How much influence should fans have on game developers?

how much influence should fans have on game developers endingsVideo game fans are certainly not shy. Every forum or comment thread on a popular video game will be filled with detailed opinions about where the developers went wrong. The majority of developer or publisher forums covering a specific game series have at least one thread discussing what gamers would like to see in a patch, update, or sequel. Regardless of what most gamers think, developers do generally read these comments, and the vast majority care about catering for their fans.

The storm over the Mass Effect 3 ending is a good example. In an interview here at DT, the Mass Effect 3 Director, Casey Hudson, said “we will always listen to feedback, interpret it and try and do the right thing by our fans.”

Within two weeks of the game’s release BioWare acknowledged fans’ disappointment with the ending and announced that Mass Effect 3: Extended Cut, featuring a new ending, would be released as a free DLC in the summer. It’s pretty clear that fans exerted their influence and BioWare reacted. Is this a positive thing for the industry or does it pose a threat for developers?

how much influence should fans have on game developers mass effect 3 endingQuit your whining

Not everyone agrees that fans should influence the course of game development. Tekken producer Katsuhiro Harada got so fed up with being spammed by fan requests to use specific voice actors that he wrote a long explanation of what they are doing that starts “I believe that, before whining and complaining about everything, you need practice at taking a step back and analyzing things objectively. And also at being an adult.”

It’s a fair point. While some demands might be popular with the majority of fans and so merit consideration, there will always be small groups of extremely vociferous fans who make questionable requests. Obviously not every idea can or should be accommodated.

Balancing act

Fraser Simpson, Lead Designer at Climax, says: “It’s a constant quandary for a game designer. You’re making a game for an audience – but do you know what they want better than they do?

“Often you get results back from a gameplay test and someone’s said ‘Make this feature do this instead.’ You think ‘Well I know how to make a game and that’s a stupid idea.’ And you’ll be right. Then, somewhere else, you see a part of the game where you intended to create a certain experience, and people just don’t get it. Then you’ve misjudged your audience.

“It’s a balance. If you’ve got your head in the sand, you’re crazy; if you’re completely democratizing your design and trying to please everyone, it’s probably going to be pretty bland.”

Creating a dialogue

Fans love to feel that they are in touch with the developers of their favorite games and that their complaints are being heard, even if they aren’t acted upon. The community manager for Diablo 3 recently admitted in a forum post responding to fan complaints that the end game is not currently up to scratch and “There needs to be something else that keeps people engaged, and we know it’s not there right now.”

He probably didn’t expect that response to be picked up and reported so widely by the video game press. You have to wonder about Blizzard’s internal thoughts on that one, but for most gamers it was perceived as refreshingly honest. Blizzard CEO, Mike Morhaime, has also now commented assuring players it will be fixed.

how much influence should fans have on game developers half life 3Loving something too much

Sometimes fans’ attempts to wield an influence are really just about their love for a particular game series. A Steam group was created at the end of last year to call for some kind of communication from Valve about when we might expect the next installment of Half-Life. It was actually a respectful attempt to get some news, and they organized a mass HL2 session which pulled in 13,000 people. The group now has over 60,000 members. Naturally they got no response. You can’t rush Valve, and to be honest that’s one of the reasons they produce such great games.

The 2009 Left 4 Dead 2 boycott wasn’t quite so friendly. Fans of the series complained that a sequel would result in a loss of support for the original Left 4 Dead and that it should be updated with more content before being superseded by a sequel. One of the project leads at Valve, Chet Faliszek, responded in an interview with Ars Technica and appealed for fans to give them a “fair shake” before venting. The Steam group still has 16,912 members as of this writing and comments about how they’ll never buy L4D2 are still rolling in.

Why shouldn’t fans have an influence?

Very few of the games that are released each year are the product of one person’s vision. Games are fundamentally a collaborative medium.

A game that pandered to every fan suggestion would probably never get released. Most fans lack a full understanding of how games are actually made, and many of their requests would be virtually impossible to fulfill. However, there’s no reason developers can’t compile a list of the most popular requests, cross reference them with existing design ideas, and accommodate the cream of the crop. The quality of some fan suggestions is actually very high.

If we’re looking at this from an artistic vision angle then the influence of publishers, marketing execs, and business people is far more damaging to games than the influence of fans. Most developers actually play the game, a lot, and their desire is to improve the experience, not to squeeze more money out of it.

Fraser Simpson at Climax puts it like this, “I’d say that there are parts of a game where gamers are entitled to insist on us meeting their expectation, like any product; they have to be competitive, they have to function, they have to be usable, feel good. For the most part, these aspects are geared completely towards audience perception.

“The parts of the game where we’re doing something artistic or new, that’s our business. Literally. We’ll test it out on people and we’ll make sure it has the intended effect, but it’s up to us to decide what we want you to experience. It’s totally fine for an audience to criticize that experience but if they don’t like it, that doesn’t necessarily mean we owe them a favor.

Ultimately, if you want to experience something new, you’re going to need to trust someone. It mightn’t always work, but when it does it’ll be worth it.”

Modding community

how much influence should fans have on game developers skyrim modsThe modding community, which uses existing game engines, content, and tools to create new games–or more often slight tweaks on existing ones–is a great testing ground for ideas. It’s churlish not to be impressed by the lengths that some gamers will go to in order to realize their ideas. Skyrim, for example, has some unbelievable mods (see image on the right).

When you think about it, the modding community has grown out of a desire for fans to implement their own ideas. Mods allow fans to tweak the game parameters and change the rules to suit their vision and occasionally the results surpass the original game or spawn something entirely new that’s worthy of further development.

Anyone who is really determined to see their ideas in a game has to go and make it for themselves. That’s exactly what drives most developers and the pros have earned the right to do it.

Fan input is a positive

Provided developers know when to listen and when not to, fan input is a definite positive.

We’ll finish off with the thoughts of Michael Hartman, CEO of Frogdice, “In my 20+ years as a game developer, I have lost count of how many times fans and players have affected or altered my designs, storylines, and plans. My core vision for the game remained the same, but beyond that nothing is sacred. Games are an interactive medium and that is a strength. Furthermore, modern games can be changed, tweaked, and improved post-release. These are strengths of the medium that movies, books, etc. do not enjoy. We should embrace these strengths not run away from them.

“While fan input is important and useful, being a slave to it is a recipe for disaster. Every recent MMO that I have played has fallen victim to this, and see-saw game/class balance is the result. As the story goes: ‘Hey developer, this is Rock. Nerf Paper. Scissors is fine.’ Good developers listen to their fans. Great developers know when not to.”

Gaming

‘Gears of War’ designer Cliff Bleszinski says he’ll never make another game

Cliff Bleszinski, the game designer best known for his work on the Gears of War series, says he will never make another video game. His studio, Boss Key Productions, shut its doors earlier this year.
Gaming

The best PS3 games of all time

Choosing the right PlayStation 3 game can be a conundrum, especially when there are nearly 1,500 titles to choose from. Thankfully, we've rounded up the best games to have ever made it to the platform.
Gaming

Every rumor about the PS5, including a new game from Luminous Productions

PlayStation 5 rumors have been circulating for over a year now but there's still plenty we don't know. Here's everything you need to know about the PS5, including rumors about its release, specs, and games.
Gaming

The best free-to-play games you can play right now

Believe it or not, free-to-play games have evolved into engaging, enjoyable experiences. Here are a few of our favorites that you can play right now, including Warframe and the perennially-popular League of Legends.
Gaming

These cheat codes made gaming history

For almost as long as video games have existed, there have been video game cheat codes. Here are some of the most famous cheat codes, including the legendary Konami Code found in dozens of games.
Gaming

Nintendo and Microsoft say they’re all-in on E3 after Sony bows out of 2019 event

Shortly after Sony announced it will not participate in E3 2019 for the first time, Microsoft and Sony announced the show will go on as usual for each software giant. E3 2019 now presents a unique opportunity for Sony's major competitors.
Gaming

‘Spyro Reignited Trilogy’ proves nostalgia can only blind for so long

Spyro Reignited Trilogy is a faithful and beatiful remaster of the PlayStation classics, but its dedication to retaining the original experience ultimately hinders the experience. Spyro was great in the late-'90s, but it hasn't aged well.
Gaming

Here's where Xur is and what he has for wares this week in 'Destiny 2: Forsaken'

The weekly vendor in Destiny 2: Forsaken always brings Exotic weapons and armor, some of the toughest loot to find in the game. Here's everything you need to know to track down Xur: Where he is, when he shows up, and what he's stocking.
Gaming

Microsoft is reportedly planning an Xbox One without a disc drive for 2019

Microsoft is reportedly planning to release a new Xbox One model without a disc drive in 2019. The console will be significantly cheaper than other Xbox One systems, including the Xbox One S.
Gaming

15 tips for keeping your vault-dwellers alive in ‘Fallout Shelter’

The wasteland can be an unfriendly place, if you don't know what you're doing. Here are 15 tips that will help your vault thrive in Fallout Shelter, including information on questing.
Gaming

Stock up on Switch accessories this week with these awesome Black Friday deals

Black Friday is right around the corner, and it's the perfect time to stock up on accessories for your Nintendo Switch. Here are the best Switch accessory deals on Black Friday, from controllers to cases and more.
Product Review

Make friends. To survive the wasteland of 'Fallout 76,' you're gonna need 'em

Fallout 76 brings the nuclear wasteland online and invites you to hop in with your friends. It’s fun, and a new direction for the Fallout franchise, but it’s not without its faults.
Gaming

‘Final Fantasy VII Remake’ director sets record straight on game’s progress

Final Fantasy VII Remake director Tetsuya Nomura clarified some information about the game's progress. There were earlier reports that the RPG was put on hold in favor of Kingdom Hearts III, but that is apparently not the case.
Features

From NES to PlayStation, retro gaming is booming. But will it last?

Everyone craves the good old days, and companies like Nintendo and Sony are cashing in with their mini versions of beloved retro consoles. But is this fad built to last or will our fixation with pixelated graphics come and go like mom…