Skip to main content

Apple will appeal $533 million patent infringement verdict

Despite being ordered to pay $532.9 million by a federal jury over a patent infringement dispute, Apple plans to appeal the verdict that awards more than half a billion to patent troll company Smartflash. Apple has been very successful at getting these type of patent verdicts tossed out, specifically overturning a $368.2 million verdict and a $625.5 million verdict in the past few years. Even if it’s not overturned, experts believe the monetary value of the decision will be reduced dramatically.

Originally asking for $852 million, Smartflash argued that Apple had intentionally infringed on patents related to “data storage” as well as “managing access through payment systems.” Specifically, Smartflash claimed that Apple used those patented technologies in iTunes, thus the company should be awarded a percentage of sales on all Apple devices. Alternatively, Apple argued that Smartflash shouldn’t be awarded more than $4.5 million.

Recommended Videos

Loosely referencing Smartflash’s dubious moniker as a patent troll, Apple spokeswoman Kristin Huguet saidSmartflash makes no products, has no employees, creates no jobs, has no U.S. presence, and is exploiting our patent system to seek royalties for technology Apple invented. We refused to pay off this company for the ideas our employees spent years innovating and unfortunately we have been left with no choice but to take this fight up through the court system.”

Speaking to Bloomberg about the decision, Rutgers University law professor Michael Carrier saidThis award won’t hold up. If there’s a large verdict in the district court, by the time it makes it through the appeals process, that verdict is slashed dramatically or overturned.”

Of course, this isn’t the only lawsuit that Smartflash has filed over patent disputes. The shell company has also sued Amazon, Google and Samsung. The Samsung trial will be scheduled next. Google is attempting to move the trial to California, likely to avoid a similar process of a potentially large verdict as well as an appeal.

Mike Flacy
By day, I'm the content and social media manager for High-Def Digest, Steve's Digicams and The CheckOut on Ben's Bargains…
Samsung’s One UI 7 update might steal this Apple Intelligence feature
Samsung One UI 6 Quick Settings on Galaxy A34 held in hand.

The mobile phone world is on the brink of an AI arms race. Between Apple Intelligence making its debut on the iPhone 16, the impending release of Samsung's One UI 7 beta, and the latest Pixels coming with Google's AI, all the major players are getting ready to utilize one of the most transformative technologies of our lifetime. Now, we have news that Samsung plans to make off like a bandit with one of Apple Intelligence's core features: notification summaries.

The tip comes from leaker Chun Bhai on X. Bhai says the feature is called AI notification and can be found in the latest One UI 7 build. The feature is currently being tested, but it's a safe enough assumption that it will appear in the final release version of One UI 7.

Read more
TicWatch reveals a $350 Apple Watch Ultra competitor, and it looks great
The TicWatch Atlas

Are you tired of the sky-high prices of the Samsung Galaxy Watch Ultra and Apple Watch Ultra 2? Mobvoi's new TicWatch Atlas offers a compelling alternative without breaking the bank. At just $350, this rugged smartwatch packs a punch with a long list of impressive features and a durable design that aims to replicate the "Ultra" smartwatch experience at a much lower price.

Crafted with a sandblasted stainless steel body, the TicWatch Atlas is built to withstand the elements and handle even the most demanding environments. But it's not just about durability; this smartwatch has advanced health and fitness tracking capabilities as well.

Read more
The Amazfit T-Rex 3 is an Apple Watch Ultra for half the price
The Amazfit T-Rex 3's screen.

The Amazfit T-Rex 3 smartwatch promises to give you the rough-and-tumble style of the Apple Watch Ultra 2 or Samsung Galaxy Watch Ultra without the high price. It’s chunky and tough, but does it have the software and ability to help win you over? Or is there a reason it’s a lot cheaper than its well-known competitors?

I spent some time wearing the T-Rex 3 to find out. Here's what you need to know.
The Amazfit T-Rex 3: design

Read more