Apple may have provided flawed evidence to European judge in Samsung Tab 10.1 case

By Mike Dunn August 15, 2011

Apple’s case against Samsung is based on the fact that it believes the Samsung Tab 10.1 looks too much like its iPad. In the evidence provided by Apple to a European judge, the company included a side-by-side picture of the iPad and Tab 10.1 that might not be as accurate as possible. The picture in question has both products side by side, and they look strikingly similar in size and shape, which is why the Samsung tablet is currently banned from being sold in most European countries.

It appears that the picture of the Tab 10.1 has been altered in that picture, and now looks more square shaped than it actually is. The Apple iPad has a 4:3 aspect ratio and is slightly more square shaped than the Tab 10.1, which has a widescreen 16:10 aspect ratio, but in the picture they look nearly identical. It looks as though the bottom edge of the Tab 10.1 is missing, which is why the aspect ratios of the two devices look so similar. In the altered picture included in the lawsuit, the Tab 10.1 aspect ratio is closer to the iPads than it is to its original ratio.

We have yet to hear a response from Apple or its lawyers about the issue, but are very interested in what they have to say. We also do not yet know if the same picture was used in Apple’s case blocking the Tab 10.1 in Australia.

It is too soon to know if the picture was altered on purpose or not, but either way it seems as though this situation is far from over. In a case that hinges on how similar two products look, this might be a pretty damaging hole in Apple’s case.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Mike graduated from University of Arizona with a degree in poetry, and made his big break by writing love sonnets to the…

Mobile

Apple may do the unthinkable — allow third-party iPhone app stores

App Store displayed on an iPhone 14 Pro against a pink background

Ever since 2008, Apple has only allowed its own App Store on the iPhone. In the past, if you wanted alternative digital storefronts, you’d have to jailbreak your device. But in response to impending regulations from the European Union, Apple may be allowing alternative app stores on the iPhone and iPad in the near future — potentially as soon as iOS 17 in 2023.

According to a report from Bloomberg’s Mark Gurman, this will be the very first time that Apple will allow third-party app stores on the iPhone. It seems that Apple is already dedicating a “significant amount of resources to the companywide endeavor.”

Mobile

Forget Apple’s newest iPad — the Galaxy Tab S8 should be your next tablet

Samsung Galaxy Tab S8 alongside the tenth-gen iPad.

For a while now, the tablet industry has been rather boring. That's not due to the lack of compelling devices, but because of lopsided competition. Apple’s iPads have reigned supreme, and with the arrival of iPadOS, Apple made it clear that it was serious at playing the tablet game.

The dominance has been particularly evident at the entry level, where the $329 iPad has been the default choice for an affordable, reliable tablet. That’s not the case anymore in 2022. The "entry-level" 10th-gen iPad now starts at $449. It looks fresh, offers USB-C nirvana, and comes with a new Magic Keyboard to sell its computing chops.

Mobile

Apple vs. Samsung: Who has the best lock screen customization in 2022?

Lock screen comparison of One UI 5 and iOS 16

One of the most notable changes to arrive with iOS 16 was a massively overhauled lock screen customization system. Apple went all-in with the new feature, blending aesthetics with a functional flair brought to life by nifty widgets.
Samsung soon followed suit with its own take on a deep lock screen customization system that made its debut with the One UI 5 update. Yes, there are similarities, but Samsung has done what Apple often does. Or as they say: "Good artists borrow, great artists steal."
Wallpapers – it's the little things that matter

Starting with the stock wallpaper selection, Apple offers a selection of six backgrounds, while Samsung lets you pick between 21 wallpaper options. Scrolling down in iOS 16, you will come across six Weather & Astronomy dynamic wallpapers, which are actually quite stunning to just tap and interact with.
Next, you have seven emoji-loaded wallpapers and an equal number of artistic background art with solid as well as gradient color styles. When you pick the emoji wallpaper option, you can customize it with any emoji of your liking. Finally, you can have seven uniform-tone wallpapers with a clean fading texture.
One UI 5 also takes a similar approach but offers fewer wallpapers across different categories. You get nine single-tone backgrounds with a gradient effect and four graphical wallpapers with solid coloring and sharp lines.
You can adjust the gradient and saturation strength and create a combination from the spectrum option. Users get this facility with One UI 5 as well as iOS 16. Both ecosystems offer a custom wallpaper option that lets you shuffle photos from your photo gallery on the lock screen throughout the day. But there’s a crucial difference here.