Skip to main content

Apple found guilty of infringing WiLan patents, must pay $145 million

iphone x waterproof phones
Julian Chokkattu/Digital Trends

Apple was ordered by a California jury on Wednesday, August 1, to pay WiLan, a Canadian patent licensing company, a sum of $145.1 million for damages as a result of patent infringement. The jury backed up WiLan’s claims that some of Apple’s iPhone models infringed on two WiLan wireless communications technology patents.

The patent infringement concerns technology used in Apple’s iPhones, specifically patents concerning “a method and apparatus for allocating bandwidth in a broadband wireless communication system” (U.S. patent 8457145), and another patent concerning “communication systems and to systems and methods for implementing adaptive call admission control” (U.S. patent 8537757). Apple apparently intends to appeal the decision, which likely means the case will bounce around courts for a little while yet.

Related Videos

This is not the first time the two companies have butted heads over patents. In 2013, a Texas jury found Apple not guilty of infringing on another of WiLan’s patents — that time over a patent covering CMDA and HSPA wireless communication technologies.

WiLan, a Quarterhill company, was originally founded in the 1990s as a producer of broadband wireless technologies, but shifted over to licensing its large portfolio of patents in 2013, after some financial difficulties. WiLan styles itself as being “one of the most successful patent licensing companies in the world”, and that it “helps companies unlock the value of intellectual property by managing and licensing their patent portfolios.” However, other sources have gone as far as to suggest that WiLan now makes a living by successfully chasing down companies like Apple over patent issues.

Of course, Apple is no stranger to legal issues over patents. Apple’s and Samsung’s seven-year tussle over the status of patents in Samsung’s Android phones has only just ended, while another case concerning the dual-camera tech in the current line of iPhones is currently ongoing. It has faced even more serious threats than just other companies too, and Apple is facing possible further challenges from the French government. Apple has taken to the offensive in other cases, suing processor manufacturer Qualcomm over allegedly exorbitant royalty fees.

We have reached out to Apple and WiLan for comment on this case and will update if we hear back.

Editors' Recommendations

The 3 biggest gambles Apple made in 2022 — and how they paid off
The Deep Purple color iPhone 14 Pro.

As 2022 starts to wind down, it’s a good time to take a moment and reflect on how wild this year has been, especially in the world of tech. Specifically for Apple, this was one of the more interesting years because it took some risks with this year’s releases.

For the most part, it has paid off. But of course, while some of Apple’s experiments worked out, others certainly raised some eyebrows. It’s been a weird one, for sure, so let’s take a closer look at what worked and what didn’t.
No one expected Dynamic Island, but it’s absolutely delightful

Read more
Apple targeting 2024 for first foldable, analyst says
Apple iPad Air 2 Apple logo rear

A new report suggests Apple could release its first foldable device in 2024 -- but it might not be an iPhone.

Instead, the tech giant is more likely to release a foldable iPad, an analyst from CCS Insight told CNBC this week.

Read more
Apple comes clean with what it really thinks about iPhone 14’s Dynamic Island
The iPhone 14 Pro's Dynamic Island showing music playing.

Two Apple higher-ups have spoken candidly in an interview about their thoughts on the iPhone 14 Pro and iPhone 14 Pro Max's new Dynamic Island. The new feature has been a major shakeup to the iPhone experience, and both Craig Federighi and Alan Dye — Apple's senior vice president of software engineering and vice president of human interface design, respectively — seem to know it.

In an interview with Japanese publication Axis, Federighi said that the shock and surprise seen in the audience when the Dynamic Island was initially revealed at the Apple "Far Out" showcase was "the same as when we first saw the feature inside Apple." He explains that after he was introduced to the Dynamic Island, he felt like the iPhone took on a "new, living identity."

Read more