Skip to main content

EA accused of secretly paying YouTubers for coverage

Following accusations that Microsoft paid YouTube commenters to give the Xbox One favorable coverage, a similar accusation has been hurled at Electronic Arts, according to a post on NeoGAF outlining the plan (via IGN). In itself, a company paying someone to talk about their products isn’t an issue, but both Microsoft and EA have been accused of having the people paid sign non-disclosure agreements barring them from revealing their arrangements with the companies in question, which may be a violation of FTC guidelines.

According to the EA “assignment” posted on NeoGAF, from December 10, 2013 through January18, 2014, the publisher was willing to put up money for certain types of coverage of its next-gen and PC games, including: Need for Speed: Rivals, Battlefield 4, FIFA 14, NHL 14, Plants Vs. Zombies 2, and Madden 25. EA offered $10 per CPM (Cost Per Mille), or $10 for every 1,000 views of the YouTuber’s total views. Different games have different “view caps,” but they are extremely high in most cases – Need For Speed Rivals had a view limit of 6 million, while Battlefield 4, for instance, has a view cap of 20 million. At $10 per thousand views, that could add up to some serious money. By comparison, Microsoft was only offering $3 CPM, with a view limit of 1.25 million.

Recommended Videos

In order to qualify for the payout, EA issued some very specific guidelines. These changed per game, but most shared a few common requirements, including not focusing on major glitches. EA does allow for those streaming to mention things it would like to see improved in games like BF4, however, as long as the person commenting stays “on assignment.”

On the face of it, there is nothing inherently wrong with this. EA is asking YouTubers that stream video to focus on certain aspects of their games, such as “Get to a heat level of 8 with 100,000 Speedpoints, put these on the line as cops swarm you” in Need for Speed Rivals, and focusing on BF4’s “levolution” (where you trigger an event that alters a multiplayer map, like bringing down a skyscraper). EA is asking those gamers to produce videos that make their games look exciting while highlighting certain aspects of it.

Where it becomes questionable is the non-disclosure agreement the publisher is reportedly asking gamers to sign, which prohibits them from telling anyone that EA is paying them.

It’s important to note that this is still unconfirmed. If it is true though, that may put EA in the crosshairs of the Federal Trade Commission, along with Microsoft. In Microsoft’s case, the accusation is a bit more damning since it was allegedly asking people to talk up the Xbox One without saying anything negative about it. That is tantamount to a paid endorsement not properly identifying itself as such, which is a violation of FTC guidelines. With EA, if true, the commenters were allowed to criticize the game, which legally may not be seen as an endorsement. 

Assuming this accusation is true, it will likely have to be settled by lawyers as they defend the non-disclosure agreement while arguing that it paying for videos is not the same as asking people to endorse them. 

Topics
Ryan Fleming
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Ryan Fleming is the Gaming and Cinema Editor for Digital Trends. He joined the DT staff in 2009 after spending time covering…
All Grand Theft Auto games in order, by release date and chronologically
People stand on boats in Grand Theft Auto 6.

In the battle for the best open world game of all time, every other game is fighting for second place behind the Grand Theft Auto games. Ever since the third game took the series to 3D, each game has gotten bigger, better, and more popular. We wouldn't be surprised if GTA 6 might be the biggest launch in all of media, not just in games. However, the time between releases has gotten longer and longer to the point where most gamers haven't played any of the games before 3. Those who have played multiple games in the series know that Rockstar likes to bring us back to familiar settings in different time periods. There aren't as many GTA games as Call of Duty games, but playing through them in any kind of order is hard. We cut our teeth on the very first GTA and have rampaged through the entire series so we can lay out how you can play the Grand Theft Auto games in release or chronological order.

All Grand Theft Auto games in release order

Read more
The powerful HP Omen Max 16 gaming laptop with RTX 5070 Ti is $350 off today
The HP Omen Max gaming laptop with Valorant on the screen.

Gamers who want an upgrade should be on the lookout for discounts from gaming laptop deals, as these devices can get pretty expensive. You should check out the HP Omen Max 16, as its configuration with the Nvidia GeForce RTX 5070 Ti graphics card is on sale from HP itself for $2,150 instead of $2,500. That's $350 in savings that you can spend on video games and other accessories, but you're going to have to hurry with your purchase if you want to buy the gaming laptop at 16% off as the offer may be already gone by tomorrow.

Why you should buy the HP Omen Max 16 gaming laptop

Read more
Bravely Default HD Remaster shows the party potential of Switch 2’s mouse controls
An airship flies in Bravely Default: Flying Fairy HD Remaster.

If I had to describe 2012’s Bravely Default, the very last term I’d use is “party game.” In fact, the Nintendo 3DS RPG is the anti party game. It’s a long, winding adventure that requires a tremendous amount of patience to get through. So it came as a bit of a surprise when the first thought I had after demoing its upcoming Switch 2 version, Bravely Default: Flying Fairy HD Remaster, is that it really sells the party potential of Nintendo’s new console.

That’s not because the RPG has changed in any way; it more has to do with its new side content. During a hand-on demo, I tried my hand at the remaster’s two new minigames, which are available as bonuses from the main menu. Both are designed to use the Switch 2’s mouse controls in incredibly clever ways that left me even more eager to see what developers can do with the unique two joy-con scheme.

Read more