Injustice! FAA crackdown on beer-delivery drone may be based on hot air

injustice faa crack beer delivery drone may based hot air lakemaid drones fe

Last week, the Federal Aviation Administration jumped into action after Minnesota brewery Lakemaid published a video on YouTube showing the company delivering cases of beer to ice fisherman, and promptly put an end to the futuristic beer run. See, according to the FAA, using a drone for “commercial” purposes (like selling and delivering beer) is against the rules, unless the company has the FAA’s permission … which is nearly impossible to get.

Thing is, the FAA’s rules against unauthorized commercial drone use may not be legal binding – meaning Lakemaid and countless other companies that want to use unmanned aerial vehicles (aka UAVs or drones) as part of their business operations should, theoretically, be able to do so – and the FAA can’t say a dang thing about it.

At least, that’s Washington, DC-based attorney Brendan Schulman’s argument. Schulman is representing Raphael Pirker, an Swiss videographer and major drone enthusiast, who was fined $10,000 by the FAA in 2011 for shooting a video for the University of Virginia using a camera-packing drone.

“The FAA was created to address the problem of airplanes running into each other after two airplanes collided over the Grand Canyon,” Schulman recently told Forbes. “That was the main issue for the FAA: ensuring the safety of people in the air, passenger aircraft, and manned aviation, not the regulation of small unmanned aircraft.”

“The FAA was created to address the problem of airplanes running into each other…”

At present, FAA rules dictate that any company that wants to use drones for commercial purposes obtain a “Certificate of Authorization,” among other restrictions. (Only flying drones below 400 feet and keeping them in the line of sight are the two big ones.) And while universities and police departments can get the needed certificate, private companies are all but shut out; only one company, ConocoPhillips, has obtained a Certificate of Authorization. It may only fly its drone, a Boeing Insitu ScanEagle, to monitor wildlife off the coast of Alaska. Try to fly a drone to make some money, and you could be hit with a cease-and-desist letter from the FAA … or a whopping fine.

Except, Pirker was not fined for flying his drone for commercial purposes, reports Politico. Instead, he was fined for “careless and reckless operation of the unmanned aircraft.” So, while the FAA might have a rule against unapproved commercial drone flight, those rules might not mean much if it comes to a court battle – which is exactly what Schulman is trying to prove. He has already argued his case before the National Transportation Safety Board, and says he expects the judge to dismiss the fine and the legally binding authority of the FAA’s rules along with it. If that happens, it’s possible that Lakemaid can deliver its beer to thirsty ice fisherman in peace.

But something tells us the FAA won’t make it that simple. The agency is currently working hard to clear up the regulations surrounding drones, and establish basic safety measures for pilots and the public, as mandated by a bill passed by Congress in 2012, which requires the FAA open U.S. airspace to commercial drones by September 30, 2015. And it recently announced the opening of six drone test sites around the country to help figure out all the ins and outs of our new drone-filled future.

Should Lakemaid be allowed to make beer deliveries with drones? Let us know your thoughts below.

Emerging Tech

Death from above? How we’re preparing for a future filled with weaponized drones

Drones are beginning to enable everything from search & rescue, to the delivery of medicines to hard-to-reach places. But they are also being used as cheap, and deadly flying bombs. How can we defend ourselves?
Smart Home

If you're not sipping beer while a robot mows your lawn, you're doing it wrong

Imagine watching your lawn being mowed by a robot while you sit on the porch drinking a beer. That’s life with Husqvarna’s line of electric Automowers, which takes the gas and the manpower out of one dreaded aspect of yard work.
Emerging Tech

The best drone photos from around the world

Most of today's drones come equipped with high-end cameras, which are quickly revolutionizing the world of aerial photography as we know it. Here are some of the best drone photos from around the world.
Emerging Tech

This intelligent parachute system can bail out clumsy drone pilots

Parachutes can save drones when they unexpectedly fall from the sky. Among a number of such systems, Austrian firm Drone Rescue is this week showing off its latest design that automatically deploys when it senses trouble.

Skydio’s self-flying drone now has an Apple Watch app for flight prep

Skydio's clever R1 autonomous drone now has its own Apple Watch app, making flight preparations simpler than ever. The $2,000 flying machine is now also selling at its first retail outlet — Apple Stores in North America.
Emerging Tech

Light-swallowing room promises Call of Duty fans the blackest of ops

What's it like to be in a room fully painted with the world's darkest material, Vantablack? The makers of one of the year's top video games teamed up with Vantablack scientists to find out.
Emerging Tech

Scientists created a condom that self-lubricates during sex. You’re welcome

Researchers from Boston University have invented a special coating for condoms which make them respond to bodily fluids by becoming more slippery. Here's how their new breakthrough works.
Emerging Tech

Are e-cigarettes safe? Here’s what the most recent science says

Ecigarettes are widely regarded and advertised as a healthier alternative to cigarettes for people who are trying to kick the smoking habit. How safe are these cigarette alternatives? We went deep into the recent scientific literature to…
Emerging Tech

You’re so vein: Palm-based biometric system could help confirm your identity

Move over, Face ID! The next biometric security systems could rely on analyzing the unique vein patterns in your palm print. Here are some of the ways the technology could prove useful.
Emerging Tech

For only $4,950, you can get jetpack lessons from the world’s only instructor

Have you ever dreamed of flying using a jetpack? JetPack Aviation founder -- and the world's only qualified jetpack teacher -- David Mayman is now offering a day of flight instruction.
Emerging Tech

Biologists have found a hormone that could make space farming possible

Researchers have shown how space farming may be possible. By encouraging plants to excrete a certain hormone, they’ve demonstrated that crops can thrive despite challenging conditions, such as low-nutrient soil and microgravity.
Emerging Tech

Keep your holiday gift list high tech and under budget with these gadgets

Modern technology doesn't always come cheap, but there plenty of premium devices that don't carry a premium price. Whether you're looking for a streaming device or a means of capturing photos from above, our list of the best tech under $50…
Emerging Tech

When tech goes wrong: Banksy’s shredder was meant to totally destroy his artwork

Banksy's recent auction stunt was meant to totally destroy one of his most famous pieces of work, but a fault with the shredder has left the buyer with something almost certainly worth far more than the $1 million she bid for it.
Emerging Tech

A Fitbit for your cat shit: Automatic litter box tracks your kitty’s health

It may look like a sci-fi teleportation chamber, but Footloose is a high-tech litter box that promises to be the most cutting-edge way for your kitty to take a dump. Here's how it works.