Skip to main content

Nest thermostats fail to save energy as advertised, class-action lawsuit claims

class action lawsuit nest claims thermostats dont work advertised thermostat
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Check out our full written Nest Thermostat review.

Chances are that you’ve heard plenty people sing the praises of Nest’s energy-saving thermostats before, but not everyone out there is so satisfied with the award-winning products. Earlier this week, a Maryland man filed a multimillion-dollar class-action lawsuit against the company, alleging that its ultra-popular Learning Thermostats are defective, and fail to accurately measure a room’s temperature.

In the complaint, Justin Darisse said he purchased one of the thermostats online for $249.99 after watching Nest promotional videos and seeing advertisements that suggested installing the device would save him money. After testing the device firsthand, he found that faulty temperature readings taken by the thermostat actually caused him to pay more for energy costs, not less.

He alleges that,”Nest’s base and faceplate heat up, which causes Nest’s temperature reading to be from two to ten degrees higher than the actual ambient temperature in the surrounding room. This defect prevents the thermostat from working properly. As a result, Nest users do not experience the advertised energy savings.”

The complaint seeks more than $5 million for Darisse and the hundreds of thousands of other consumers who’ve purchased one of Nest’s thermostats, alleging that the company has violated warranty and consumer protection laws. Five million dollars is likely a drop in the bucket for the company, which was recently acquired by Google for $3.2 billion back in Janaury. But if the lawsuit sticks – and there’s no guarantee it will, at this point – it’ll likely cause a significant amount of damage to the company’s image.

 You can read the full complaint, which was first spotted by Law360, for yourself here.

[via GigaOM]

Editors' Recommendations

Drew Prindle
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Drew Prindle is an award-winning writer, editor, and storyteller who currently serves as Senior Features Editor for Digital…
The 4 best smart thermostats in 2024
A person operating the Google Nest thermostat.

A lot of folks may feel that a smart thermostat device is just a gimmick for the lazy that lets you control it remotely, but there are actually quite a lot of good things when it comes to smart thermostats. Depending on which model you buy and how much money you spend, there can be some significant savings, especially if you spring for the kind that learns your patterns and adjusts the temperature to eat up less electricity. Some thermostats even know what time of day electricity is expensive and adjust to use less of it to help bring your costs down.

As such, if you rely heavily on your HVAC, then having a smart thermostat can save you money and add a ton of convenience, even if you don't go for one of the smarter ones. Just knowing your energy usage over time can help you adjust and spend less money while also being a bit more eco-friendly. While there are a ton of options, we've collected four of our favorites below across various budgets and features, so be sure to check things out thoroughly and be sure a smart thermostat supports your HVAC system before taking the plunge.
The Best Smart Thermostats in 2024

Read more
Echo Show 8 vs. Nest Hub: Does Amazon or Google offer the best smart display?
Google Nest Hub 2nd Gen on table.

Anyone in the market for a reasonably priced smart display has probably stumbled across the Echo Show 8 and Nest Hub. Both clock in at under $150 (often less when on sale) yet provide homes with many of the same features found on premium alternatives like the Nest Hub Max and Echo Show 10.

But is the Echo Show 8 better than the Nest Hub? And what exactly is the difference between these two smart displays? Here's a comprehensive look at both to help you decide which one to bring into your smart home.
Pricing and design

Read more
Nest Hub Max vs. Echo Show 10: which is the better smart display?
The Nest Hub Max on a table.

The world of smart displays is dominated by two companies -- Amazon and Google. Amazon is responsible for the Echo Show 10, while Google is behind the Nest Hub Max. Both offer large screens, access to a massive roster of apps, and the ability to connect (and control) the rest of your smart home. There are a lot of similarities between the two popular displays, but there are a few key differences you should be aware of before adding one to your home.

Here's a closer look at the Echo Show 10 and Nest Hub Max to help you decide which is best.
Pricing and design

Read more