Skip to main content

The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes review: Technical flaws are afoot

The Testament of Sherlock Holmes reviewIn November of 1887, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle published a story in the British magazine Beeton’s Christmas Annual dubbed “A Study In Scarlet.” It would be the first appearance of Doyle’s most famous character, the detective Sherlock Holmes, and as a result would go on to set the stage for one of the most enduring figures in modern fiction.

Holmes, for the non-existent subset of readers that aren’t immediately familiar with the character, is defined by his almost superhuman powers of deduction. Show the man a dirty walking stick and he’ll rattle off the name of its owner, his profession, and what sort of soil he had recently been strolling through, merely by observing minute facts about the stick. This would be an impressive character trait by itself, but what makes Sherlock Holmes so enduring is that all of his deductions follow a relatively simple path of logic that makes perfect sense once the story explains how Holmes was able to figure things out so quickly. His appeal, it seems, is that Sherlock Holmes is simply a normal human, with no supernatural abilities, who just happens to be really, really excellent at his job.

Though Doyle may not have known it at the time, he was creating a timeless icon in Sherlock Holmes, and it should come as little surprise that the character has remained relevant to modern audiences for the entirety of the past 125 years. Before his death in 1930, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle wrote four novels and 56 stories featuring the character, but fans just can’t seem to get enough of the detective’s adventures and he’s appeared in hundreds of tales since that time. Tales like The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes, an adventure game created by French developer Frogwares, and the subject of today’s review.

Baker Street Irregulars

In almost all regards, The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes is a pretty standard adventure title. You’ll spend a lot of time in the game walking through rooms, examining every icon that you can possibly interact with, and attempting to match your wits against the developer’s sense of logic. Unlike classic adventure games however, The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes is a fully 3D, modern console title with at least some of the accoutrements you’d expect that to entail.

Sherlock HolmesThat said, The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes is not what I’d describe as “thoroughly modern.” It’s not out of place on an Xbox 360 or PlayStation 3, but when compared to any of the major titles released in either this year or last, the game’s aesthetics are simply not up to snuff. I’d expect to see character animations and texture work like this in a game from 2008, but in 2012 they stick out like a poorly-rendered sore thumb. Don’t get me wrong, they’re all serviceable, but there’s nothing in this game that will make you sit up and take notice of your gorgeous surroundings.

Normally that would be a big strike against the game, but in the case of The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes I can understand why the game isn’t as gorgeous as, say, the next Call Of Duty sequel. Frogwares, the game’s developer, is not only a relatively independent studio from France, they’re also far more accustomed to publishing games exclusively for the PC. Additionally, The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes was initially scheduled for release in 2010 before unexpected delays pushed its release a full two years into the future. While my job dictates that I can’t entirely forgive the developer for the game’s aesthetic shortcomings, I can point out that its inability to directly compete with major, blockbuster gaming studios should be a given. If you really expected this game to be gorgeous, you’re either delusional or completely misunderstand how the gaming industry functions.

Remember when I mentioned that Frogwares titles usually appear only on the PC? That’s important, as it seems quite apparent that the PC was seen as the key platform during the development of The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes. Everything from the game’s style of play to its menu system seem like things that would work better on a computer. While Frogwares did a pretty competent job of adapting the game’s controls and options to better suit a modern console, prospective players should know that the Xbox 360 version of this game seems like an afterthought, at least as far as baseline functionality is concerned.

Testament of Sherlock HolmesDespite all that though (and likely owing to the relatively simple conventions of the adventure game genre), The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes is entirely functional. I don’t want that last paragraph to scare people off (at least not before I get to the next section of this review), so please know that even with the game’s obvious rough edges, it is without any crippling issues. Is it odd that a modern video game like this doesn’t include an autosave option, and that players are only given four manual save slots? Absolutely, but for the vast, vast majority of people, the systems in place here just work. This foundation may not be anything spectacular, but it’s enough to convey the game’s story, and that’s where The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes really shines.


The most impressive aspect of The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes is that it isn’t based on a tale written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, yet still manages to capture the spirit and tone of his novels almost exactly. As a fan of the original Holmes stories (and a massive fan of the BBC’s recent, phenomenal series Sherlock), I wouldn’t place it among the greatest stories the character has ever played a part in, but that shouldn’t be seen as a slight toward the game so much as praise for Doyle’s work. There is a good reason why this character has endured for over a century, and that appeal is on full display in The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes.

In The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes, you play as a combination of the titular detective and his partner, Dr. John Watson. Though the cases start out rather simply — “simply” in this case means that the first mystery you must solve involves a monkey stealing a priceless necklace and nearly lighting a house on fire — the game quickly turns into a complex web of mysterious events that cause the people of London to lose faith in the detective. Before the game comes to a close you’ll be accused of nearly all the crimes you’re attempting to solve, and only by proving your innocence can you bring the game’s shadowy antagonist to justice.

The Testament of Sherlock HolmesThat’s a relatively standard set up for an adventure game, but it allows the developers of The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes to explore almost every notable aspect of the game’s lead character. Long-time fans of Sherlock Holmes will find that this game is utterly drenched in fan service, from Holmes’ iconic deerstalker cap, to his dependence of cocaine, The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes offers an intensely well-researched portrait of its protagonist and demonstrates the affection that the game’s developers have in abundance for Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s most famous creation.

While this history lesson is quite helpful, the true crux of the game revolves around solving mysteries that are initially baffling. To do so, your character must explore every nook and cranny of his environment, interacting with notable objects and occasionally examining them in closer detail as fully rendered 3D objects. There’s nothing here that you haven’t seen in dozens of adventure games before, but aside from the recent Walking Dead episodic series from Telltale Games, The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes is as user-friendly and well-designed as any recent adventure title.

Unfortunately, and though this type of game design explicitly demands that it be played a certain way, The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes doesn’t quite grant players the feeling of actually deducing facts from otherwise baffling stacks of evidence. In effect, you can play through this game entirely by wandering aimlessly and clicking on anything that lights up. Things will move much faster if you pay attention to the clues presented by the game, but if you’re lazy or just uninterested, there’s no real need to assume the role of “detective” for this title.

Testament of Sherlock Holmes gameOddly, that doesn’t really detract from the experience (which is good given that I can’t come up with a viable way to accurately mimic Holmes’ uncanny ability to solve crimes in a video game). If anything, it feels like the gameplay mechanics are merely there because they add some sort of interactive element to what is otherwise a fantastic story. Holmes fans will adore the twists and turns in this game (and, likely, Holmes’ resemblance to famed actor Basil Rathbone), and to be totally honest with you that should have been the key selling point for The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes.


The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes is objectively not a great game. On almost every technical level it is overshadowed by other modern releases, and even on the PC, where its quirky design should feel more at home, it wouldn’t appeal to anyone who demands that all games use the absolute cutting edge of graphics technology. However, this game isn’t really aimed at the mainstream audience. Instead, it’s an obvious love letter to the character of Sherlock Holmes that pays him homage by crafting an excellent adventure akin to those that initially made him famous.

While this tale may have worked better in literary form, the minor technical failings of The Testament Of Sherlock Holmes should not be seen as enough to deter any Holmes fans from enjoying this story. If nothing else, this should serve as a perfect way to get your fix of the classic character during those periods where American fans have to wait months for new episodes of the aforementioned BBC series. In that regard, it’s a stunning success, even if it fails in many others.

Score: 6/10

(This game was reviewed using an Xbox 360 copy provided by publisher Atlus.)


Editors' Recommendations

Aaron Colter
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Best GPU deals: MSI, XFX, EVGA
An AMD graphics card in an external GPU enclosure.

The latest generation of graphics cards has really caused a lot of controversy, especially with the RTX 40-series cards becoming so expensive and raising the general cost of GPUs across the board. That means even AMD cards are a bit pricey nowadays, especially if you go to the higher end, so if you're aiming for a powerful gaming PC, you're going to have to spend some extra cash. That said, we've done our best to go out there and find the best GPU deals on the market so that you can save a bit extra, especially if you want to get the best. That said, if you feel that the prices are too high or that putting your own PC together is too much work, be sure to check out these gaming PC deals.
PELADN AMD Radeon RX 5500XT with 8GB GDDR6 -- $118, was $199

While this is an excellent deal already, it's made even better thanks to a $10 promotional gift card you'll get with your purchase -- usable at Peladn's online store. But even without that card, this GPU is ready to rock. It has 6GB of GDDR6 dedicated VRAM with a 1717MHz core clock speed and 1750MHz memory clock speed. It utilizes PCI Express 4.0, one of the latest standards, and employs a dual-fan cooling system with a few upgrades. For example, the built in cooling module heatsink, custom PCB board, digital HD interface, and aforementioned dual fan cooling system keep the performance high during use delivering stable frame rates. The unique white and orange styling doesn't hurt either, especially if you're going for a unique look inside your case.

Read more
This Lenovo starter gaming PC is 31% off today
Lenovo Legion Tower Gaming PC on a table.

The Lenovo Annual Sale is offering a $400 discount on the Lenovo Legion Tower 5 Gen 8, which has an estimated value of $1,270, so you'll only have to pay $870 for this excellent starter gaming PC. We're not sure how much time is remaining before the savings disappear or stocks get sold out though, so it's highly recommended that you add the gaming desktop to your cart and check out immediately because tomorrow may already be too late.

Why you should buy the Lenovo Legion Tower 5 Gaming PC
The Lenovo Legion Tower 5 Gen 8 is featured in our roundup of the best starter gaming PCs as the top entry-level option because its Nvidia GeForce RTX 3050 graphics card is the minimum standard for playing today's most popular titles. You won't be able to run the best PC games at their highest graphics settings, but with the gaming desktop's AMD Ryzen 5 7600 processor and 16GB of RAM, there will be no issues on low to medium settings. If you're not sure what to play, the Lenovo Legion Tower 5 Gen 8 comes with three months of Xbox Game Pass Ultimate, which will give you access to hundreds of titles.

Read more
5 gaming laptop deals worth buying before the end of the month
Razer Blade 17 angled view showing display and left side.

We see a refresh of gaming laptop deals at the end of each month, which gives gamers a new set of options for the next device. With February coming to a close, this may be your last chance to take advantage of the offers that we've rounded up as we're not sure if they'll still be around when March rolls in. Whether you want a budget-friendly gaming laptop or you're willing to make a significant investment, there's something for you in the bargains below, and once you're determined what to buy, it's highly recommended that you proceed with the purchase immediately while the discount is still online.
HP Victus 15 -- $550, was $800

The HP Victus 15 is featured in our list of the best budget gaming laptops as the top 15-inch option, as it offers decent performance at a relatively lower cost than its peers with the AMD Ryzen 5 7535HS processor, the Nvidia GeForce RTX 2050 graphics card, and 8GB of RAM. These specifications are enough to run the best PC games -- though you may have to go with low graphics settings for the more demanding titles. The gaming laptop also comes with a 15.6-inch Full HD display with a 144Hz refresh rate, and a 512GB SSD with Windows 11 Home pre-installed.

Read more