Skip to main content

Nintendo found guilty of patent infringement, ordered to pay $30 mil in damages

nintendo wii u
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Despite some very good image management  Nintendo has never been quite the hardware innovator that people paint them as. In fact, the Big N got its start in the video game business not making its own machines, but distributing consoles like the Magnavox Odyssey in Japan and re-appropriating stock arcade boards to make new games like Donkey Kong. That’s the company’s tech legacy: Re-appropriating good ideas like touch screens and making them new and exciting in machines like the Nintendo DS. It’s rarely been accused of flat out stealing ideas, however. The Nintendo 3DS’ patented glasses-free stereoscopic 3D screen is apparently the rare example. Turns out the glasses-free tech isn’t patented by Nintendo at all, and as a result, the 3DS manufacturer has been found guilty of patent infringement.

Former Sony employee and inventor Saejiro Tomita is the actual inventor of the 3D display technology used in the Nintendo 3DS. Tomita sued Nintendo for infringement in 2011, and the jury in a U.S. District Court in New York decided on Wednesday that the house of Mario has indeed used Tomita’s technology without his permission or fair compensation, and the company must now pay him $30.2 million in damages.

Nintendo did not deny that it had consulted with Tomita about his technology. He brought his glasses-free display technology to Nintendo back in 2003, a period when Nintendo was still prototyping the 3DS’ predecessor, Nintendo DS. Nintendo’s defense was that it had met with many different display creators at the time before moving forward nearly a decade later with the actual tech in the 3DS.

While patent infringement accusations against Nintendo are rare, they have happened before. Tech company Hillcrest accused Nintendo of copying its technology that let “users select items on a screen by waving a handheld device” in its now iconic Wii remote. The International Trade Commission acquitted Nintendo of infringing on anyone else’s patents with the remote though, in Hillcrest’s case in 2008 and again in 2011 when ThinkOptics brought similar charges against the company.

Interestingly enough, Nintendo received the Wii remote’s motion control technology from an independent inventor not unlike Saejiro Tomita. California inventor Tom Quinn shopped around his gyroscope-based motion control tech to all the video game console companies back in 2001, but only Nintendo expressed interest. In fact, Quinn said that Nintendo was the only company even cordial to him, with both Microsoft’s Xbox and Sony’s PlayStation hardware teams laughing him out of the room.

Editors' Recommendations

Anthony John Agnello
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Anthony John Agnello is a writer living in New York. He works as the Community Manager of Joystiq.com and his writing has…
Nintendo’s Wii Shop Channel and DSi shops are back online
Nintendo 3DS close-up.

After months of service outages, Nintendo's Wii Shop Channel and DSi Shop are back online.

Nintendo's two virtual marketplace services went down in March of this year. In a statement to Kotaku on the outage, Nintendo acknowledged the downtime but had nothing to report other than that the shops were undergoing maintenance and that it would provide updates on them at a later date. It seems it completely skipped the update and simply put both back online instead.

Read more
The 25 best Nintendo 3DS games
Nintendo 3DS close-up.

If you're looking for the best Nintendo 3DS games, there's no shortage of titles to choose from, thanks to the console's long life cycle.

The 3DS has enjoyed several updates over the years, but each was compatible with its predecessor, and that translates to a large and diverse library. It's getting increasingly tough to find a 3DS, especially since Nintendo has officially discontinued the console and no longer supports it to focus on releasing Switch games. Even so, the legacy of the 3DS lives on with a long list of excellent, pocket-sized adventures. Here are our favorite ones.

Read more
Nintendo’s eShop closures are a necessary, but messy move
A Nintendo Wii U gamepad flat on a table.

Nintendo last week announced its intentions to shut down the Wii U and 3DS eShops, the systems' digital storefronts, in March 2023. This decision was disappointing for hardcore fans who stuck with Nintendo during that rocky era and extremely worrying as many of the games available on the platforms won't be preserved.
More significant Wii U games and a handful of 3DS titles were ported to Switch, but many titles are still stuck on those systems and can’t be ported. Once the digital storefront shutdowns, digital-only titles will be gone forever, and physical copies of these titles will get more expensive and harder to experience. Fans and game preservationists have not been pleased by this decision, with the Video Game History Foundation giving the most candid response.
https://twitter.com/GameHistoryOrg/status/1494398068346654720
Following this announcement, Digital Trends spoke to an industry analyst and game preservationists to get a better idea of what exactly caused Nintendo to shut down these stores and to learn how it could do a better job at preserving its legacy.
Why is Nintendo shutting down the 3DS and Wii eShops?
Officially, Nintendo’s FAQ on the eShop closures says “this is part of the natural life cycle for any product line as it becomes less used by consumers over time." The answer doesn’t get into specifics and might confuse those still playing games on the system or fans of games only available on Wii U or 3DS. Omdia Principal Analyst Matthew Bailey explains Nintendo’s user base argument in more detail, highlighting the massive gap between the number of people playing the Switch as opposed to the Wii U.
“While Omdia expects the number of Switch consoles in active use to exceed 90 million on a global basis this year, the Wii U’s global active installed base will drop under one million in 2022,” he explains. “Even when you include the more enduring 3DS family of consoles into the equation, the Switch still comfortably accounts for over 90% of Nintendo’s total active console install base.”
If one is going off just the numbers, it’s sensible that Nintendo would want to focus on the majority of its players. Bailey admits that “Switch users are already reaping the benefits of Nintendo’s singular first-party development focus on one platform.” Still, one might argue that Nintendo should just let the eShops remain up even if it isn’t actively updating or maintaining them.

Unfortunately, Nintendo doesn’t see that as possible due to cost and security issues. Game Over Thrity, a Twitter user with over 20 years of experience working on IT projects and infrastructure, shed some light on what might have influenced Nintendo’s decision-making in a thread.
“As these systems age, they require patches, security, special contracts, updates, and personnel that know how they were built (and maintained),” his Twitter thread explains. “As time goes on, there are security holes, servers, code, infrastructure, etc., that can’t be brought up to modern standards. It becomes a constant struggle between maintaining legacy systems, paying people to do so, and trying to keep up with global regulations. It’s not cheap by any means. They can’t just ‘leave the lights on’ and stop supporting them. What if someone hacked the payment processor?”
With every passing year, the Wii U and 3DS eShops likely became more expensive to maintain and an increased security risk for the video game publisher. Instead of investing the time and resources into pleasing a smaller amount of players, the easier option is to turn everything off entirely. While he isn’t affiliated with Nintendo, Game Over Thirty’s assessment aligns with what we’ve heard from Nintendo and Omdia.
"The Wii U’s global active installed base will drop under one million in 2022."

Read more