Skip to main content

Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Why trust us?

Apple Arcade teeters on irrelevance as it desperately seeks ‘engagement’

A report from Bloomberg on June 30 revealed an apparent change in direction for Apple Arcade, the company’s subscription game service. According to the report, Apple has canceled contracts with several developers “while seeking other titles that it believes will better retain subscribers.” According to Bloomberg, Apple wants games that will keep players hooked — and subscribed to Arcade. Grindstone, an action-puzzle game with tons of levels and constant progression, is cited as an example of what Apple is looking for.

Apple Arcade’s original pitch focused more on high-quality, innovative games. This is, in fact, still what you’ll see when visiting Apple’s site for Arcade, which promises “games that redefine games.” Apple’s launch promoted small, innovative, self-contained games like Sayonara Wild Hearts, Sneaky Sasquatch, Exit the Gungeon, and Overland.

Arcade’s launch lineup looked strong. Yet it has slowed to a trickle since. Only 20 new games have appeared on Arcade in 2020. Worse, many of those games have failed to stand out. Games like Beyond a Steel Sky and Crossy Road Castle are exceptions to the rule, but while they stand out on the roster, they’re not enough to propel Arcade forward.

A focus on “engagement” will mean different games

Now, with a shift in focus toward engagement, it’s unclear if Apple’s past branding of Arcade will remain true for the service going forward.

Most games promoted by Apple at the launch of Arcade are small, tight experiences. They’re games built to wow the player with a novel experience, which also means they’re not designed to bring in repeat players. You start them, experience them, then put them down.

A drive toward engagement will push Arcade away from games like these and toward titles that are more like the mobile gaming market overall.

Grindstone for iOS
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Grindstone, which reportedly represents the direction Arcade wants to pursue, illustrates the point. I like Grindstone. It’s a fun action-puzzle game supported by outstanding art. Still, it’s not fundamentally different from comparable free-to-play games in the genre. It delivers brief, snackable, repetitive levels inside the structure of a massive game with gobs of progression.

Massively multiplayer games provide a point of comparison. Some games in this genre are free and generate revenue microtransactions, while others are driven by subscriptions, and others take a hybrid approach. Whatever the business model, games in this genre — which is why massively multiplayer games never “end,” and instead focus on replayability.

Why does Apple Arcade need to exist at all?

Don’t get me wrong. I have no ax to grind with repetitive, replayable content. I’m a fan of massively multiplayer games, and actually prefer them over most single-player experiences. Still, I can’t help but feel that Apple’s shift in direction destroys the appeal of Arcade.

Engagement-driven games don’t just do well on mobile. They do so well they’ve crowded out smaller, carefully crafted games, suffocating innovation in the process. Arcade was Apple’s attempt to drag mobile gaming out of that rut.

Now, the company seems ready to abandon that fight — which begs a question. If Arcade is simply going to offer games similar to those available without a subscription, why does Apple Arcade need to exist at all?

Editors' Recommendations

Matthew S. Smith
Matthew S. Smith is the former Lead Editor, Reviews at Digital Trends. He previously guided the Products Team, which dives…
A busy 2023 wasn’t enough to pull me away from my go-to mobile game
Ms. Marvel listening to lo-fi in Marvel Snap.

I play lots of games across every platform for work, but my most-played game in 2023 was one I primarily engaged with for personal enjoyment. While I sunk dozens and dozens of hours into games like Baldur’s Gate 3, The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom, Fire Emblem Engage, Fortnite, Starfield, and more, my most played game was something that didn’t even come out in 2023.

That honor goes to Marvel Snap, a collectible card game from Second Dinner for PC and mobile

Read more
The next great Sonic the Hedgehog game may be hiding on Apple Arcade
Sonic dashes away from a crab in Sonic Dream Team.

Love it or hate it, you have to respect the Sonic the Hedgehog series. Sega and Sonic Team refuse to get stuck in a creative rut, constantly zigging when fans expect them to zag. Last year, the series took an unexpected open-zone pivot with Sonic Frontiers, only to return to familiar 2D platforming with this year’s Sonic Superstars. Just one month after that game’s release, the blue blur is taking another surprising turn with Sonic Dream Team.

Launching exclusively for Apple Arcade on December 5, Sonic Dream Team sees the series returning to the 3D roller-coaster design of the Sonic Adventures era. It’s both a nostalgic return to form and something entirely new, making for the most ambitious Sonic mobile game yet. It’s not the project I’d imagine anyone was expecting, but it might just be the one that fans have been waiting for.

Read more
How to get the most out of Honkai: Star Rail’s polarizing auto-battle system
Seele with red eyes using Ultimate with blue light

Honkai: Star Rail is full of great quality of life features, but auto-battle has the game's community divided. Rather than playing traditional turn-based RPG battles, auto=battle essentially does the work for players. Some fans love it because of how it helps them grind through daily resource runs or overcome early-game hurdles. Others, though, complain that it problematically automates what's supposed to be a main component of the gameplay.

So, is it worth using? Yes. For the most part, it’s a helpful tool -- when used properly. There are just a few exceptions that players should be wary about if they want to take advantage of the feature. Auto-battle works best in specific scenarios. Nine times out of 10, you're smarter than the AI. That's why so many people complain about dumb decisions it makes, like buffing a teammate that doesn’t need it or popping an Ultimate when a battle is nearly finished. At its core. auto-battle is meant to automate the most monotonous parts of the game and leave the most challenging (and frustrating) content for you to enjoy. If you're looking to experiment with it, here's how to use it to its fullest.
Making the most of auto-battle
Auto-battle offers a solution where you can blow through battles with the press of a button, so you don't have to stay engaged during the entire process. You can press the little double arrow icon in the top-right corner of your battle menu, surf the web in another tab, and check your game after a few minutes to find all your rewards waiting for you on the screen. I use auto-battle to fight waves of Calyxes, one of the challenges you can complete for experience books and level-up materials. It's a big ask for players to commit even 30 minutes a day to grinding through the same challenges.

Read more