Skip to main content

Apple should have been awarded an injunction against Samsung, says federal appeals court

Tim Cook
If you’re hearing loud cheers today, it’s probably from Cupertino. Apple received a victory today in its long, drawn-out legal war with Samsung.

There are a couple of major cases involving the two companies, but today’s decision is in relation to a ruling from May 2014 that Samsung infringed on Apple’s patents involving slide-to-unlock, autocorrect, and autolink features. Apple was awarded $120 million, but U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh denied an injunction in August 2014 that would stop Samsung from selling any products that use the features. Her reasoning was that the $120 million settlement was good enough. Apple appealed and argued that Samsung stole those features, and therefore, had no right to continue to use them.

Related Videos

Fast forward to today and a U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said that an injunction should have been awarded, and the lower court abused its discretion in failing to do so. Unfortunately for Apple, this does not mean the company was actually awarded an injunction today. It just means that this case will be sent back to the U.S District Court that refused to issue the injunction to reconsider its ruling.

The Court of Appeals said in its 2-1 decision, “The right to exclude competitors from using one’s property rights is important and the right to maintain exclusivity — a hallmark and crucial guarantee of patent rights deriving from the Constitution itself -— is likewise important.”

Samsung had the backing of Google, HTC, LG, and Rackspace Hosting, but it wasn’t good enough. The companies argued that an Apple victory could allow a patent owner to “to unfairly leverage its patent for competitive gain.”

Furthermore, Samsung told the Court of Appeals that none of its current models uses slide-to-unlock or autocorrect, and only one product uses the autolink feature.

So why is Apple spending all sorts of money to keep this one alive? A win probably won’t force Samsung to make many changes, but it could set a precedent for future patents that Apple owns. Many believe that companies shouldn’t be allowed to patent common-sense software features. Awarding too many patents could cause unnecessary resources to be spent in the legal system rather than on innovation.

Let’s also not forget that Apple and Samsung have another blockbuster case ongoing. Apple already won that one in 2012 when a court ruled that Samsung copied the design of the iPhone. Apple was awarded $1 billion, but the Federal Circuit reduced it to $548 million in May. However, the final amount still needs to be determined by a trial limited to the issue of damages.

Editors' Recommendations

Surprise Apple sale brings big discounts on iPad and Apple Watch
Data from a workout showing on the screen of the Apple Watch Series 8.

There are plenty of great discounts on Apple devices over at Amazon right now. That means substantial price cuts on the latest Apple Watch range as well as plenty of iPads too. If you're keen to learn more, we're here to help. We've picked out some of our favorite Apple deals going on right now. Check them out below to see how you can save big on highly sought-after devices.
Apple Watch SE (2nd Gen) -- $220, was $249

The Apple Watch SE (2nd Gen) is a marvel at this price. Easily one of the best smartwatch deals, it covers everything you could need. You gain comprehensive yet easy-to-use fitness tracking thanks to Apple's Activity Rings system and steady stream of challenges and rewards. It's fast too thanks to having the latest processor. Despite that, you still get to enjoy a two-day battery life with the watch easily comfortable to wear all day long. It lacks the ECG and blood oxygen sensors of the Series 8 along with the always-on display, but that won't be an issue for everyone. The key thing is you get an excellent smartwatch at a great price.

Read more
Apple Watch Series 9: the 6 biggest things we want to see
The Apple Watch Ultra with the Apple Watch Series 8 and Watch SE 2.

The Apple Watch Series 8 was a bit of a boring release for Apple’s wearable, as it wasn’t a huge upgrade over the Apple Watch Series 7; Apple seemed to spend more energy focusing on the Apple Watch Ultra instead. The only real upgrades for the Series 8 were the newer-generation S8 chip and a new body temperature sensor, though the use cases for that are pretty limited. But if you didn’t have a Series 7, then the Apple Watch Series 8 was still a great upgrade for those coming from older models.

We’re still a few months away from Apple revealing the next generation of Apple Watch with a Series 9 model, which is most likely coming sometime in the fall, along with the iPhone 15. But until then, here’s what I’m hoping Apple will put in the Apple Watch Series 9 when it finally comes out.
Nonintrusive blood glucose monitoring

Read more
Pixel Watch update brings a much-requested Apple Watch feature
Man using the Google Pixel Watch's app menu.

The Pixel Watch is a solid first outing as Google's debut smartwatch. However, it's still lacking a handful of features that early adopters have been requesting that are found on similar devices. Luckily, today marks the start of the rollout of one frequently requested feature: fall detection.

Fall detection is a crucial health and safety feature that all smartwatches are better for having, and now the Pixel Watch is finally joining the ranks of the Apple Watch and the Galaxy Watch with its addition.

Read more