Skip to main content

Windows 10X will have two File Explorers, and that’s a problem

Yup, you read that right. When you someday go to save, open, or locate a file on your beautiful new Surface Neo, you may encounter one of two filing systems. One is more touch-friendly, and the other is the classic File Explorer you know and love.

Microsoft has good reason for stitching together this Frankenstein monster of an app solution. It’s determined to not repeat the same mistakes of its past. Unfortunately, when it comes to the experience of using the device, it feels jumbled together.

Microsoft’s File Explorer faces a familiar problem

Windows has always been an open platform. It’s part of what made the Windows app ecosystem so rich over the years. It is also what made Microsoft’s leap into the modern world so difficult.

Windows 10X is Microsoft’s latest attempt at moving ahead. This time, it’s taking a more measured approach. Rather than limiting access to older applications, Microsoft is embracing them all — regardless of the platform. Web, Win32, and UWP will all stand on equal footing in 10X.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Microsoft has a long and complicated way of making these various ecosystems work together, which brings us to the twin File Explorers. To accommodate Win32 apps, Microsoft needed to keep the old File Explorer to ensure legacy apps play nice with the rest of the operating system. On the other hand, Microsoft wants a modern File Explorer for use with UWP apps.

The compromise is two different File Explorers that work together, but aren’t unified. The classic File Explorer is only called upon when absolutely necessary, thankfully. Microsoft has declined to comment on what other applications and functions might require such a compromise.

It’s the Settings interface all over again

Seeing the old File Explorer next to the new one should seem familiar. It’s not dissimilar to how Windows 10 treats certain settings.

On the surface, Settings looks sleek, modern, and minimal, providing just enough information for users. Dig too deep, though, and your operating system will feel like it  time-traveled from the past. At its worse, you’ll find two ways of accomplishing the same thing, such as setting up a VPN.

This strange approach is the safest thing Microsoft could do, as it supports both future and legacy apps. Given the company’s troubled history in this regard, I don’t blame them. Twin File Explorers was the only way to bring in Win32 apps. And users — particularly large companies and organizations — absolutely demand Win32 support.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Google attempted a similar approach, bringing Android apps over to Chromebooks. They work (usually), but it ain’t pretty. The stitches between the worlds of mobile and desktop computing have never been more visible.

Microsoft’s solution seems more elegant, if only because of what it’s learned from the past. Whether it’s Windows RT, Windows 10 S, or the Surface Pro X, all attempts to restrict older applications that aren’t as friendly to modern chip architecture and touchscreens have been failures. Convincing Windows users and developers to drop their beloved Win32 apps was something Microsoft still struggles with today.

So far, Windows 10X feels like Microsoft waving its white flag and calling both sides to a draw. In the end, it might be a necessary step toward some kind of a future. But for now, it could make for a very disjointed experience.

Editors' Recommendations

Luke Larsen
Senior Editor, Computing
Luke Larsen is the Senior editor of computing, managing all content covering laptops, monitors, PC hardware, Macs, and more.
Windows 10X has reportedly been pushed back to later in 2021
Windows 10X

Microsoft's upcoming Windows 10X operating system for education and enterprise PCs could be seeing yet another delay. After rumors indicated a launch catered toward single-screen devices could come as soon as this spring, it's now looking as though Microsoft might not be ready to release it until the second half of 2021.

Citing internal sources at Microsoft, Windows Central's Zac Bowden believes that the company wants to push Windows 10X back to "ensure the product is ready and robust for a smooth release." Despite leaked builds of the operating system recently spreading online, it looks as though Microsoft wants to spend more time ironing out bugs and other issues before making anything official. Bowden also says the company wasn't able to sign off on a final "shipping build" of the OS back in December.

Read more
Windows 10X, the revolutionary new version of Windows, could be coming in March
Windows 10 Surface Pro 4 stock photo

Windows 10X, which comes with many new features like an improved tablet mode, modern File Explorer, keyboard, Start Menu, and Action Center could be coming in March. That's according to the prominent and reliable Microsoft leaker  who on February 25 tweeted and appeared to refer to the operating system as "The New Windows" coming next month."

Read more
The next version of Windows 10 might have Parallax 3D effects on the lock screen
windows 10 getting parallax 3d lock screen

Microsoft could be working to bring a new feel to the Windows lock screen in the next version of Windows 10. In the first major change to the lock screen since Windows 8, it is rumored to be getting support for "Parallax" 3D effects, according to a report from Windows Latest.

What this means is that the Windows lock screen could have a similar "Perspective Zoom" movement that Apple has implemented on the home screen and lock screen in iOS and iPadOS. This is where, as you rotate your device, the lock screen will respond to your movements with tilt or pan effects. The feature could be powered by accelerometers already found on board tablets like Microsoft's Surface Pro, or other 2-in-1s like the HP Spectre x360.

Read more