Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Gaming
  3. Features
  4. News

Xbox Scorpio will live and die by its games, not its power

Gabe Gurwin
By

We found out the full technical specifications of the upcoming “Project Scorpio” Xbox One console on Thursday, and they’re undeniably impressive. Six teraflops of GPU performance, 12GB of GDDR5 RAM, and the ability to play games in “native 4K” — 4K resolution at 60 frames per second – is simply unheard of on a home console. Games originally released at 1080p or 900p resolutions will be able to run in 4K and will sport better framerates and loading times. All things being equal, numbers like these should make Project Scorpio the go-to destination for multiplatform releases.

The announcement lacked one key component: video games.

Recommended Videos

As impressive as Scorpio’s spec sheet is, the announcement lacked one key component. Video games. Microsoft has remained surprisingly quiet about how developers will support the new console. Even if it could run games at 8K resolution and project full-blown holograms, Project Scorpio and the entire Xbox One family cannot succeed without the exclusive games that will give players a reason to turn it on.

The Xbox One and PlayStation 4 both launched in 2013, with a selection of exclusive games that served to showcase the new consoles’ more powerful hardware. On Xbox One, games like Ryse: Son of Rome and Forza Motorsport 5 were beautiful and showed off a selection of the system’s new features like Kinect and enhanced haptic feedback, but they failed to deliver a compelling experience that wasn’t already available on the Xbox 360. PlayStation 4’s Killzone: Shadow Fall fared similarly, and is now regarded as the weakest game in the series.

In 2014, the consoles were still fairly evenly matched, with Titanfall and inFamous: Second Son offering beautiful visuals and hours of fun to Xbox One and PlayStation 4 owners, respectively, but Microsoft’s first and second-party software lineup quickly fizzled out. Halo: The Master Chief Collection launched with a litany of matchmaking problems. Project Spark withered away and died. Twisted Pixel, a studio Microsoft purchased after the success of its Kinect game The Gunstringer on Xbox 360, released LocoCycle to a critical mauling, and the studio regained its independence shortly thereafter. ReCore, developed by a dream team of Mega Man and Metroid veterans, was one of the most disappointing games released last year.

Conversely, the PlayStation 4 has seen “true” exclusives like Bloodborne, Uncharted 4, Horizon: Zero Dawn, and Nioh, along with the console-exclusive Nier: Automata. Persona 5, just released this month, is only available on PlayStation systems. Each and every one of these games released to critical acclaim.

More pixels and smoother framerates might not be enough to help Xbox gain ground.

Microsoft’s problems with the Xbox One may have sprung from technical inferiority and a higher price point compared to the PlayStation 4, but the lack of noteworthy games tied to its name has not done it any favors. The company’s selection of first-party games, and even its timed exclusives developed by outside studios, simply haven’t been of the same quality as the PlayStation 4’s games. Formerly acclaimed series Halo is now something of a question mark, with Halo Wars 2 releasing to very little buzz, and 2015’s Halo 5: Guardians stumbling over a narrative that meandered.

The future, as of now, doesn’t look much brighter. Scalebound, which was expected to be Microsoft and PlatinumGames’ heavy hitter this holiday season, was unceremoniously canceled earlier this year. Microsoft has a bevy of upcoming games we hope, if not expect, to launch around the same time as Project Scorpio, including Crackdown 3 and Sea of Thieves. Yet they will have to be better — not just look better — than the next wave of PS4 exclusives, which may include the God of War reboot, Insomniac’s Spider-man, and The Last of Us: Part II.

If Microsoft is able to pair Project Scorpio’s horsepower with studios capable of delivering generation-defining experiences – as it did with Bungie for Halo and Epic Games with Gears of War – it could make a strong case for becoming the definitive destination for video games. We’re certainly excited for the big surprises in store for this year’s E3 presentation. But as it stands, more pixels and smoother framerates might not offer enough firepower to help Xbox gain substantial ground in the console war.

Without the content to back it up, 4K resolution and 60 frames-per-second will just be a constant reminder of what could have been.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Gabe Gurwin
Gabe Gurwin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Gabe Gurwin has been playing games since 1997, beginning with the N64 and the Super Nintendo. He began his journalism career…
With Redfall’s stumbles, the pressure is on for Starfield
A character levitates a book in Redfall.

Judging by reviews and early impressions, Redfall is a resounding disappointment for Xbox and Bethesda. Hyped as Xbox’s first AAA release in over a year and one of the most significant things to come from Xbox’s 2021 acquisition of ZeniMax Media, Redfall isn't quite living up to those lofty expectations. While I'm still working through the game myself, I’ve played enough to know that this open-world vampire shooter pales in comparison to Arkane’s previous titles and its co-op shooter peers.

Coming after one of Xbox’s roughest years ever in terms of exclusives and the failure of the Activision Blizzard acquisition, it’s not a good look. It puts an excessive amount of pressure on just one game in Xbox’s lineup: Starfield.

Read more
Why cloud gaming is the linchpin in Microsoft’s troubled Activision Blizzard acqusition
Key art showing multiple devices playing games via the cloud.

The United Kingdom’s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) delivered a shocker this week when it blocked Microsoft’s acquisition of Activision Blizzard on Wednesday. While a lot of focus on Microsoft’s fight was centered around whether or not the acquisition would give Xbox consoles an unfair advantage over PlayStation consoles, what ultimately decided it was a much smaller market: cloud gaming.
The idea of being able to stream the game you’re playing from the cloud has existed for well over a decade. Cloud gaming’s relevance to the video game industry has only grown over the past several years thanks to both failed and successful efforts from big tech companies like Google, Amazon, and, most importantly, Microsoft. Still, cloud gaming is considered relatively niche, with Activision Blizzard Bobby Kotick calling it "inconsequential" in an interview with Bloomberg and UCL Associate Profession Joost Rietveld saying it’s not a distinct market in a submission to the CMA.
Despite those pleas, the CMA claims that cloud gaming is a “nascent market” and that “already strong incumbent in this market even stronger” in its 418-page report on the matter. Following the CMA’s decision on Wednesday, I spoke to several different analysts to find more clarity about how big Microsoft is in the cloud gaming space and why the CMA should feel compelled to intervene. While experts mostly side with Microsoft over the CMA on this decision, one greater truth emerged from these discussions. Whether one thinks cloud gaming is relevant to this acquisition or not, this emergent style of gaming has reached a point of no return where it'll be instrumental to the video game industry going forward. 
Microsoft, king of cloud gaming
Cloud gaming may sound like a niche within the industry, but that's not entirely accurate. BrandFinance Managing Director Laurence Newell tells Digital Trends that “cloud-based services account for over 70% of Microsoft’s brand value, amounting to a staggering $137.5 billion.” That’s quite an eye-catching number that understandably would raise a regulator's alarm bells. However, Newell admits that gaming only makes up 8.5% of Microsoft’s revenue, and cloud gaming is an even smaller amount of that slice.
Despite its relatively small impact on the wider company, most of the experts I spoke to agreed that Microsoft has emerged as a cloud gaming leader thanks to its compatibility with a large segment of the Xbox Game Pass Ultimate library. Conversely, Activision Blizzard has had almost no cloud gaming presence outside of one Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice port on Google Stadia before that service’s shutdown. If it were to be acquired, it is inevitable that more Activision Blizzard games would likely come to cloud-based gaming services.

Despite the shutdown of Google Stadia and the relatively small brand value received from cloud gaming compared to the rest of the company, the CMA still points out in the press release about its decision that “monthly active users in the U.K. more than tripled from the start of 2021 to the end of 2022. It is forecast to be worth up to 11 billion British pounds globally and 1 billion pounds in the U.K. by 2026.” Associate Professor of Strategy and Entrepreneurship at the UCL School of Management Joost Rietveld, who has also been a consultant for Microsoft during its acquisition process, challenges the notion that cloud gaming as a whole is a single market.
Instead, Rietveld splits it into four categories, placing Xbox Game Pass into a category called “cloud gaming as a feature,” which is when it’s “offered as part of a consumer-facing distribution platform” or “included within a bigger bundle of services provided by the platformer.” Under Rietveld’s view, services like Nvidia GeForce Now, Ubitius, and EE -- all of whom Microsoft has made individual deals to bring Activision Blizzard and Xbox Game Studios titles to -- fall into different categories and thus shouldn’t be considered or directly compared to Xbox Game Pass. No matter how they’re categorized now, the real question mark looming over the technology is its future growth, according to Omdia Senior Principal Games Analyst Steve Bailey.
“Will it remain a niche additional service or become the gaming platform of the future?” Bailey asks in his statement to Digital Trends. “Our projection is that cloud gaming is growing rapidly (revenue should more than double by 2026), but it’s still a long way from taking over the games market, so it remains arguable either way.”
“Arguable” stands out as the keyword to me here. Like any emergent technology, we’re heavily debating the positives and negatives of cloud gaming, specifically through the lens of this acquisition. But what exactly is it that the CMA sees in Microsoft that worries them?
The CMA’s problem with Microsoft
“The CMA’s argument is not that acquiring Activision Blizzard would allow Microsoft to dominate the console market as a whole, where Sony and Nintendo have strong positions relative to Xbox, but only that it would help it to achieve a dominant position in cloud gaming specifically,” Bailey tells Digital Trends. “Microsoft and Activision Blizzard will likely argue that this is disproportionate, given the relatively small scale of the cloud gaming market.”

Read more
PS Plus’ library is looking more like Game Pass’ in May lineup
Two cars race side-by-side in Grid Legends.

Sony revealed the next batch of three games that will be available throughout May 2023 as part of PlayStation Plus Essential. The lineup includes Grid Legends, Chivalry 2, and Descenders. All are very solid games in their respective genres, but interestingly, they are all also games that Xbox Game Pass subscribers will already have access to.
Grid Legends is the headlining game for this month, and it's a racing game from Codemasters where the standout feature is a story mode framed like a racing documentary with live-action interviews. While I had mixed feelings about the game and the mode when reviewing it last year, those looking for a basic but enjoyable racing game to tide them over until the next Forza Motorsport, Test Drive Unlimited, or The Crew can have some fun with it. If you're subscribed to Xbox Game Pass Ultimate, you're also able to play this game on that platform thanks to EA Play.

For those that are still in a sporty mood, Descenders is an enjoyable downhill biking game that'll scratch the same gaming itch as series like Tony Hawk's Pro Skater or Lonely Mountains: Downhill. Then, there's Chivalry 2, a very intense multiplayer game set in medieval times, which gives it a very welcome change in setting compared to many of its multiplayer peers. Both games are currently playable if you have an Xbox Game Pass subscriber, but will likely leave the service at a later date. 
If you are subscribed to both PS Plus and Xbox Game Pass, you will be fine skipping out on May's PS Plus Essential titles. If you only own a PlayStation console, though, or want to guarantee that you'll still have these games after they leave Xbox Game Pass, then definitely consider downloading them. These games will all be available with PS Plus from May 1 until June 6. Make sure you pick up April's PS Plus Essential games before May 1 as well. 

Read more