Skip to main content

EA accused of secretly paying YouTubers for coverage

ea accused paying youtubers highlight games without telling public logo
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Following accusations that Microsoft paid YouTube commenters to give the Xbox One favorable coverage, a similar accusation has been hurled at Electronic Arts, according to a post on NeoGAF outlining the plan (via IGN). In itself, a company paying someone to talk about their products isn’t an issue, but both Microsoft and EA have been accused of having the people paid sign non-disclosure agreements barring them from revealing their arrangements with the companies in question, which may be a violation of FTC guidelines.

According to the EA “assignment” posted on NeoGAF, from December 10, 2013 through January18, 2014, the publisher was willing to put up money for certain types of coverage of its next-gen and PC games, including: Need for Speed: Rivals, Battlefield 4, FIFA 14, NHL 14, Plants Vs. Zombies 2, and Madden 25. EA offered $10 per CPM (Cost Per Mille), or $10 for every 1,000 views of the YouTuber’s total views. Different games have different “view caps,” but they are extremely high in most cases – Need For Speed Rivals had a view limit of 6 million, while Battlefield 4, for instance, has a view cap of 20 million. At $10 per thousand views, that could add up to some serious money. By comparison, Microsoft was only offering $3 CPM, with a view limit of 1.25 million.

In order to qualify for the payout, EA issued some very specific guidelines. These changed per game, but most shared a few common requirements, including not focusing on major glitches. EA does allow for those streaming to mention things it would like to see improved in games like BF4, however, as long as the person commenting stays “on assignment.”

On the face of it, there is nothing inherently wrong with this. EA is asking YouTubers that stream video to focus on certain aspects of their games, such as “Get to a heat level of 8 with 100,000 Speedpoints, put these on the line as cops swarm you” in Need for Speed Rivals, and focusing on BF4’s “levolution” (where you trigger an event that alters a multiplayer map, like bringing down a skyscraper). EA is asking those gamers to produce videos that make their games look exciting while highlighting certain aspects of it.

Where it becomes questionable is the non-disclosure agreement the publisher is reportedly asking gamers to sign, which prohibits them from telling anyone that EA is paying them.

It’s important to note that this is still unconfirmed. If it is true though, that may put EA in the crosshairs of the Federal Trade Commission, along with Microsoft. In Microsoft’s case, the accusation is a bit more damning since it was allegedly asking people to talk up the Xbox One without saying anything negative about it. That is tantamount to a paid endorsement not properly identifying itself as such, which is a violation of FTC guidelines. With EA, if true, the commenters were allowed to criticize the game, which legally may not be seen as an endorsement. 

Assuming this accusation is true, it will likely have to be settled by lawyers as they defend the non-disclosure agreement while arguing that it paying for videos is not the same as asking people to endorse them. 

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Ryan Fleming
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Ryan Fleming is the Gaming and Cinema Editor for Digital Trends. He joined the DT staff in 2009 after spending time covering…
YouTube copies Twitch with feature that lets you tip your favorite stars $2
YouTube TV

Viewers can now "clap" at their favorite YouTube stars as another way for creators to earn money through the Google-owned video platform. The donation feature mirrors one offered by Amazon gaming streaming service Twitch and may be another way for YouTube to lure e-sports streamers from the popular niche platform.

The feature is officially called "viewer applause" on YouTube and rests nest to the Like and Dislike buttons for viewers and can be enabled in a creator's dashboard. However, the feature is in the beta testing phase and only a small number of creators with more than 100,000 subscribers have access to it at this point.

Read more
Twitch remains king of livestreaming, but YouTube is catching up
twitch tries out commercial free viewing

It's going to take more than a Ninja to take down Twitch. Despite the exodus of top-tier streamers to competing platforms like Mixer and YouTube over the last year, no service comes close to matching Twitch's viewership. But YouTube isn't ready to crown Twitch the king of streaming just yet.

Game content streaming is up 17% compared to January 2019, according to livestream tools provider StreamElements, and viewership increases can be seen across Twitch, YouTube Gaming, Facebook Gaming, and Mixer. Amazon-owned Twitch sits at more than 842 million January hours watched, which is more than twice that of its closest competitor.

Read more
Overwatch League, Call of Duty League to exclusively stream on YouTube
Call of Duty Modern Warfare

Activision Blizzard and Google have entered a multi-year partnership to "power new player experiences," and part of the deal is for the Overwatch League and the newly launched Call of Duty League to be exclusively streamed on YouTube.

YouTube will host Activision Blizzard's official live broadcasts of its esports leagues, which started on January 24 for the launch weekend of the first season of the Call of Duty League with 12 teams. To follow suit will be the Overwatch League, which will kick off its 2020 season on February 8.

Read more