The difference between second screen and social TV apps is that there isn’t one

second screensIt’s time to talk about something we’re doing wrong. This might sound arbitrary and pedantic and like something only a handful of us care about, but it’s going to become more and more important, so let’s just get ahead of the curve and clarify something:

The second screen and social television are not the same thing. Except sometimes … when they are. Most of the time. Kind of. Maybe?

Digiday recently touched on the confusion in this terminology. We’re using the terms interchangeably but in reality, they’re defining two different sides of the evolving real-time TV market – however, there is ample overlap.

Second Screen generally refers to an application that complements your TV viewing. These apps can be social, but they aren’t necessarily. Lots of second screen apps allow you to dive deeper into the experience. For instance, ESPN apps that show you the stats of who’s playing, or apps for TV series that dive into the world of the characters.

Founder and CEO of Zeebox Anthony Rose says that in the company’s research, there were five key factors that consumers need in a second screen app:

  • Discovery. People need help finding and choosing what to watch on TV – plus, the ability for the app to work as a remote to control the TV.
  • Information. Supplementary content for whatever is on TV; i.e., character background stories, behind-the-scenes photos; IMDB info.
  • Participation. This is a little forward-thinking, but something game shows like American Idol are starting to do, wherein viewers can vote or in some way interact directly with what’s happening on the air (Choose Your Own Adventure for TV, essentially).
  • Shopping. This element would allow you to buy something you see on TV; if a commercial is advertising a new couch – and you want that couch – you can automatically hit a button to buy that couch. The realization of frictionless shopping.
  • And last but not least … Social. Consumers need to be able to connect and share with friends during and about TV shows.

Social TV itself, however, is still far, far more difficult (impossible, really) to define thanks to the relatively ambiguous, amorphous nature of all things social media-related. So really, instead of a need to define the difference between second screen and social TV apps, the question really is: What is social TV?

Anything “social” is overarching and vague, and social TV is no exception. Social interaction with television content is happening with and without apps specifically targeting this market. For instance, Facebook is a “social TV” app even though it never positioned itself as such. Same goes for Twitter. And Instagram. And Tumblr. But in a handful of ways, each of these are providing a social element to watching TV. Does that make them social TV apps? That’s for us to decide, but case in point: Pretty Little Liars.

“Social TV is a rubbish term. Please kill it.”

Pretty Little Liars, for instance, is a show with an incredibly active and tuned in social media following – in part, thanks to the Instagramming, Twittering, Facebooking obsessions of its young and digitally devoted cast. The Stars of the ABC Family show have active Twitter and Instagram accounts, post plenty of behind-the-scenes looks and interact with fans. According to a recent interview with Entertainment Weekly, there used to be a sign on set that asked people not to post to social media accounts, but after realizing it was adding to the hype instead of diminishing it, the sign was taken down.

The season 2 finale recently made “social TV” and Twitter history: 645,000 tweets were sent during the first showing of the episode, reaching a rate of 32,000 tweets per minute. In total, 1.6 million PLL-related tweets were sent by 667,000 users that day.  

There is a Shorty award for “The Best Prettylittleliars in Social Media” in which the most actively tweeting fan will win.

Clearly, PLL is social TV – but then take a look at some of the available second screen apps. The selection is fairly lacking.

“Social TV is effectively Twitter and Facebook,” Boxfish cofounder and CEO Eoin Dowling says. “There have been many attempts over the last couple of years to build businesses off the back of the social TV hype – most are now in the deadpool. The fact is that Twitter and Facebook own social TV. This has become more apparently with Twitter’s movements in the space – the Bluefin acquisition and deal with Nielsen are great moves toward monetizing their position. And they have a lot more to come. Facebook will be the dark horse here also, it has a great position and no doubt will reveal its intentions soon.”

“Either way, social TV is a rubbish term. Please kill it.”

Point taken: Social is a vertical of everything and anything that has to do with media (if this isn’t true for your media content, you’re officially doing it wrong).

“Tweeting ‘I’m watching this football game,’ is no more social than being stranded on an island and throwing out a message in a bottle saying ‘I’m stuck on this island.’”

Right now there are a disappointing amount of applications out there that throw a Twitter stream on the sidebar or include a “share” button that call themselves social, when really all that does is allow for passive activity – you can see what’s happening, but you can’t do much (or anything) about it. “The ‘second screen,’ be it tablet or smartphone or laptop, can and should serve as a conduit that facilities ‘social TV,’” TweetTV founder and CEO Bradley Markham says. “But the problem is that most of what is considered ‘social TV’ right now has little actual ‘social’ value. A second screen that offers time-synced content in relation to a TV show, for example, is not social.”

Really, the fact that we’re experiencing some confusion between second screen and social TV apps is because we’re still uncertain what qualifies as social. We instinctively know what isn’t social, but it’s become a broad, vague industry term that too many undeserving apps and services claim to offer. Slap on a share button and you’re good to go! Except that you’re not.

“Simply tweeting to say ‘I’m watching this football game,’ is no more social than being stranded on an island and throwing out a message in a bottle saying ‘I’m stuck on this island.’ That message wouldn’t be social until someone actually responded,” Markham explains.

Then there’s the fact that all of these apps can actually just be pulling us out of the viewing experience.

“There’s a ton of overlap between social TV and second screen apps,” says RUWT?! founder and CEO Mark Philip. “But to paint with broad strokes, in social TV I see the actual TV as the protagonist and the smartphone as the foil, while in second screen apps, the roles are actually reversed.”

“Our phones have intuitive, comfortable interfaces, but are filled with distractions that pull viewers away from the content on the TV,” he says. “As the ability to use your phone or tablet as your remote becomes more commonplace, the TV and the smartphone will become peers in the relationship, making the apps infinitely more useful to – and sought after by – users.”

As it goes with all things digital, we’re laying the tracks while driving the train. And it’s especially confusing because everyone is involved in this building process; it’s not just app developers and TV producers or networks, it’s anyone with a Tumblr account who knows how to make an animated GIF or who has the potent combination of bravado, sarcasm, and immunity to Twitter haters to start a parody account.

Admist all of this confusion, a few things are true: Consumers want to interact with TV, and they want to do it using popular social platforms. A good second screen app is going to know this, and leverage the mechanisms already making this happen. So pay attention to us, developers. We’re creating loads and loads of content and conversation for you. Less time spent trying to make a “social app” and using what’s already out there is a good starting point. 

Product Review

With more screen and 1 world-first feature, the Apple Watch still rules the wrist

Apple already ruled the smartwatch market with the Apple Watch Series 3, but the Series 4 elevates it to new levels with more screen, a sleeker design, and even an world-first electrocardiogram app that lets you keep tabs on your ticker.
Mobile

Google’s Family Link expands globally, now works on more devices

Google's Family Link app makes it easier for parents to keep track of their kids' smartphone usage. They can restrict them from downloading apps, see which services they use the most, and more. Here's everything you need to know.
Home Theater

What is MHL, exactly, and how does it work with your TV?

There are more ways to mirror your smartphone or tablet to your TV than you might think. Check out our rundown of MHL for everything you need to know about the wired protocol and its myriad uses.
Home Theater

Time for a TV upgrade? Here’s what you need to know about 4K Ultra HD TV

Ultra HD 4K has quickly taken over the world of TVs. But what is Ultra HD 4K, how does it work, and most importantly, should you upgrade, or keep your old TV? We explain it all right here.
Home Theater

Dish Network or DirecTV: Which is the better choice for you?

So, you’ve chosen to go with a satellite television provider. Check out our quick rundown of what both Dish Network and DirecTV offer in terms of content, hardware, and pricing, and why you might choose them over streaming services.
Home Theater

Pandora takes aim at Spotify’s Release Radar with smart playlist The Drop

Pandora is debuting its own answer to Spotify’s Release Radar in the form of The Drop, a weekly personalized playlist for Premium subscribers full of new music based on what they already love.
Home Theater

Vizio is bringing Dolby Atmos to your living room without any setup headaches

Vizio’s new home theater sound systems offer all of the good parts of Dolby Atmos object-based surround sound to your living room without the troublesome setup chores of some other systems.
Home Theater

HDMI 2.0b is a whole lot more than just a connection to your TV

HDMI 2.0b is the backbone for many of the latest updates in 4K UHD technology. And while a new cable standard can often involve a bunch of changes for consumers, that is not the case this time around.
Home Theater

What’s new on Amazon Prime Video (October 2018)

Amazon Prime Video adds new titles each month that are available for free to all Prime members. Check out our list to find all the content hitting Amazon Prime Video in September and October 2018, from new comedies to terrifying horror…
Deals

Black Friday 2018: When it happens and where to find the best deals

Black Friday is the biggest shopping holiday of the year, and it will be here before you know it. If you can't wait until November 23 to start formulating a shopping plan, we've got you covered.
Home Theater

Sol Republic delivers a long-awaited true wireless sequel with its Amps Air 2.0

Sol Republic is delivering a long-awaited sequel in its Amps Air true wireless earbuds in the Amps Air 2.0, which feature Bluetooth 5.0 and an IPX4 rating alongside the awesome charging case that fans of the original model loved.
Movies & TV

Brie Larson powers up in the first 'Captain Marvel' trailer

Academy Award winner Brie Larson will play Captain Marvel in the upcoming Marvel Studios movie hitting theaters in March 2019. Here's everything we know about Marvel's first female-led superhero movie.
Movies & TV

2018 Emmy Awards winners: The night of ‘Mrs. Maisel’ and diversity

The 2018 Primetime Emmy Awards, hosted by Colin Jost and Michael Che, was full of laughs and drama, as well as some surprises. Here is the full list of nominees, winners, and highlights from the show.
Home Theater

Bowers & Wilkins’ upgraded 600 Series speakers hit stores

Bowers & Wilkins has revamped its entry-level speaker lineup, borrowing some goodness from the company's flagship 800 Series speakers, which brings a more refined sound signature while keeping impressively low price points. What's not to…