Fighting fraud with fractions: New algorithm weeds out fake product reviews automatically

michelle bachmann fraudulent amazon product review

How often do you check the comments and number of stars a product has received prior to purchasing a service or product?

If you’re like most of us, the answer is nearly always. On the Web, positive or negative product reviews will often be the deal breaker — or maker — for potential customers. Which also makes faking them big business. To combat the growing market for fraudulent user reviews, researchers at the University of Illinois at Chicago with the backing of Google have developed an algorithm, dubbed GSRank, for weeding out fraudulent reviews.

Novice fraudulent reviews are easy to catch — reviewers will create a new account specifically to vilify or praise a single product. More complex operations use multiple accounts working in tandem to review multiple products. Yet this collaborative effort is what allows the algorithm to identify the fraudulent reviewers.

Looking at groups of reviews turns out to be the key. When a competitor intends to slander a rival, it’s likely that the fraudulent reviews will come from a group of multiple accounts, called “spammer groups.” The same grouping patterns appear in fraudulent “good” reviews meant to bolster the profile and desirability of a company’s own product.

Drilling down further, the researchers found eight signals for false reviews, which serve as the foundation for the algorithm that ultimately flags the fraudulent reviews. They are:

1. Group Time Window – A spam group will tend to publish its reviews within a short window of time.

2. Group Deviation – Reviews that deviate significantly from the others on a product may have a higher probability of being fake. 

3. Group Content Similarity – Whether you’d call it lazy or not, spammers will copy reviews from within their own spam group. After all, there isn’t much money to be made in a single review, and spending time on a single review is money that could have been made elsewhere.

4. Group Member Content Similarity – Like Group Content Similarity, a single reviewer may save time by reusing, with slight edits, a review for a similar product.

5. Group Early Time Frame – The earliest reviews will tend to have the biggest effect on swaying the decisions of potential customers. Accordingly, companies are inclined to hire spammers early in the product’s existence, so fraudulent reviews will typically be among the first to review the product or service.

6. Group Size Ratio – The size of a spam group with respect to the total number of reviewers will also be a sign of spammers.

7. Group Size – The larger the spam group’s size, the more damaging the reviews will be. The chances that the reviews will be submitted at the same time will also be slimmer. Larger spam groups are more inclined to intentionally time the review’s post, or if reviewers in spam groups have been selected individually, a post will be unlikely to be published at the same time.

8. Group Support Count – A group of potentially fraudulent accounts is far more likely to have reviewed the same products than a group of genuine accounts.

So far, the research, mining and manual detection of false reviews has been a laborious and expensive process. With the introduction of the researcher’s GSRank algorithm, the process can be mostly automated. Companies trying to work the system now have a formidable hurdle.

Product Review

For picture quality on a budget, Vizio's new P-Series is absolutely unbeatable

Vizio’s P-Series TV line has always been the best among the brand’s long run of budget-friendly TVs, but this year’s model has really stepped up. While the competition is also improving, Vizio’s latest P-Series keeps the brand among…

Your PlayStation 4 game library isn't complete without these games

Looking for the best PS4 games out there? Out of the massive crop of titles available, we selected the best you should buy. No matter what your genre of choice may be, there's something here for you.
Home Theater

How to buy speakers: A beginner’s guide to home audio

From the difference between bookshelf speakers and monitors to the proper way to audition, our ultimate speaker buying guide has all the information you need to create your own home audio nirvana.
Smart Home

Amazon has an even dozen new smart devices. Here’s how to order

Amazon's hardware announcement meant a whole bunch of new Amazon Alexa gadgets. From a microwave to stereo equipment, here is the complete list of devices that were announced, as well as reviews for some.
Emerging Tech

Healthy mice born from two genetic mothers using stem cells, gene editing

Healthy mice have been born from two genetics mothers and later went on to bear healthy offspring of their own, according to a recent paper published by researchers at the Chinese Academy of Sciences.
Emerging Tech

Japanese scientists are chewing over an ‘electric gum’ that never loses flavor

Researchers at Japan's Meiji University may have found the secret to unlimited chewing gum -- and it just involves zapping your tongue with electricity. Here's what makes it all work.
Emerging Tech

Light-swallowing room promises Call of Duty fans the blackest of ops

What's it like to be in a room fully painted with the world's darkest material, Vantablack? The makers of one of the year's top video games teamed up with Vantablack scientists to find out.
Smart Home

Vector, the engaging Alexa-like robot, is ready to roam around your home

Anyone who has ever watched Short Circuit or WALL-E has surely dreamed about having a robot buddy come live with them. Finally, that dream is now a reality. It's name is Vector, and it's available now.
Emerging Tech

Ekster 3.0 lets you ask, ‘Alexa, where did I leave my wallet?’

Ekster's newest smart wallet is its best yet. It's slimmer than ever, boasts a neat card-dispensing mechanism, and will even let you know where it is, thanks to smart speaker integration.
Emerging Tech

Johns Hopkins’ lab-grown human retina could lead to big insights

Scientists from Johns Hopkins University have successfully grown human retina tissue from scratch in a lab. The work could help with the development of new therapeutics related to eye diseases.

Skydio’s self-flying drone now has an Apple Watch app for flight prep

Skydio's clever R1 autonomous drone now has its own Apple Watch app, making flight preparations simpler than ever. The $2,000 flying machine is now also selling at its first retail outlet — Apple Stores in North America.
Emerging Tech

Are e-cigarettes safe? Here’s what the most recent science says

Ecigarettes are widely regarded and advertised as a healthier alternative to cigarettes for people who are trying to kick the smoking habit. How safe are these cigarette alternatives? We went deep into the recent scientific literature to…
Emerging Tech

Scientists created a condom that self-lubricates during sex. You’re welcome

Researchers from Boston University have invented a special coating for condoms which make them respond to bodily fluids by becoming more slippery. Here's how their new breakthrough works.
Emerging Tech

You’re so vein: Palm-based biometric system could help confirm your identity

Move over, Face ID! The next biometric security systems could rely on analyzing the unique vein patterns in your palm print. Here are some of the ways the technology could prove useful.