Court Finds That Bloggers are not Protected by Journalistic Legal Shields

Bloggers may be in trouble. is reporting that the New Jersey case of Too Much Media v. Hale have found against the blogger, and find that bloggers are not protected as journalists. It is only the second appellate ruling in any state to address the legal status of bloggers.court finds that bloggers are not protected by journalistic legal shields house

“Simply put, new media should not be confused with news media,” the court ruling stated. It went on to say that the blogger in question, “exhibited none of the recognized qualities or characteristics traditionally associated with the news process, nor has she demonstrated an established connection or affiliation with any news entity.”

The news is troubling for inhabitants of the blogosphere who have long  blended the art of writing actual news with the ability to freely say anything they like with almost no oversight or legal responsibility. It has been a mixed blessing that allowed opinions to be freely discussed, but the inevitable downside has always been the potential abuses it can cause.

The lawsuit stems from a case where blogger Shelle Hale was sued for defamation over statements she made on the website, a page known primarily in the adult entertainment circles. Hale accused Too Much Media, a software provider that primarily works with Internet porn providers, of engaging in fraud and “illegal and unethical use of technology.” Halle claims that the company profited from the theft of email addresses stolen by hackers in 2007.

Hale went on to set up the website She then informed the Attorney General of Washington, her home state, of her intentions to further investigate the potential criminal activities in the porn world and then inform the public.

Too Much Media sued Hale for defamation and demanded to know her sources. Hale moved for a protective order under the journalistic shield that allows reporters the protection of not releasing their sources. The claim was denied in June of 2009, and Hale appealed. A further appeal was recently dismissed by the New Jersey court of appeals.

Appellate Division Judge Anthony Parrillo stated in the decision that Hale “took no notes of conversations, meetings or interviews with contacts or sources, never asked the company principals for their version of the security breach incident and did not provide details about any fact-checking on information she collected.”

The ruling also states that the website she posted to,, is essentially a message board that anyone can post to, and so if the website were a newspaper, Halle’s posts would be the equivalent of an opinion based letter to the editor.

The ruling clears the way for Too Much Media to press on with its lawsuit and to depose Hale on her sources. Halle’s lawyers are considering the ruling, and may try a further appeal.

A California appellate court also ruled on an Internet blogger that requested to be protected as a journalist. Its rulings contradict the New Jersey courts, as the Californian judges upheld the legal rights of the blogger to refuse a subpoena to name the sources of an Apple-Insider-based news leak.

Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: heat-powered watches, phone cases with reflexes

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!

Apple banned from distributing some iPhone models in Germany

Apple is following the FTC's lead and has sued Qualcomm for a massive $1 billion in the U.S., $145 million in China, and also in the U.K., claiming the company charged onerous royalties for its patented tech.
Movies & TV

From premiere date to footage: Here's all we have on 'Game of Thrones' season 8

With the eighth and final season looming, Game of Thrones fever has officially become a pandemic. Our list of all the relevant news and rumors will help make the wait more bearable, if you don't mind spoilers.

Muscle cars, trucks, and EVs roared into the subdued 2019 Detroit Auto Show

The 2019 Detroit Auto Show was the quietest edition of the event in recent memory, but that doesn't mean nothing significant happened inside the Cobo Center. Here are the new cars and concepts we saw at the show.
Smart Home

GHSP makes a (back)splash with its touchscreen concept kitchen

One of the coolest concept kitchens from CES 2019 came from GHSP. It created a backsplash entirely made of touchscreens. That means the control panel for your kitchen is accessible no matter where you are.
Product Review

Kwikset Kevo Contemporary review

Tired of carrying around keys? Make keyless entry so easy that all you have to do is have your phone nearby to open the door. It’s a little pricey, but sleek lines and simple features make the Kwikset Kevo Contemporary a great choice for…
Health & Fitness

In search of the fountain of youth, beauty companies turn to tech

Beauty tech is a fairly new concept, but at CES 2019, companies such as Olay, L’Oreal, and Neutrogena were fully embracing it with all kinds of gadgets that promise to give you glowing skin.
Smart Home

Airbnb says sorry to guest for how it dealt with undisclosed security camera

An Airbnb guest recently found a surveillance camera in his rental apartment that hadn't been properly disclosed in the listing. The firm admits its initial response to the guest's complaint was poor, but has since made amends.
Smart Home

Thinking of buying an Instant Pot? Here's what you need to know

The Instant Pot is a powerful kitchen appliance that does everything from pressure cook to to slow cook to steam. Heck, you can even make yogurt in it. Here's all you need to know about the magic device.
Smart Home

Want a smarter home? Ditch the keys with these great smart locks

A good smart lock should offer a combination of security and convenience. Fortunately, these devices keep your home protected, your family safe, and your belongings secure from possible intruders.
Smart Home

The best sous vide machines cook your food perfectly, every single time

Want to make four-star meals from the comforts of your own kitchen? Here are the best sous vide machines available right now, whether you prefer simple immersion circulators or something more complex.
Smart Home

Busted: Facebook Portal gets 5-star reviews from company employees

It's fair to say that Facebook's Portal smart display received a tepid response at launch, so it was something of a surprise to see lots of glowing reviews of the device on Amazon. Turns out some were written by Facebook workers.
Smart Home

Idaho mother says her child’s light-up sippy cup exploded

After a mother filled a Nuby insulated light-up cup with milk, the cup allegedly exploded. The incident caused burns to the mother's hand and face and a stinging sensation in her lungs that required a trip to the hospital.
Smart Home

Project Alias is a ‘smart parasite’ that stops smart speakers from listening

Two designers chose to do something about nosy smart speakers. The result is Project Alias, a "smart parasite" that whispers nonsense to Google Home and Alexa until it hears a specific wake word.