5 processor, with HD 5500 and HD 6000, respectively, carry the banner for the fifth generation. Aside from the Iris 6100, which is not a common choice, HD 6000 is the quickest graphics solution currently available with Core processors.

Futuremark’s 3DMark provides a generalized look at performance that usually translates well to real-world games.

HD 520 was tested in an i7 Surface Book with the dedicated GPU turned off. There’s also Intel HD 530, which we tested in the Core i7-6700K desktop processor. Despite the removal of a numerical from the name, HD 530 is meant to be a new mid-tier integrated graphics option for desktop chips. HD 540 was with another Dell XPS 13 with a Core i7-6560U processor.

Microsoft’s Surface Pro was used to test Intel HD 620 graphics. Dell yet again arrived to represent, as the 2018 redesign of the Dell XPS 13, with Core i5-8200U processor, was used to test Intel UHD 620.

Obviously, it’s impossible to conduct an absolute apples-to-apples test. Intel integrated graphics is updated on a generational basis, so newer and faster processors are paired with newer and faster graphics. Newer devices will also have more RAM and faster hard drives, too. Still, these tests offer insight into how Intel HD graphics has progressed over time.

3DMark

Futuremark’s 3DMark is the industry standard among graphics benchmarks, and it provides a generalized look at performance that usually translates well to real-world games. It’s a good test for how determining how much Intel has matured over the years.

These results show how much Intel HD Graphics has improved over the years. The Cloud Gate score has more than doubled from HD 4000 to the newest mid-range solution, UHD 620. And that arguably undersells the improvement, because UHD 620 offers support for new graphics APIs like DirectX 12.

At the same time, though, Intel’s UHD 620 is a bit disappointing. Previous leaps to new hardware saw significant increases of around 20 or 30 percent. UHD 620, however, is basically identical to HD 620. Note also that HD 620 arrived in 2016. From a performance perspective, Intel’s HD Graphics has made little progress over the last two years.

Intel does have the G-Series processors, which bundle AMD’s Radeon Vega graphics with an Intel processor. We didn’t include them in the chart above because they absolutely smash Intel HD — and would render the graph near unreadable. The G-Series chips are only available in a small handful of of devices like the Dell XPS 15 2-in-1, however, and they do no favors for battery life.

World of Warcraft

World of Warcraft: Legion
Blizzard Entertainment

Blizzard’s famous massively multiplayer game is over 10 years old, but it’s not a cinch for modern hardware to handle. The game has been updated significantly over the years with new areas, new textures and, most recently, new character models. There’s also been a general increase of stuff in the game, from foliage to particle effects to larger areas. Can today’s Intel HD hardware handle this evolving title?

World of Warcraft doesn’t fair so well on older Intel HD graphics. Intel HD 4400 and HD 5500, two very common solutions in ultrabooks from the prior generation, struggle to provide an enjoyable experience when detail is increased beyond low. The least powerful version of Intel HD we’ve tested, the HD 4200, can only handle the game at 1,366 x 768 resolution and low detail.

Intel HD 520 can play the game at 1,366 x 768 and high detail. HD 530 and 540 tack a few extra frames on to that performance, and come close to — but don’t quite manage to — to reach an average of 30 FPS at 1080p and high detail.  HD 530 and HD 540 are neck-and-neck here, while the desktop HD 530 IGP had an edge over the mobile HD 540 in 3DMark.

Upgrading another generation to Intel HD 620 and UHD 620 provides another big buff to performance. The average framerate finally exceeds 30 FPS at 1080p resolution with detail settings at high, which means it’s playable, though only just. We still noticed a lot of momentary hesitation which, we suspect, is due to the lack of dedicated video memory. A game like World of Warcraft often needs to load new assets as you explore its large game world.

Battlefield 4

battlefield 4 screenshot 13

Battlefield 4 isn’t the latest shooter from DICE, but we decided to kept it as a test benchmark so we didn’t have to throw out results from older devices. And while this isn’t the most recent game, it does run the same basic Frostbyte engine as Battlefield 1 and the new Star Wars Battlefront games.

The difference between generations in this game is incredible. A few years ago, in the HD 4000 and HD 4400 generation, Battlefield 4 was utterly hopeless. It would not play even at 1,366 x 768 resolution with detail wound all the way down.

The Intel HD 5500 and 6000 series changed that, to an extent. It at least improved performance to a level that was vaguely playable, albeit at a low resolution. Most gamers would not be happy with the experience. But if you didn’t have anything else to play Battlefield 4 on, you could manage it. Kinda.

Intel HD 500 takes the game a step further. HD 530 and HD 540, in particular, raise the bar. The HD 530 comes close to 30 FPS at 1080p resolution and low detail. HD 540 exceeds that, and also makes 1,366 x 768 at High detail playable, if only just.

The latest generation, Intel HD 620 and UHD 620, once again up performance significantly. They don’t quite beat HD 540, but that’s not a fair comparison, because HD 620 is a mainstream solution meant to replace HD 520. And HD 620 is much quicker than its predecessor, improving performance by at least 50 percent across the board. Battlefield 4 can flirt with a consistent 30 FPS at 1080p resolution and low detail, though it does land just shy of that mark.

Conclusion

Our tests make it clear that Intel’s HD Graphics has improved greatly over the years. A modern system with UHD 620 graphics is more than twice as quick in games as an Intel HD 4000 laptop. Games that seem impossible to play on that older system may be enjoyable on a modern laptop with UHD 620.

You can expect a new flagship smartphone or tablet to handle any available game with ease, but you can’t expect the same of most laptops.

Yet we kept can’t but feel a bit disappointed. We’ve kept the roster of tests in this article the same for years, so we could offer a baseline of comparison. Despite that, World of Warcraft and Battlefield 4 remain enjoyable only with significant compromise. These aren’t new games, yet you can’t expect to install them and automatically see smooth gameplay on Intel HD Graphics. Some tweaks are required, and you may have to downgrade the resolution below 1080p.

Lackluster integrated graphics performance remains a big problem for Intel. You can expect a new flagship smartphone or tablet to handle any available game with ease, but you can’t expect the same of most laptops. There’s a clear gap between what people experience on mobile and what they experience on a PC.

Intel seems to be working on a solution. It hired Raja Koduri, AMD’s graphics chief, in 2018. He’s working on a graphics solution that’s expected to arrive in 2020. Until then, though, most people will continue to struggle on with HD Graphics. Here’s hoping a better default option is just around the corner.

Computing

We tested Nvidia’s RTX 2080 and 2080 Ti. Are they a worthy upgrade?

We finally have Nvidia's newest graphics cards, the RTX 2080 and 2080 Ti, and put them through our standard suite of benchmarks and game tests to see how they performed in a standard play of Battlefield 1 and Fornite. How do they compare to…
Computing

Nvidia's new GPUs are all about ray tracing. Here's why that matters

Nvidia's new GTX 2000 series graphics cards bring Ray Tracing technology to modern real-time 3D graphics, including games, for the first time. But what is ray tracing, and what does it mean for your games?
Computing

Here are all the games that support Nvidia’s RTX ray tracing

These are the upcoming games that support ray tracing rendered on Nvidia's RTX series graphics cards. They aren't many in number at this point, but thanks to the power of ray tracing, they are some of the best looking games ever made.
Computing

No games will support ray tracing when Nvidia RTX graphics cards launch

Nvidia's new RTX graphics cards won't have much use for those RT cores on launch day, as no games will support ray tracing for at least a month after they officially start shipping out to consumers.
News

Winamp media player might be back from the dead, with Windows 10 support

Winamp might be back from the dead, and it's bringing support for Microsoft Windows 10 with the first new software release since its acquisition by Radionomy in 2014. Fans of the media player will also enjoy new features and bug fixes.
Computing

Photoshop isn't required to resize images. Here are 6 ways to do it in seconds

Resizing an image isn't the toughest thing in the world, even if it may seem like a hassle. Here's how to resize an image using six tools that allow you to make quick work of any photo, regardless of your operating system.
Product Review

Canon Pixma Pro-10 review

If you plan to put those digital high-resolution images you’ve shot with a DSLR onto paper, Canon’s Pixma Pro-10 will deliver gallery-quality prints. Just don’t expect it to be speedy.
Computing

Heavily overclocked RTX 2080 Ti steals every 3DMark record

Nvidia's RTX 2080 Ti is already the most powerful graphics card ever released, but with liquid nitrogen cooling overclocker Kingpin was able to push the card to new heights and break a bunch of records in the process.
Computing

Chromebook keyboard showcase may have leaked Pixelbook 2 images

As we approach Google's #madebygoogle event taking place in early October, new rumors and leaks for a possible Pixelbook 2 are appearing online. This latest one may show what the rumored Nocturne design will look like.
Virtual Reality

Walmart stocks its stores with VR training for its employees

Walmart will begin rolling out virtual reality training experiences to all of its stores this year with the power of Oculus Go. More than 6,300 stores will receive the new technology, helping the company train its employees.
Computing

Tap Strap wearable keyboard gains support for VR applications

TAP System's wearable keyboard gains support for virtual reality, now compatible with Windows Mixed Reality, Oculus Rift, and HTV headsets. Type and tap for up to eight hours in VR without needing to look at a physical keyboard.
Computing

Wi-Fi vulnerability could allow attackers to steal your data on unencrypted sites

A 20-year-old security flaw in the design of the Wi-Fi standard and how computers communicate using the transmission control protocol could allow hackers to perform a web cache poisoning attack to steal your data and login information.
Deals

Walmart takes $380 off the MacBook Air for a limited time

Walmart is offering a steep discount on the MacBook Air. Though the $380 discount is lovely, this offer comes with an extra charger to sweeten the deal. If you're looking to pick up an Apple MacBook for less, now is an excellent time.
Computing

PDF to JPG conversion is quick and easy using these simple methods

Converting file formats can be an absolute pain, but it doesn't have to be. We've put together a comprehensive guide on how to convert a PDF to JPG, no matter which operating system you're running.