Skip to main content

If you can’t beat ’em, pick on someone smaller! Networks go after Aereo copycat

filmon responds to 90000 fine alki david
FilmOn founder Alki David at his broadcast television antenna farm

Aereo has been expanding its services into new markets in a very strategic way, coordinating its expansion and its legal defense at the same time.  But those efforts could be foiled due to the legal entanglements a smaller but similar service in California is involved in. Depending on the outcome of deliberations in the U.S. Court of Appeals in Pasadena, California, Aereo could find itself headed to the Supreme Court. 

Aereo, which leases out tiny HDTV antennas and uses them to stream live, over-the-air network television broadcasts via the Internet, spent a fair amount of time in court defending itself before it was handed a legal victory by the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in New York. Since receiving the courts blessing, Aereo has slowly but steadily expanded beyond NYC into Boston and Atlanta, and is set to start operations in Chicago next month

Meanwhile, broadcast networks including Fox, ABC, NBC and CBS are going after a much smaller, Beverly Hills-based company which now goes by the name FilmOn  (the company’s name for its service was Aereokiller). The company, which provides essentially the same service as Aereo, was shut down in January 2012 by a federal court in Los Angeles in response to Fox’s request for an injunction. Judge George Wu of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California ruled that the service infringed on broadcasters’ copyrights. Today, FilmOn’s legal team gathered before the U.S. Court of Appeals in Pasadena to square off with the big broadcast networks.

If the judge decides to uphold Fox’s earlier victory, it will have ruled in contradiction to the decision made by the appeals court in New York on what is essentially the same technology. If that happens, the issue could very well be taken to the Supreme Court, and Aereo along with it.

At the heart of the legal matter is the interpretation of the public performance clause of the Copyright Act of 1976. Aereo’s lawyers maintain that the company’s service amounts to a private performance. Networks consider it a rebroadcasting, and therefore a public performance. But it could be argued that this really comes down to re-transmission fees, which Aereo doesn’t pay. If Aereo can lure away enough cable and satellite subscribers, it will have a real impact on broadcaster revenue. 

Before Aereo gets too wrapped up with preparing for a Supreme Court battle, it will need to take care of unfinished business in New York. Its early victory there simply kept it from being shut down. Aereo’s request that the case be dismissed entirely has not yet been decided on.

Editors' Recommendations

SiriusXM now has an app for Vizio TVs
SiriusXM app on Vizio Smartcast.

If you have a Vizio television but have been dying to play your SiriusXM satellite radio subscription directly through it, you're in luck. There's now a SiriusXM app for the Vizio Smatcast platform.

“Vizio users can now access their favorite on-the-go programs directly on the biggest screen in their homes,” Katherine Pond, Group Vice President of Platform Content & Partnerships at Vizio, said in a press release. “From podcasts to music, we are happy to bring SiriusXM’s audio and video entertainment to millions of Vizio users across the U.S.”

Read more
YouTube TV did 4K sports right — so maybe it’s time to cancel it
World Cup in 4K on YouTube TV.

Let us stipulate a few things: When it comes to video, higher resolution is better. Sure, there are diminishing returns — I wouldn't go out and buy an 8K television just yet. But going from 720p to 1080p is a huge leap in quality. Maybe a little less so when you go from 1080p to 4K, but that's also very much going to depend on your circumstances — television size, what room you're in, etc.

And one more stipulation: 4K for World Cup 2022 was pretty much a necessity. If you've ever watched live sports in 4K, you probably already knew that. FuboTV has had some live sports for years now, and YouTube TV — which is the most popular live service in the U.S., and more than five times larger than FuboTV with more than 5 million subscribers at last count — has had it as an option since the summer of 2021. You also could watch in 4K via the Fox Sports app, provided that you already had a subscription to a cable, satellite, or streaming service.

Read more
How much is Apple Music, and how can you get it for free?
Someone using Apple Music's app on an Android smartphone.

For iPhone or Mac owners, it’s only natural to be curious about Apple Music. In comparison to music streaming sites like Spotify or Pandora, Apple Music can feel a bit mysterious.

There are some limited-time "free" options and a free trial to check out Apple Music, but if you stick with the service long enough, you will end up paying. Anyone who signs up will have to pay a monthly fee to use the service. Considering that Apple Music offers live radio shows and interesting exclusives, this fee may be well worth it to the right buyers. Let's take a closer look at how much Apple music is.
Apple Music plans

Read more