Skip to main content

Barnes & Noble seeks DoJ probe into Microsoft Android patent tactics

Barnes_&_Noble_Union_Square_NYC
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Barnes & Noble has accused Microsoft of attempting to stifle innovation in the mobile device market by demanding royalties for the use of Android, for which Microsoft owns a number of key software patents, reports Bloomberg. The book giant has asked the US Department of Justice to launch an antitrust investigation against Microsoft.

“Microsoft is embarking on a campaign of asserting trivial and outmoded patents against manufacturers of Android devices,” wrote Barnes & Noble, in a letter to Gene Kimmelman, the DoJ’s chief counsel for corporate competition policy. “Microsoft is attempting to raise its rivals’ costs in order to drive out competition and to deter innovation in mobile devices.”

Of course, Microsoft sees things differently.

In March, Microsoft sued Barnes & Noble, saying that its Nook and Nook Color e-readers infringe on five of its patents. The software maker has filed a complaint with the US International Trade Commission, in an attempt to block imports of the Nook devices. 

“All modern operating systems include many patented technologies,” said Microsoft in response to Barnes & Noble’s claims. “Microsoft has taken licenses to patents for Windows and we make our patents available on reasonable terms for other operating systems, like Android. We would be pleased to extend a license to Barnes & Noble.”

So far, HTC, Samsung and Amazon have all agreed to sign licensing agreements with Microsoft. Barnes & Noble says the patents Microsoft owns supply a “trivial and non-essential design element” Android. In addition, Barnes & Noble says that the licensing fee is equal to what Microsoft charges for the use of its Windows Phone OS. 

Barnes & Noble also pointed to Microsoft’s recent partnerships with Nokia and MOSAID, which recently acquired 2,000 patents from Nokia, as evidence that the Redmond, Washington-based company aims to make it harder for other mobile device makers to compete.

The trial between Barnes & Noble and Microsoft will begin in February of next year.

Editors' Recommendations

Andrew Couts
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Features Editor for Digital Trends, Andrew Couts covers a wide swath of consumer technology topics, with particular focus on…
You don’t want to see this warning on your Google Pixel phone
Someone holding the Bay blue Google Pixel 8 Pro.

It's summertime in the U.S., so it's getting hot. When that happens, keeping yourself and your mobile devices cool is important. With that in mind, Google is developing a new message that will be displayed on Pixel phones when they overheat.

As 9to5Google discovered in fresh code, Google will no longer show a basic message warning when a phone may be overheating. Instead, it plans to post: "Phone needs to cool down: You may experience slower performance. Try avoiding direct sunlight or close any battery-intensive apps."

Read more
Apple is working on a futuristic iPhone feature that sounds too good to be true
A person holding the Apple iPhone 15 Plus.

Apple’s numerous teams are constantly working on innovative projects and regularly file new patents for them. One of the company’s recent patents pertains to a new feature for the iPhone that, if brought to fruition, could significantly transform how we use our mobile devices.

Patently Apple recently discovered a new patent that covers a concept for a new iPhone that would allow you to replace the standard back panel with something else. In other words, it would add modularization to the iPhone.

Read more
5 phones you should buy instead of the Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 5
Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 5 on a flat surface with the purple Galaxy Buds 2 Pro TWS Bluetooth earbuds on the side.

Though foldable phones are still a smaller part of the smartphone world, they appeal to users who want something more from their phones. Having a phone that can become a mini tablet opens up a whole new world for productivity and creativity.

If you’re in the market for a foldable, you may be considering the Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 5, which is one of the more popular choices. But it’s not the only foldable out there. Here are some alternatives to the Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 5 that you should look at first.
OnePlus Open

Read more