Skip to main content

US judge says commercial drones are legal (for now)

samsung may be developing a drone geared toward selfie shooters
Image used with permission by copyright holder

C’mon Jeff, there’s a window of opportunity here, a chance for you to get your Prime Air flying machines off the ground; and what about all those pizza- and beer-carrying drones we’ve been reading about over the past year – this could be their big moment.

Following a legal ruling in the US Thursday, commercial drones can legally buzz around American skies right now. The development is the result of a decision by National Safety Transportation Board judge Patrick Geraghty, who sided with Raphael Pirker in his appeal to overturn a $10,000 fine imposed by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) back in 2011 for flying a drone in a manner that had been deemed dangerous. The 29-year-old Swiss man had been using his unmanned aerial vehicle to film a commercial at the University of Virginia.

His lawyer, Brendan Schulman, argued that an FAA policy notice from 2007 banning commercial drone flights was not legally binding as the administration had never regulated model aircraft, news site Motherboard reported.

Speaking about the case earlier this year, Schulman said the FAA had alleged Pirker was flying his “styrofoam model aircraft” in a built-up area, describing the flight as careless and reckless. However, the lawyer said the FAA had “nothing that specifically addresses model aircraft or commercial drones,” adding, “We think that having the same safety regulations on a model airplane as you have with a large jetliner is inappropriate.”

Happily for Pirker, Judge Geraghty agreed with the essence of Schulman’s argument, dismissing the FAA’s claim of wrongdoing.

The FAA could, in theory, attempt to establish an emergency rule to try to keep commercial drones out of the skies, though it has so far given no indication that it intends to do this.

So, for the time being at least, you’re free to fly your drone and charge a few bucks for some related service, meaning there’s never been a better time for Amazon to trial its Prime Air contraption. Come on, Mr. Bezos, what are you waiting for?

Editors' Recommendations

Trevor Mogg
Contributing Editor
Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…
Watch Amazon’s all-new delivery drone zipping through the sky
watch amazons all new delivery drone zipping through the sky amazon prime air  2019

Amazon Prime Air’s New Delivery Drone

Amazon has taken the wraps off the latest iteration of its Prime Air delivery drone that it says could be delivering online orders to customers’ doors “in the coming months.”

Read more
Alphabet’s Wing drones now have FAA approval to deliver packages in the U.S.
alphabet wing faa us delivery screen shot 2019 04 23 at 17 19 32

Alphabet Wing, the drone delivery startup owned by Google’s parent company, announced that it has become the first company to receive Air Carrier Certification from the United States Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). This lets Wing begin commercial deliveries from local businesses to homes in the U.S. -- including the crucial ability to fly over civilians and beyond the visible line of sight of drone operators.

Operations will start “over the coming weeks” in the Blacksburg and Christiansburg areas of Virginia, where Wing will run a commercial delivery pilot as part of the Integrated Pilot Program (IPP) later in 2019. This means that the U.S. will officially join Canberra, Australia, where Wing already operates a commercial air delivery service. It is also poised to start trials in Europe, delivering to homes in Helsinki, Finland.

Read more
Digital Trends’ Top Tech of CES 2023 Awards
Best of CES 2023 Awards Our Top Tech from the Show Feature

Let there be no doubt: CES isn’t just alive in 2023; it’s thriving. Take one glance at the taxi gridlock outside the Las Vegas Convention Center and it’s evident that two quiet COVID years didn’t kill the world’s desire for an overcrowded in-person tech extravaganza -- they just built up a ravenous demand.

From VR to AI, eVTOLs and QD-OLED, the acronyms were flying and fresh technologies populated every corner of the show floor, and even the parking lot. So naturally, we poked, prodded, and tried on everything we could. They weren’t all revolutionary. But they didn’t have to be. We’ve watched enough waves of “game-changing” technologies that never quite arrive to know that sometimes it’s the little tweaks that really count.

Read more