CEA’s ”Theft of Service’ bill fact sheet

The Consumer Electronics Association (CEA) today released the following fact sheet in order to clarify recent misinformation from the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) regarding its “modelstate communications security legislation.”

‘Theft of Service’s Bill Fact Sheet

Yesterday the MPAA attempted to defend its model state “theft of services” law with the following “assurances”:

The [model bill] is exclusively about stealing communications services. The legislation only provides for criminal and civil remedies if an individual steals a service offered for a fee, and expands the criminalization of electronic devices and software – beyond already outlawed illegal cable television devices, if such a device was specifically designed, distributed and marketed to steal communications services.

This statement provides only cold comfort to consumers, retailers and innovators.

First, what MPAA doesn’t say is that they have advocated an expansive definition of “stealing” that encompasses many legitimate consumer practices and expectations.

In a recent interview, the President and CEO of MPAA even stated that “Fair use is not a law…in the digital world; we don’t need back ups, because a digital copy never wears out.” Given MPAA’s views, it should be no surprise that their model legislation could criminalize normal fair use practices and subject honest consumers to massive civil liability.

Second, this over-reaching bill is in no way confined to “stealing”, even as broadly defined by the MPAA. The vast litany of prohibited actions includes receiving, acquiring, transmitting, possessing, retransmitting, manufacturing, distributing, developing, assembling, transferring, importing, offering and advertising, and even includes possessing plans or instructions, as well as assisting others in any of those acts.

Among the specific anti-consumer provisions are as follows:

* The bill has an undefined “intent to defraud” provision on which much of the “theft” limitation depends. Yet, many states have doctrines of “constructive fraud” which allow proof, even in criminal cases, with no showing of actual “intent” at all. Under such an interpretation, a consumer who attaches legal products to a broadband network could be subject to criminal penalties if the device is prohibited or not specifically permitted by the service contract.

* The bill addresses consumer acts pertaining to “transmission” and “retransmission,” which may occur after the content has been lawfully received by a consumer, yet would still be criminalized. This would make illegal certain “fair use” practices such as a consumer emailing a television program to himself or a family member.

* The bill is so extreme as to define devices possessed by one individual as “unlawful” based solely on subsequent usage by another individual. In other words, if a product is used by even one person to infringe, any other consumer or retailer in possession of that product could be subject to criminal penalties. These unknowing parties would then have to defend against criminal charges based on their “intent” as imputed by their mere possession or marketing of the products.

* The bill also would impose Draconian civil and criminal penalties that are potentially vastly disproportionate to the conduct of the person charged with its violations. Indeed, the inclusion of potentially massive civil liability has not existed in theft of services law prior to MPAA’s model bill. It appears the real intent is to intimidate and sue anyone who makes, sells or uses any product that the MPAA or other content providers do not like or approve of. The impact will be anti-consumer, anti-competitive and anti-innovation.

Having been rightfully denied anti-consumer legislation of this sort by Congress, MPAA has switched tactics in an attempt to convince state legislatures to turn honest consumers, retailers and manufacturers into criminal and civil defendants.

Along with a wide range of consumer, retailer and technology groups, CEA urges state lawmakers to reject this ill-considered legislation in order to protect consumers, technology manufacturers, retailers, and their states’ digital economies.

Features

Netflix’s latest price increase heralds the end of streaming’s golden age

Netflix’s recent price rise is just the latest in a string of signs that streaming’s golden age is nearly over. As more services enter the fray, content will be further partitioned, signaling the end of streaming’s good old days.
Mobile

It’s back! Here’s how to switch to Twitter’s reverse chronological feed

Twitter has finally brought back the reverse chronological feed, allowing you to see your feed based on the newest tweets, rather than using Twitter's algorithm that shows what it thinks you want to see. It's easy to switch.
Movies & TV

‘Sopranos’ prequel ‘The Many Saints of Newark’ adds ‘The Punisher’ star

The upcoming movie The Many Saints of Newark, based on HBO's hit series The Sopranos, will serve as a prequel to the show. It will focus on Tony Soprano as a boy, as well as the race riots that rocked Newark in 1967.
Home Theater

Looking to cut cable? Here’s everything you need to know about Pluto TV

Pluto TV offers plenty of entertainment in a fashion similar to live internet TV services, only at no cost — you don’t even need to register. Too good to be true? Here’s everything you need to know.
Home Theater

Want to mirror your smartphone or tablet onto your TV? Here's how

A vast arsenal of devices exists to allow sending anything on your mobile device to your TV. Our in-depth guide shows you how to mirror content from your smartphone or tablet to the big screen from virtually any device available.
Deals

Need a smart speaker? Amazon knocks $50 off Sonos Beam soundbar with Alexa

If you're looking to add some oomph to your home audio setup, then through February 3, the Alexa-enabled Sonos Beam is on sale for $50 off, bringing this excellent smart sound bar down to just $349 on Amazon.
Home Theater

Yamaha’s MusicCast Vinyl 500 turntable spreads analog joy throughout your home

It can be tough to listen to your favorite analog tunes anywhere besides the room where your turntable is located. With its MusicCast Vinyl 500 turntable, Yamaha allows you to stream your tunes throughout your home.
Home Theater

Walmart abandons its plans for a streaming Netflix killer

Rumored plans for a Walmart owned, Vudu-labeled Netflix streaming killer have been shelved according to a new report from CNBC. The billions it would have needed to invest in order to compete apparently gave the mega retailer cold feet.
Home Theater

Dolby’s secret recording studio app may soon exit stealth mode

In secret testing since June, Dolby's stealth recording and social network app may soon be ready to make an appearance. Dolby 234 blends unique noise-canceling tech with Instagram-like audio filters.
Home Theater

From the Roku Ultra to the Fire TV Cube, these are the best streaming devices

There are more options for media streamers than ever, so it’s more difficult to pick the best option. But that’s why we're here. Our curated list of the best streaming devices will get you online in no time.
Home Theater

Plex is the latest player to contemplate the subscription streaming game

With massive reach thanks to its client app being supported virtually every media device on the planet, Plex is now looking at the future of its media curation platform. A future that may include free and subscription services.
Home Theater

Here are some common AirPods problems, and how to fix them

Apple’s AirPods are among the best fully wireless earbuds we’ve seen, but they’re not perfect. If you’re having trouble, take a look at our guide to the most common problems and what you can do to fix them.
Deals

Here’s a look at the hottest 4K TV deals for January 2019

There's no doubt that a good 4K smart TV is the best way to take your home entertainment setup to the next level to enjoy all your favorite shows, movies, and games in glorious Ultra HD. We've got the best 4K TV deals right here.
Deals

Amazon knocks $50 off the Sonos Beam soundbar and smart speaker

If you're looking to add some oomph to your home audio setup, then through February 3, the Alexa-enabled Sonos Beam is on sale for $50 off, bringing this excellent sound bar down to just $349 on Amazon.