BlackBerry Torch Keeps RIM in the Smartphone Game

blackberry torch keeps rim in the smartphone game

Right now, the battle for smartphone dominance rages between three players: Apple, RIM and the unorganized mess of Android licensees. Nokia and Microsoft, at least for the moment, are in the fight in name only, though both are working to get back into the mix. Apple appeared to be unstoppable until the release of the iPhone 4, which drew a lot of criticism and attention due to reception issues, and how Apple addressed those problems. RIM’s potential last chance to save itself came this week in the form of the new BlackBerry Torch.

Let’s see how the Torch stacks up against the iPhone 4 and Android’s finest.

blackberry torch keeps rim in the smartphone game iphone 4 vs torcBlackBerry Torch vs. iPhone 4

Much like the new iPhone builds on the strengths of earlier versions, this new BlackBerry isn’t trying to be anything but a better BlackBerry phone. The Torch isn’t like so many of the phones that have been coming out from a variety of vendors (including RIM with the Storm) that attempt to clone the iPhone. I think that is a good thing, because the BlackBerry has many advantages over the other phones.

BlackBerry phones, when they stay true to the BlackBerry core benefits, tend to excel at battery life, business functions and e-mail. Unfortunately, they have typically sucked where the iPhone has been most competent, including: Web browsing, apps, and multimedia. The Torch closes the gap with regard to the latter, and appears to retain its advantages on the former, which is good for RIM users. Apple should, at least with regard to unique personal applications, continue with a significant lead for some time.

It is kind of amazing how many people I know who carry BlackBerry phones and iPhones at the same time; the first to deal with business functions and e-mail, and the second for fun and personal calls. Part of the reason to have two phones for many of these folks is that their business calls need to be logged (financial analysts, attorneys, etc.) and they would like their personal calls to stay, well, personal. But they do struggle with having to work with two very different tools for similar things and I think many would prefer to have one type of phone, even if they still had to use two, to do both.

Because companies are already used to paying for BlackBerry phones, going towards RIM wouldn’t require an executive to sign off on the move and so should be easier to get on the company dime than an iPhone or Android phone. The Torch and its successors will be going after that opportunity. It will likely be some time before we know if this version is good enough, but there is no denying the opportunity.

Initially, this is an AT&T-only phone, so if that is the problem – and it is for many iPhone users – an alternative carrier isn’t yet an advantage with this phone.

While the Torch won’t appeal to loyal iPhone users, it could win back those who moved from a BlackBerry to an iPhone and regretted the move. It also appears vastly more capable of satisfying existing BlackBerry users who are on AT&T, and provides a vastly stronger alternative to both Android and Apple than ever before.

blackberry torch keeps rim in the smartphone game androidBlackBerry Torch vs. Android

The big problem with Android is that there are way too many choices, which makes the selection of the right phone more difficult. The leading phones appear to be the HTC Evo 4G from Sprint, the new Motorola Droid X from Verizon, and the Samsung Captivate on AT&T, but sustaining that argument would be painful, given the mass of choices for this platform and how many versions of Android, from 1.6 to 2.2, layered with user interface customizations, that are out there.

Against the complexity of Android choices, both the new Torch and the iPhone are a breath of fresh air, and may showcase the problems with too many choices, which can often trump those with too few. Still, Android, at least for now, retains one big advantage, and that is carrier choice. Android is also number two in terms of application store depth, and has the first 4G phones in the market, but coverage is spotty at best, and battery life in 4G mode has proven to be unacceptably short (three to four hours).

Here, the Torch’s biggest exposure is the lack of carrier choice, so you get a conflict of too much choice against too little. Given that RIM is a multi-carrier company, generally I expect this shortcoming to be addressed in a few weeks, and not become a sustaining disadvantage.

Android also has keyboard phones both that drop from the bottom and side, but they have largely relied on partners HTC, or application providers like Touchdown (which isn’t bad) to complete their e-mail, calendar and contact solutions. On the other hand, to really leverage RIM’s advantages in this space, you need a RIM server, and most don’t have that.

So RIM’s big advantage over Android remains simplicity of choice, consistency in product, and a consistently good experience, which a multi-hardware vendor like Google or Microsoft will have difficulty matching. In a weird way, Android provides the best iPhone and RIM clones, but hasn’t yet really defined itself outside of the other two players yet, except as the platform of choices, a title it wears perhaps too well.

Staying the Course

The Torch is a return to RIM’s roots, and a nice advancement on what has come before. Much like Apple tends to be successful by improving on its own model and has stumbled when copying others, so has RIM in the past. The Torch represents what may be a very Apple-like strategy of being true to RIM’s origins. People aren’t all the same, and considering RIM has a higher market share than Apple does right now, that could work out well for them.

Compared to Apple and RIM, Google is kind of an uncontrolled mess, but does represent a level of choice that neither of the other firms can match, and that remains a huge risk particularly given the AT&T problems.

In short, the Torch doesn’t win any wars. It just assures that RIM remains in the fight, and will likely win a number of battles.

For more on the Torch check out BlackBerry Torch: Everything You Need to Know.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.


Which smartphone manufacturers won and lost in 2018

As the curtain comes down on 2018, we take a look at the big successes and failures in the smartphone market over the last 12 months. Which phone maker had the best year, and who had a year to forget?

Save up to $800 with the best smartphone deals for December 2018

Need a better phone but don't want to spend a fortune? It's never a bad time to score a new smartphone and save some cash. We rounded up the best smartphone deals available that can save you as much as $800.

The best iPhone deals for December 2018

Apple devices can get expensive, but if you just can't live without iOS, don't despair: We've curated an up-to-date list of all of the absolute best iPhone deals available for December 2018.

5G’s arrival is transforming tech. Here’s everything you need to know to keep up

It has been years in the making, but 5G is finally becoming a reality. While 5G coverage is still extremely limited, expect to see it expand in 2019. Not sure what 5G even is? Here's everything you need to know.
Product Review

With sapphire glass and analog dials, you'd never know this watch is smart

The world of hybrid smartwatches is getting much larger, and the latest comes from a name with history — New York Standard Watches. In our NYSW GTS Activity Tracker review, we find out what makes this watch special, and why we were so…

Scientists have charged a phone and a Fitbit with solar-powered clothes

Scientists from Britain's Nottingham Trent University have discovered a way to incorporate solar panels into clothing, and they've even managed to charge a phone and Fitbit with the energy created.

Fitbit supercharges its smartwatches with its new 3.0 operating system

Fitbit announced a new software update for the Versa and Ionic, called Fitbit OS 3.0. The new OS will allow for things like on-device daily views, as well as 10 new third-party apps on the watch.

The Lenovo Z5 Pro GT packs the most RAM ever seen in a smartphone

The next generation of smartphones has begun, and it's begun with a bang. The Lenovo Z5 Pro GT comes with the next generation Snapdragon 855 processor, 12GB of RAM, and 512GB of storage.

The best iPhone XS Max screen protectors to safeguard that huge display

If you love big screens, then the iPhone XS Max's huge 6.5-inch display is perfect for you. But it won't fare well against concrete. Protect your display with the best iPhone XS Max screen protectors.

Google’s Gboard communication app reaches 500 languages in only 2 years

In December 2016, Google launched Gboard with support for an already-impressive 100 languages. Since then, however, Google has added a hefty 400 languages to the software keyboard, bringing the total number to 500.

Sending SMS messages from your PC is easier than you might think

Texting is a fact of life, but what to do when you're in the middle of something on your laptop or just don't have your phone handy? Here's how to send a text message from a computer, whether you prefer to use an email client or Windows 10.

Walmart’s $100 2018 iPad discount is one of the best we’ve seen yet

The 2018 iPad is one of the best tablets we've ever seen and the tablet we recommend to the vast majority of users. Now, Walmart is offering one of the best deals so far on the device: $100 off the 32GB space gray version.
Social Media

Twitter makes it easier than ever to switch between latest and top tweets

Twitter has finally delivered on its promise to give users more control over their timeline. It comes in the form of a new button on the main screen that lets you switch between two different kinds of tweets.

Google’s new Street View backpack offers better imagery in a lighter package

Higher-quality imagery is coming to Street View thanks to a new design for Google's Trekker backpack. The kit, which enables Street View to capture imagery from more places, has improved camera sensors and is lighter than before.