Skip to main content

Apple balks at $138,000 bill from court-appointed ebook watchdog, files complaint

Apple iBooks Lawsuit Tim Cook
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Back in July, a court ruled Apple had conspired to fix ebook prices, and part of its punishment was to have an appointed watchdog come in and check it followed antitrust rules. The man put in charge of the operating was one Michael Bromwich, an attorney with experience in the field, having kept an eye on offshore drilling platforms after the Gulf of Mexico spill in 2010.

However, Apple isn’t pleased with Michael Bromwich, and has filed a complaint with the courts. Apple’s problem comes from having to pay Bromwich a fee for the pleasure of his company, a figure it describes as, “extraordinary,” and higher than any lawyer has ever demanded from the firm.

Recommended Videos

So, what charge has made the world’s most valuable technology firm balk? According to the filing, Bromwich charges $1,100 per hour, plus a 15 percent administration fee, and another $1,000 for his legal support team. In the first two weeks of his appointment, Bromwich presented a bill for $138,432 to Apple. According to this report, that’s what a federal judge earns in nine months. Seeing as Bromwich is overseeing Apple’s policies and procedures for two years, if these bills continue, Apple will end up paying more than $7 million for his services.

Apple argues that as Bromwich was appointed by the judge, he’s the only game in town, and appears to be taking full advantage of the fact in his fees. As Apple can’t replace Bromwich, its only recourse is to file a complaint with the court. In addition to having an issue over fees, Apple’s also unhappy with his request to interview various top executives in the company, including Tim Cook and Jony Ive. These chats would take place without legal representation, and the conversations relayed back to Judge Denise Cote, who ruled on the case.

The filing says Bromwich is, “Operating in an unfettered and inappropriate manner,” to which the attorney responded he has seen, “Little reciprocity and instead a consistent pattern of delay, unresponsiveness and lack of cooperation,” from the firm. He’s due to visit Apple this week, and we doubt it’ll be a very pleasant occasion for anyone involved.

Apple’s complaint joins its appeal against the original decision, and it denies any involvement in price fixing.

Andy Boxall
Andy is a Senior Writer at Digital Trends, where he concentrates on mobile technology, a subject he has written about for…
Leaked OnePlus timeline suggests at least four new devices this year
A person holding the OnePlus 13.

OnePlus has a lot of different things in the oven right now, and a newly-leaked roadmap suggests there could be a new device in April, May, October, and November. The leak comes via Oneline Technology on Weibo and seems to confirm several expected launches, including the OnePlus 13 Mini as the OnePlus 13T.

The post lists the four devices as the OnePlus 13T, the Ace 5S, the OnePlus 14, and the OnePlus Ace 6 and Ace 6 Pro. The tipster says the products are "temporarily" named and are likely to change, so the exact names aren't yet confirmed. If the company does go with the 13T naming scheme, it will be the first time since the OnePlus 10T released in 2022.

Read more
T-Mobile satellite-to-phone service opens for all, and free until July
Showcase of T-Mobile Starlink service on an iPhone.

Two years ago, T-Mobile inked a deal with SpaceX to enable network connectivity via the Starlink constellation of satellites. Late in 2024, the carrier opened registrations for beta testing its direct-to-cell satellite service. Today, the company aired a Super Bowl ad and announced that the beta testing is now open to everyone.

The coolest part is that T-Mobile will offer free access for all registrations until July. Once the beta freebie is phased out, the service will be bundled at no extra cost for subscribers on the Go5G Next plan covering individual and business customers.

Read more
The Galaxy S25 Edge may be even slimmer than we expected
Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge next to the Galaxy S24 and Galaxy S25 molds

The clue about what makes the Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge special is in the name, but exactly how slim are we talking? The most up-to-date speculation puts the phone at a mere 5.84mm thick, even slimmer than has been suggested already. It brings the device’s dimensions far closer to some of the thinnest phones ever made.

Until now, the Galaxy S25 Edge -- previously known as the Galaxy S25 Slim -- was expected to be 6.4mm thick, which although definitely thin, wasn’t groundbreaking. The latest comes from well-known phone leaker Ice Universe, apparently quoting another well-known phone leaker, OnLeaks. In a message on the Chinese social network Weibo, it’s stated the Edge’s dimensions will be 158.2 x 75.5 x 5.84mm.

Read more