Snowden wants more security, but are we too lazy for more locks?

snowden live talk privacy impact president trump wants more security
Edward Snowden tells the SXSW 2014 crowd that encryption is the solution to our surveillance woes (Photo: Alfred Lui/Flickr)

At South by Southwest 2014 on Monday, Edward Snowden said the best way – perhaps the only way – to prevent mass government surveillance is through the use of widespread end-to-end encryption. Slamming the door on the NSA with technology, in other words, rather than waiting for the legal process to do it for us.

“The actual collection problem doesn’t seem to be a bottleneck for the NSA, and that’s because the so many of the services that we’re relying on are not secure by default,” explained ACLU Principal Technologist Chris Soghoian, Snowden’s fellow SXSW event speaker. “We need to lock things down,” he said.

He’s right, of course. But with a slew of options for locking things down already available, the bigger issue may simply be getting people to use them. I wonder if words like “privacy” and “encryption” are holding them back more than helping.

There’s Mailvelope browser plugin for encrypted emails,Cloudfogger for securely using Dropbox and other cloud storage services (or SpiderOak if you want to avoid the mainstream cloud options altogether), Cryptocat  and Telegram for secure text messaging through your Web browser or iPhone, and Whisper Systems (which Snowden name-dropped at SXSW) whose RedPhone app for Android enables encrypted calls. Do any of you use any of these? Have you even heard of these? I’d bet hard cash that the percentage of who can say yes is incredibly low.

One problem with these communication services is that they require not just you but everyone you speak with to also use the service, in order for it to be effective. In the case of Cryptocat, which just launched for iPhone last week, for example, there’s often not anyone else to talk to. Not a single one of my friends or family thought Cryptocat was worth the (free) download. And the app currently has just six reviews in the iTunes App Store.

Then there is, of course, TOR – the routing network that encrypts user traffic, bounces it around through a jumble of IP addresses, and makes it extremely difficult (but not impossible) for whomever might be watching you to do so effectively. But as Ben Wizner, Snowden’s attorney and director of the ACLU Speech, Privacy & Technology Project who moderated the Snowden SXSW event, said, “Using Tor … I feel like I need new IT support in my office just to be able to do this work.”

Tor, like so many other encryption services that actually protect privacy and security, is ugly, slow, and thus seems like an unnecessary burden for everyday Web browsing and communications. As Soghoian said, “we should understand that most regular people are not going to go out and download an obscure encryption app. Most people are going to use the tools that they already have. That means that they are going to be using Facebook or Google or Skype.”

We need secure communications tools that pretend to be nothing of the sort.

And the problem with Google and Facebook, says Soghoian, is that both of them are “advertising companies” whose business models are based on collecting user data. If that data is encrypted, neither Google nor the NSA can grab it – and that just ain’t gonna fly, at least not with the way things are.

The solution, Soghoian believes, is to change the business model.

“I think we are slowly getting to the point where telling your customers, ‘Hey, $5 a month for encrypted communications, no one can watch you.’ I think that is something that many consumers may be willing to pay for,” he said.

Perhaps. WhatsApp, with its nearly half-billion users and $19 billion from Facebook, proves that we are willing to pay for services that at least tip their hat to privacy – as long as the price is around $1 per year. WhatsApp also proves that, despite what I found with Cryptocat and similar privacy-focused services, people are willing to switch to closed systems in order to communicate with one another. Were WhatsApp to provide end-to-end encryption then we’d be a whole lot closer to the private future Snowden envisions.

What we are not willing to pay for is privacy alone. We need another reason to use a service besides it being secure. In fact, considering 55 percent of Americans told Washington Post-ABC News pollsters in November that they believe Snowden did the “wrong thing” by exposing the NSA’s dragnet ways, putting surveillance-blocking at the forefront of your marketing message may do more harm than good.

National Security Agency headquarters
NSA Headquarters, Fort Meade, MD

The answer, then, is to build communication services that include privacy features but don’t tout them as the most important thing. We need secure communications tools that pretend to be nothing of the sort.   

For those who care about privacy above all else, that may seem like an idiotic thing to say. But if you’re anything like me, you leave your car doors unlocked when you feel like it’s safe to do so. And you don’t want to actively hide everything you say behind encryption walls when you know you’re not saying anything incriminating. Doing so feels a bit skeevy and odd – illicit in and of itself. And besides, why be more secure than necessary?

Snowden, Soghoian, and the rest of the privacy advocates of this world are right to warn us about the pervasive surveillance of the world’s innocent people. Those of us who hate the idea of being watched by the government for no good reason are rightly upset. And encryption is, I believe, the right way to go about solving our spying woes. But it’s important for the developers who will help solve this problem to remember: For most of us, the reason we don’t take the time to learn how encryption works is because we simply don’t want to think about it at all. 

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.

Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: Halfbikes, VR for all your senses, and more

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it's fun to gawk!

Halo: Reach beta might be delayed, PC version needs more work

Halo: Reach is coming to Halo: The Master Chief Collection this year for both PC and Xbox One players. Invites were expected to go out toward the end of the month, but 343 Industries now says they may be delayed.
Social Media

No more moon showers as Facebook Messenger’s dark mode gets official rollout

Facebook Messenger launched a dark mode last month, but to activate it you had to message the crescent moon to someone. Now it's been rolled out officially, and it can be accessed in a far more sensible way — via settings.
Movies & TV

Best new podcasts for the week of April 6, 2019: Voices of the Movement and more

Feel like you’re drowning in podcasts? In this weekly series, we’ll help you pick out the best of the new and returning shows. This week’s picks include a hunt for a serial killer, cougars that sometimes get a little too close, and…

From cars to computers: How data is transforming F1 racing

After a single weekend of racing, a Formula 1 pit crew typically pulls around 2TB of data from the car. Everything, from tire pressure to the temperature of the track, is recorded and analyzed in the name of boosting performance -- and not…

Seven years later, ‘Dark Souls’ is still a gloriously punishing masterpiece

Despite my experience and love of From Software’s Dark Souls III and Bloodborne, I never played the original Dark Souls. The new remastered version gave me a chance to remedy that, and it was glorious.

From street to surreal, meet 14 often overlooked women who shaped photography

Photography's long history is often dominated by men -- but women played a large role in shaping what photography is today. Meet 14 historic women in photography, from the first female war photojournalists to the first woman to pick up a…
Emerging Tech

Hidden figures of the Manhattan Project: Meet the women behind the A-bomb (Part 1)

Participants of the Manhattan Project went on to win an impressive amount of Nobel Prizes, but the women scientists who worked along with them are often overlooked. They too had Ph.D.s in physics and chemistry but had few opportunities than…

Photoshop is headed to the iPad Pro, but is a tablet enough for photographers?

Adobe is bringing Photoshop to the iPad -- but are tablets ready to tackle the more complex photo edits? While Photoshop isn't yet available for the iPad, we added an iPad Pro to our photography workflow to see how the tablet holds up.
Emerging Tech

In the race for an atomic bomb, women scientists couldn't afford to be ignored

Participants of the Manhattan Project went on to win an impressive amount of Nobel Prizes, but the women scientists who worked along with them are often overlooked. They too had Ph.D.s in physics and chemistry but had few opportunities than…
Emerging Tech

Nonny de la Peña wants to put virtual reality within Reach

Telling a story in VR can sometimes pack a punch regular films can’t. As a pioneer in immersive journalism, Nonny de la Peña wants to open that experience to everyone with her Reach platform.

Verizon just flipped 5G live in Chicago, but finding it is like panning for gold

Verizon activated its first 5G network in the U.S. on April 3, a week ahead of schedule, and we flew to Chicago to see what it’s like. There’s a high cost of entry, so is it worth it -- at least in 2019?
Emerging Tech

I tested my cat’s DNA, but the results only led to more mysteries

There are a couple of services that will test your cat’s DNA, including Basepaws and Optimal Selection. One doesn’t give any health information, while the other is marketed toward breeders.

As A.I. takes over the grunt work, doctors can get back to healing

The key to A.I.-based medical research is patients owning their own data. Rather than storing patient records in the cloud, researchers want patients to house their own data on their phones. This data could then be shared and pooled to…