Skip to main content

Apple, Samsung top J.D. Power mobile phone satisfaction

J.D. Power 2011 Mobile Satisfaction Smartphones

J.D Power and Associates has released its 2011 studies assessing consumers’ overall satisfaction with both smartphones and traditional mobile handsets—and the overall rankings contain few surprises, with Apple showing a strong lead in the smartphone category (with HTC the only other company to beat the industry average), while Samsung just barely edged out LG and Sanyo to claim top honors in the feature phone category. Overall, consumers showed much higher levels of satisfaction with smartphones than with traditional mobile handsets.

However, it’s almost more interesting to note what companies ended up at the bottom of the heap: amongst smartphones, Nokia devices ranked even lower in satisfaction amongst U.S. consumers than Palm/webOS devices, and in feature phones only Kyocera ranked lower than Nokia. And Google’s latest big acquisition—Motorola Mobility—didn’t even beat the industry average in either category.

“It’s not unexpected that satisfaction is higher for devices that have new technological advances or features,” said J.D. Power and Associations senior director of wireless services Kirk Parsons, in a statement. “Having the right combination of physical dimensions and operating functions and features for both smartphones and traditionally equipped devices is key to creating an exceptional ownership experience with each type of wireless device.”

J.D. Power 2011 Mobile Satisfaction traditional handsets

The study found several factors directly impacted customer satisfaction with smartphones: J.D. Power found that consumers are more satisfied with phones that are lighter, thinner, and offer touchscreen control rather than QWERTY keypads or a mix of touchscreen and QWERTY keypads. Consumers also prefer fast processing speed, high-quality displays, and the resolution of a phone’s camera is also a contributing factor. In general, the more megapixels a phone’s camera offers, the higher a customers’ satisfaction will be, although the cutoff is about 5 megapixels: customers weren’t significantly more satisfied with 8 megapixels or more than they were with 5 megapixels.

J.D. Power also found U.S. consumers are very satisfied with 4G-enabled devices, with the average satisfaction of 4G users significantly higher than that of 3G users; the study also found 4G users are more active users of their devices, engaging in more calling, texting, and Internet use.

The 2011 results mark the sixth consecutive time Apple ranked highest amongst smartphone manufacturers for customer satisfaction.

Editors' Recommendations

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Huawei to dump low-cost phones, eyes the mobile high-life lived by Apple and Samsung
Huawei Ascend P7 review angle 2

Huawei has decided it no longer wants to make low-cost, low-end mobile devices, and will concentrate on its high-end hardware. It hopes this will push its international sales forward, and give the company a taste of the mobile high-life it believes is lived by those at Samsung and Apple.

The news comes from Huawei CEO Richard Yu, who in an interview said, “We are giving up the low-end of the market. Many vendors are suffering. Only two have a good life: Apple and Samsung.”

Read more
Apple leads phone sales in May, Samsung gains, and LG loses steam
Apple company logo

Apple hasn’t unveiled a new iPhone in more than nine months, but the company still has a stranglehold on the U.S. smartphone market. In May, Apple claimed 41.9 percent of the market, according to a report from comScore. Samsung grew its market share, while LG and HTC lost a bit of their respective shares of the pie.

Apple’s share reflects an increase of 0.6 percentage points from its 41.3 percent share in February. Samsung finished May in second place with 27.8 percent of the market, up 0.8 percentage points. LG finished third with 6.5 percent of the U.S. smartphone market, down 0.3 percentage points.

Read more
T-Mobile’s rise, BlackBerry’s fall, and 12 more of the biggest mobile stories of 2013
Top mobile stories 2013

As 2013 draws to a close, we thought we’d cast an eye back over the last 12 months in mobile. A lot can, and did, happen in 365 days. We’ve seen successes and failures; we’ve borne witness to exciting new releases and disastrous flops. So, who won and lost? What impressed us and what disappointed? What mobile stories will 2013 be remembered for? Grab yourself a stiff drink, find a warm chair, and join us as we delve into the highs and lows of the past 8765 hours.
NSA is uncontrollably spying on everyone
After all that fuss about the Chinese spying on us it turns out that the NSA was engaged in a massive spying mission the whole time. An interesting defense suggested that the surveillance was only about metadata, so instead of actually listening in to your calls, the NSA is just studying who you call, when you call them, and how long the call lasts, then who you call next, who they call next, and on and on. All of which feeds into the same kind of big data predictive analytics that advertisers are engaging in to target us better, none of which is really very reassuring.
T-Mobile is the Uncarrier
It was deepest, darkest January, and 2013 was still in its infancy when T-Mobile’s new CEO, John Legere, took to the CES stage and unveiled the carrier’s plan to beat the competition by ditching the standard two-year contract system for smartphones. He may be crazy, but his network has drastically improved over the last year, and throughout 2013 T-Mobile systematically launched new services, giving users free international roaming and tablet Internet access, among other things. The “uncarrier” is now a tempting enough proposition that many people (including our very own mobile editor) are making the switch to T-Mobile, attracted by clarity and fairer pricing. Stranger still, T-Mobile's moves have made a big enough impact that the other major carriers have tried to copy it, leading to a fairer way to buy phones all around.
Unlocking your smartphone is legal, no wait it’s illegal
It was exempted back in 2006, but at the end of 2012 the Librarian of Congress decided that unlocking smartphones should be illegal. This new law came into effect at the end of January to the sound of carriers cheering and rubbing their hands with glee and a big fat “meh” from the general public. A few months later we found out that no one listens to the law - phone unlocking actually increased since becoming illegal. It makes sense, though. It’s not like anyone served time for unlocking their phone. Just this month, the major carriers finally saw sense and agreed to let everyone unlock their cell phones again. 
BlackBerry circles the RIM

A bright start to the year saw the rebranded BlackBerry finally launch the delayed BB10 platform on the Z10 handset. It looked good, if not great, and it seemed like there was a chance the company would turn things around. Then news turned south. Sales of the Z10 were disappointing and exacerbated by the unpopular Q10. Things got so bad that BlackBerry's board put it up for sale at the end of the summer. CEO Thorsten Heins walked away amidst a failed takeover in November, and the future remains far from clear. The company will probably survive in some form, but we wouldn’t buy a BlackBerry right now.
Windows Phone finally claims third
Analysts have been predicting that Microsoft’s platform would claim third place in the market and grow into a real competitor for the big two, Android and iOS, for a long time now. They were proved half right this year as Windows Phone finally wrestled that third spot away from BlackBerry. We can’t pretend that BlackBerry’s horrible fall from grace isn’t part of the reason, but it’s worth noting that Windows Phone is not stealing people away from Android or iOS. According to Kantar World Panel it’s sucking in a lot of first time smartphone buyers. If we look at IDC stats, the 3.6 percent share Windows Phone claimed in the third quarter is still less than the 4.1 percent share that BlackBerry had in that same quarter a year ago, but things are looking up for Windows Phone.
Microsoft buys Nokia
The slow climb in market share for Windows Phone was due to one company and that company was Nokia. By August Nokia was responsible for 85 percent of the Windows Phone market. Microsoft completely failed to tempt other manufacturers to commit to its platform in a major way; in fact, it had to pay Nokia handsomely to do so. What was the next step, amid countless suggestions that Nokia should branch out and jump on the Android bandwagon? Microsoft bought Nokia's phone assets outright for $7.2 billion. Will this be a good thing for Microsoft’s mobile pretensions? It’s very hard to say, but Microsoft fans seeking good news need look no further than Ballmer’s departure. 2014 could be a very big year for the company.
Googorola comes good

Read more