Skip to main content

Android beats iPhone 4 in web test (that may be totally wrong)

chrome-vs-safari-browser-Android-iPhone-4A study by web optimization company Blaze shows that websites load 52 percent faster when using phones with Google’s Android 2.3 operating system than Apple’s iPhone 4 loaded with iOS 4.3. Both of the latest updates for Android and iOS focused on improvements to their JavaScript engines and faster browsing.

Good news for Android, right? Not necessarily. It’s possible that the Blaze’s entire test is entirely flawed.

First, the test: Blaze conducted what it calls the “largest ever research study of smart phone browser performance,” carried out in order to “measure the true mobile browsing experience.” That included 45,000 page loads of websites of Fortune 1000 companies using a Nexus S and an iPhone 4. Blaze analyzed the results to discover that Android loaded websites a “whopping” 52 percent faster on average than the iPhone 4.

According to the study, Android 2.3 had a median load time of 2.144 seconds, compared to iOS 4.3’s median load time of 3.254 seconds. For websites optimized for mobile devices, Android was only 3 percent faster. But for non-mobile websites, Android clocked in at 59 percent faster than the iPhone.

“”We were very surprised by the results,” said Blaze CTO and co-founder Guy Podjarny, “We assumed that it would be closer race and that the latest JavaScript speed improvements would have a more material impact on performance. The fact that Android beat iPhone by such a large margin was not expected.”

The problem with Blaze’s test, says The Loop‘s Jim Dalrymple, is that “the study is flawed.”

In the Blaze study, the speed measurement “was done using the custom apps which use the platform’s embedded browser. This means WebView (based on Chrome) for Android, and UIWebView (based on Safari) for iPhone.”

Unfortunately for Android, the UIWebView didn’t actually receive any of the performance-enhancing updates in the 4.3 upgrade that the Safari browser did receive. That means the browser Blaze used in the test didn’t have any of the JavaScript speed improvements.

“Obviously someone is looking to make a mountain out of a molehill,” analyst Michael Gartenberg tells The Loop. “It’s not an apples to apples test.”

So is Android 2.3 really faster than iPhone 4.3? Maybe — but this test shouldn’t be the final word on the matter.

Update: Apple spokesperson Trudy Muller has issued a statement to Ars Technica about the test, which essentially echos The Loop‘s Dalrymple and analyst Gartenberg. It reads: “Their testing is flawed because they didn’t actually test the Safari web browser on the iPhone. Instead they only tested their own proprietary app which uses an embedded web viewer that doesn’t take advantage of Safari’s web performance optimizations. Despite this fundamental testing flaw, they still only found an average of a second difference in loading web pages.”

Editors' Recommendations

Andrew Couts
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Features Editor for Digital Trends, Andrew Couts covers a wide swath of consumer technology topics, with particular focus on…
There’s a big problem with the iPhone’s Photos app
The Apple iPhone 15 Plus's gallery app.

While my primary device these days continues to be my iPhone 15 Pro, I’ve dabbled with plenty of Android phones since I’ve been here at Digital Trends. One of my favorite brands of phone has been the Google Pixel because of its strong suite of photo-editing tools and good camera hardware.

Google first added the Magic Eraser capability with the Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro, which is a tool I love using. Then, with the Pixel 8 series, Google added the Magic Editor, which uses generative AI to make edits that wouldn’t be possible otherwise. There are also tools like Photo Unblur, which is great for old photographs and enhancing images that were captured with low-quality sensors.

Read more
How to use iMessage on an Android phone or tablet
iMessage on an iPhone 14 Pro Max, plus iMessage on an Android phone using the Beeper app.

One of the big draws of iPhone and Mac is the iMessage software. This texting app makes it easy to stay connected to friends and family, and many users point to it as a key reason they stay within the Apple ecosystem – venture off to Android, and you'll be stuck with third-party apps or standard text chats.

However, that's not actually the case anymore. While Apple's iMessage software is exclusive to iOS and you won't find it in the Google Play Store, a new app called Beeper lets you access the iMessage platform. The universal chat app works with a variety of texting software beyond iMessage, making it a one-stop-shop for all your communication needs.

Read more
10 iPhone productivity apps you need to download right now
iPhone 14 Pro showing the Moon always-on screen, held in a man's hand.

If you're anything like us, your Apple iPhone is a beast with multiple uses. It can go from an email-firing machine to a dedicated Netflix device in seconds and then into playing video games just as fast. But just because it can do all of those things doesn't mean it couldn't stand a little fine-tuning when it comes to optimizing it for productivity.

"Productivity" can mean a lot of things, whether it's sending emails, making tweaks to documents and spreadsheets, or just planning for your day ahead. Whatever being productive means to you, there are apps that will make it easier. Here are 10 iPhone productivity apps you need to download today.
Todoist
The best to-do app

Read more