A.I. will make smart homes autonomous, but don’t expect perfection or privacy

smart home control

In today’s smart home, a weekday routine might have the alarm clock going off at 7 a.m., the shades raising, the thermostat turning up the heat a few degrees, and the lights turning on in the bathroom. But these scheduled tasks aren’t much help on a morning when you have to wake up an hour earlier to catch a flight, unless your hub has access to your calendar and is smart enough to trigger your wake-up sequence at 6 a.m. Here’s the question: Should your hub be able to ask you first?

One of the big questions with smart home technology is, “how much of this should be user-driven versus A.I.-driven?” said Mark Spates, Google’s product lead for smart home, during his keynote talk at the 2018 Connections Conference in San Francisco on May 22. And, in order to get to the level where devices start to act like the user without any input, the reliability has to be 100 percent, something that’s currently not happening, he said.

How much of the smart home should be user-driven versus A.I. driven?

The idea of sentient bots that seamlessly control every aspect of your life is hyperbole, iRobot’s Chris Jones said on a panel about artificial intelligence.

“That’s not something I’m worried about or I see being applicable to our products anytime soon,” Jones said. He called machine learning, A.I., and deep learning “very specific tools that are very good at some things but aren’t the solution to all problems.”

For the moment, device makers often use A.I. for mundane uses, like figuring out how often their products are offline.

irobot smart home

“You’d be astonished at how abysmal the connectivity rates of IoT products are today,” said Aditya Pendyala, co-founder of Mnubo, which helps companies analyze their Internet of Things data. This is where A.I. could help figure out how to optimize software and setups to make more reliable products, he added.

“A lot of it we still don’t understand how it works or why it works on a fundamental level,” said Chris Mitchell, CEO of Audio Analytic.

A.I. still depends on humans – for better or worse

There are still humans behind the scenes, making decisions and fixing mistakes. The A.I. Is only as good as its input and the parameters people assign. For example, Mitchell’s company has a database of sounds that it uses to create profiles of glass breaking or dogs barking for smart devices, so they can recognize them when they happen in the real world and send the user an alert.

Sentient bots that seamlessly control every aspect of your life is hyperbole.

One company that uses the software noticed a large number of smoke alarms were going off in a certain part of France. Turns out that there weren’t actually fires; instead, a regional parrot’s squawk matched a manufacturer’s alarm sound closely enough that it was fooling the sensors.

Humans are fallible as well, and device makers can frame crucial parts of their systems around biases and outlooks that are far from universal.

“Americans are very tied to the idea of liberty, independence, and distrust of government. Many historical factors go into that idea of protecting one’s data,” Intel’s Melissa Gregg told Digital Trends. “We have to be careful as engineers and architects building this technology that we don’t presume that our point of view on privacy is going to hold to everyone.”

schlage smart lock alexa

While the machines aren’t ready, Gregg thinks we’re not really equipped, either. “We still don’t have a very good attitude or even psychological preparedness for when a machine has agency,” she said, though she admits there are times when she’d like the help.

Privacy or Personalization?

The price for that assistance is often the privacy some of us hold dear. When it comes to discrete tasks, though, some see the tradeoff as worthwhile. For example, your smart stove could probably be a better judge of what “simmer” means than you and could adjust the burner to the proper temperature if you share your beef stew recipe with it.

Maybe you don’t care that your appliance maker now knows you make the Barefoot Contessa’s stew. Of course, if it’s your grandmother’s secret recipe that she gave you on her deathbed, maybe you’ll just set the time and temperature yourself. But if you make that recipe every Sunday around 6 p.m., maybe after a month your stove will just start heating up to 275 degrees when you turn it on Sunday evenings and will shut off without you having to put the timer on.

With A.I.’s limitations keeping full smart-home autonomy at bay, we still have time to weigh its potentials against its pitfalls, as long as the right people are in the room asking these questions.

Smart Home

4 small appliances that have changed the way we cook food (for the better)

These are exciting times for home cooks seeking to advance or simplify their technique in the kitchen, thanks in part to four small appliances that have made a splash in the past few years. Here’s why you should consider buying them.
Product Review

Packed with features, the Ring Spotlight Cam Wired makes home security a breeze

With an integrated spotlight, crystal-clear video, and color night vision, this device makes home security a cinch. Here's why we like the Ring Spotlight Cam Wired as a great choice for outdoor home security.
Smart Home

Language barrier? Psh. Here's how to make your Google Home an ace translator

You can now use interpreter mode on your Google Home devices. This means, you can use your Google Home device to translate conversations in real-time. Here's how to use interpreter mode.
Smart Home

Let a robot do your chores! Here are the best robot vacuums for 2019

Robot vacuums are a convenient way to tidy up your home and minimize your weekly to-do list. From a top-of-the-line model to a handy budget option, here are the best robot vacuums you can buy right now.
Smart Home

Check out the largest pools in the world - and how you can get there

From Egypt to Singapore to California, here's a pictorial breakdown of some of the biggest and largest pools in the world. Many of these pools are so big that you can even kayak and windsurf on them.
Product Review

From tables to porches, Ring's Stick Up Cam watches wherever you want

Ring’s latest home security camera offers more versatility than ever before, with the ability to mount it, set it on a table, or put it inside or outside. We got a chance to test it out. Here’s how it went.
Product Review

Ring Video Doorbell 2 is the simplest entry into a smarter doorway

The Ring Video Doorbell 2 may lack the style and sophistication of premium door-dingers, but few can match its simplicity and versatility. The device, available in both wired and wireless configurations, is easy to set up and adds instant…
Smart Home

Consumer groups call out retailers in a bid for better IoT security

Consumer groups posted a "Dear retailer" letter on February 12 that called out Walmart, Best Buy, Amazon, and Target, shaming the companies for selling insecure smart home devices.
Deals

The best Presidents’ Day sales 2019: Amazon, Walmart, Dell, and more

Presidents' Day sales are a great chance to score electronics, clothing, home and office stuff, and other goodies at a discount. We’ve smoked out a large handful of the best of these Presidents' Day deals, from tech to bedding, to help…
Deals

Walmart drops a killer Instant Pot deal for Presidents’ Day weekend

With the Walmart Presidents' Day sale going on right now, you can actually pick up the Instant Pot Lux60 6-quart programmable pressure cooker for just $69 -- $30 off its normal price.
Smart Home

Walmart slashes prices on Google Home during its Presidents’ Day sale

Walmart slashes prices on Google Home during its Presidents' Day sale. Whether you're taking your first step in configuring a smart home or expanding to every room, Walmart has excellent sale prices for all the key components.
Deals

Walmart Presidents’ Day sale: Instant Pot, Google Home, and 4K TV deals

Presidents' Day weekend is one of the best times of the year to find deep discounts on 4K TVs, laptops, Instant Pots, clothes, mattresses, and furniture. And Walmart is offering deals on all of those things and more.
Smart Home

What exactly is Alexa? Where does she come from? And how does she work?

While "Alexa" has become synonymous with products like the Amazon Echo, you can't actually go out and buy an "Alexa." So what is Alexa? How does she work? Here's everything you need to know about Amazon's virtual assistant.
Smart Home

Clean up with these Presidents’ Day sales on washers and dryers

Clean up with these Presidents' Day weekend sales on washers and dryers. We picked the top washers and dryers from six major online merchants, but there are many more choices. Altogether the six sites have 920 washers and dryers on sale.