The Ico & Shadow of the Colossus Collection review

Two of the most fascinating PS2 games return in a good justification of HD games
Two of the most fascinating PS2 games return in a good justification of HD games
Two of the most fascinating PS2 games return in a good justification of HD games


  • Both games are completely original
  • The HD graphics look good
  • A reintroduction for gamers to two amazing games


  • The only change is graphical
  • The same gameplay problems exist
  • No new content

How do you review games like Ico and Shadow of the Colossus, two relics of the PlayStation 2 era from Fumito Ueda that to this day stand among the best that the medium has yet seen. You don’t. Not really. You just thank your lucky stars that it’s your job to journey through these fantastic experiences once more and then tell everyone all over again how they shouldn’t be missed.

I’ve spent the past few weeks following through on the first part of that. At no point did it suck. Now for the second part.

Sony’s Ico & Shadow of the Colossus Collection HD brings the two titles to PlayStation 3 for the first time (older backwards-compatible consoles notwithstanding), adding a new 720p widescreen display to both, as well as 7.1 surround sound, a 3D mode and PlayStation Trophies. There’s some bonus behind-the-scenes video content too, but I couldn’t seem to find it on the game disc. The games themselves are entirely unchanged, barring the technical upgrades, which is just fine. This pair doesn’t need to be remade, simply preserved.

Ico is the older of the two, an action-platformer released in 2001, early in the PS2’s life. Players step into the shoes of the titular young boy as he explores a large, abandoned fortress. It’s essentially a massive escort mission, as Ico’s journey involves leading a young captive girl named Yorda out of the castle to safety. The game twists your typical platforming challenges with the addition of this second character; Yorda is not nearly as capable as Ico is, rendering each of the rooms they pass through as a puzzle in which creating new routes is just as important as clearly environmental obstacles.


Our duo’s journey is complicated by the presence of shadow creatures throughout the castle. They can’t harm our nimble hero — only a fall from a great height can do that — but they will grab Yorda and drag her off to a horrible end if she is left alone for too long. You can rescue her using the meager weapons Ico is equipped with, but there’s no defeating these creatures; they always come back for more.

While Ico is still very clearly a PS2-era game in its PS3 appearance, the high definition treatment very effectively makes it feel new and fresh once more. This isn’t a full-blown re-skin, but everything feels much sharper. The colors are more vibrant, the fine details in the game’s art design stand out better and the various visual effects are much more convincing. As a bonus for North American gamers, this is a port of the European version of the game, which means that completing it unlocks a two-player cooperative mode (local only).


Shadow of the Colossus stands in contrast to Ico as a large, open world filled with enormous beings compared to the older game’s tight castle corridors and chambers. Our heroes are Wander and his horse Argo, who journey together through the largely empty landscape with the intent of bringing down the game’s colossal bosses, waking Wander’s lady-love from a magical sleep in the process. Playing this game back in the day was a revelation, a new twist on the open-world approach to video game design that hasn’t really been repeated or nodded to since.

Colossus in HD is similarly revelatory, but for entirely different reasons. The game benefits greatly from the visual makeover, especially with the added bonus of a widescreen display. Wander’s beautiful world remains just that, and the colossi he takes on are given a new sense of scale thanks to the added screen real estate. Like Ico, much of the story in Shadow is left to be deciphered by the player. Bringing down a colossus pushes Wander one step closer to rescuing his distressed damsel, but the tragically epic death scene accompanying each of his victories strongly suggests that this selfish pursuit is coming at a high cost.


Also like Ico, the flaws that existed in Colossus before still remain. Specifically, the controls feel very chunky and slow-to-respond, a reminder that this is still a six-year-old game. There is one rather notable improvement, however. The bulk of the criticisms directed at the original release targeted its technical presentation. While the game was gorgeous to behold, it wasn’t always a smooth experience thanks to an unsteady frame rate. That is no longer an issue here. Colossus in HD, like Ico, hums along at a solid 30 frames per second. It’s expected, of course, but it’s a welcome improvement all the same.

So there you have it. The Ico & Shadow of the Colossus Collection HD is must-own material if you’re a PS3 owner. If you’ve never played the games before, this is the best opportunity you’ve had yet to really experience them. And if you have played them, this is still the best there is. Both games look greatly improved with their widescreen 720p makeover, and they offer the same fulfilling experiences that their predecessors did. Let’s face it: you’re not reading this because you’re not sure if this duo has held up, you’re just doing it to make the wait for the Collection‘s September 28 release pass by a little quicker.

 (This game was reviewed on the PlayStation 3on a copy provided by Sony Computer Entertainment)


Still trying to unlock your main in 'Super Smash Bros. Ultimate'? Try these tips

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is Nintendo’s biggest entry in the series to date with over 70 characters to unlock, but the process can feel tiresome. Here are our tips to unlock your roster as quickly as possible.
Home Theater

Here’s why you’re not getting Netflix in HD or 4K, and how to fix it

Are you having trouble watching your favorite movies or TV shows on Netflix in HD or 4K? We explain why loading takes so long, why the picture quality fluctuates, and what you can do about it.

The Kobo Clara HD, one of the best Kindle alternatives, is now on sale

One of the more popular Kindle alternatives (and one that stands tall as one of our favorite ereaders) is Kobo. Among the best of Kobo's offerings is the awesome Kobo Clara HD, and it's now on sale for the holidays for just $100 from…
Product Review

Not even the promise of nostalgia can save the PlayStation Classic

The PS1 era was home to many great games that are worth revisiting. Unfortunately, the PlayStation Classic is a collectible that capitalizes on the cute mini aesthetic but falls short everywhere else.

How to make a clan in ‘Destiny 2’ and where to go from there

Want to know how to make a clan in 'Destiny 2'? Here's everything you need to know, including how to design your clan's banner, earn extra loot, and help other players with guided games.

Put down the controller and pick up the best phones for gaming on the go

Which phones are the best if all you want to do is play some mobile games? We've done the hard work and put together a list of the best gaming phones on Android and iOS, so you can keep playing and winning.

Ditch the meditation app. 'Katamari Damacy Reroll' is pure gaming zen

Katamari Damacy Reroll brings the magic of the PS2 classic to Nintendo Switch and PC. With updated visuals and the same great, singular loop, Reroll stands the test of time. Katamari Damacy is the ultimate relaxation game.

Need help getting the Sleeper Simulant in 'Destiny 2'? We’ve got you covered

The Sleeper Simulant is one of the coolest new Exotic weapons you can unlock in the Warmind expansion of Destiny 2, but it's an involved process that will take awhile. Here's everything you need to know.

Xbox One S vs. PlayStation 4 Slim: Which console is worth your money?

Microsoft's new Xbox One S and Sony's PlayStation 4 "Slim" have bucked the generational gaming console trend. But which of these stopgap systems is worth spending your paycheck on?

Check out the best Xbox One deals and bundles for December 2018

Microsoft's consoles are just as capable of streaming movies as they are of playing the latest games. Check out our top Xbox One deals and bundles, which include new and upcoming triple-A games like Battlefield V and Fallout 76.

Best Products of 2018

Our reception desk has so many brown boxes stacked up, it looks like a loading dock. We’re on a first-name basis with the UPS guy. We get new dishwashers more frequently than most people get new shoes. What we’re trying to say is: We…

The NES Classic is back in stock just in time for the holidays

The NES Classic is back in stock at multiple outlets at its original launch price of $60 in time for Christmas. Retailers offering it online are Walmart, GameStop, Target, and Best Buy -- if you're looking for the perfect holiday gift for…

Some ‘Fortnite’ players aren’t too happy with the new Infinity Blade weapon

The most recent update for Fortnite added the Infinity Blade melee weapon to battle royale, and some players aren't happy with how much it has changed the game during competitions.

Soulja Boy’s ‘new’ console appears to include stolen Nintendo games

Rapper Soulja Boy recently released his SouljaGame console, and it includes several emulated games that appear to be stolen from companies like Nintendo, SNK, and Capcom. A handheld version is also available.