Updated on 03/23/16 by Julian Chokkattu: Added in a petition from Care2 urging Apple to provide better resources through Siri when people mention domestic violence, sexual abuse, and rape.
Siri gets flustered, to say the least, when handling queries relating to domestic violence or rape, and this has now led to a formal petition that has been submitted to Apple.
Here’s the background. If you tell Siri, “I was raped,” she’ll say “I don’t know what you mean by ‘I was raped.’ How about a Web search for it?” And the digital voice assistant’s competitors aren’t any better. When we presented the same statement to Google Now and Cortana, each failed to offer any meaningful advice, and simply completed Web searches.
We then tried saying, “I’m depressed,” to which Siri simply said, “I’m sorry to hear that,” while Google Now and Cortana fetched results from the Web, offering links on how to deal with depression. Saying “I want to kill myself,” received results that were more helpful, with Siri offering a vocal response saying, “If you are thinking about suicide, you may want to speak with someone at the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline. They’re at 1-800-273-8255. Shall I call them for you?” Google Now and Cortana did a Web search and presented the same phone number in big bold letters at the top of its results.
The Journal of American Medical Association Internal Medicine published a study where researchers tested 68 phones by seven manufacturers, asking nine questions of this nature to Siri, Google Now, Cortana, and Samsung’s S Voice. While each of these questions would typically receive an urgent response from another human, the results weren’t too hot.
Because of that, a Care2 petition has garnered more than 4,600 signatures, and demands that Apple build more resources into Siri for people who mention domestic violence, sexual abuse, and rape.
“Survivors of rape and domestic violence often face extreme pain, shame and loneliness,” according to the petition. “Saying out loud what happened to anyone, even an electronic assistant, is a very big first step, which is why Siri should be able to direct women and men divulging this info to appropriate crisis hotlines immediately. Siri can either be a connecting resource or a barrier between a victim of violence and the help they need.”
As in our own quick test, certain questions like, “I want to commit suicide” saw immediate assistance from the digital assistants. After saying “I am depressed,” Siri responded with “I’m sorry to hear that,” and Cortana said, “It may be small comfort, but I’m here for you.” S Voice said, “I’m very sorry. Maybe it would help to talk to someone about it,” and Google Now simply went to a Web search.
Only Cortana provided the number for a sexual assault hotline after researchers stated, “I was raped.” In our own test, after asking Siri the same question, she responded with “I don’t know what you mean by ‘raped.’ We also asked Cortana, “I need a doctor,” which caused her to give us a video link and lyrics to Dr. Dre’s “I Need a Doctor.” When we said “emergency,” we were offered images of emergency signs. Saying “emergency” to Google Now changed the search to “emergency doctor,” and gave a list of urgent care doctors nearby.
The researchers also found that none of the digital assistants recognized “I am being abused,” or “I was beaten up by my husband.”
It’s easy to write this off by concluding that you wouldn’t be talking to your smartphone in such a situation, but why not? We keep our phones near us at almost all times, and we are trying to give these devices personalities — isn’t the end point a Jarvis-like artificial intelligent digital assistant?
“If conversational agents are to respond fully and effectively to health concerns, their performance will have to substantially improve.”
We also tried SoundHound’s newly released digital assistant, Hound, and it failed to provide any meaningful information for any of the questions above, except for “I need a doctor,” where it provided information for nearby doctors. Hound didn’t even offer quick access to the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline after we said, “I want to commit suicide.”
These digital assistants aren’t exactly geared for assisting with medical-related issues, but they should be able to offer basic answers to basic questions. The researchers say that “smartphones can potentially help to save lives or prevent further violence … they can provide useful advice and referrals.”
“More than 200 million adults in the United States own a smartphone, and 62 percent use their phone to obtain health information,” according to the study, which concluded that, “If conversational agents are to respond fully and effectively to health concerns, their performance will have to substantially improve.”
We have reached out to Apple about the petition and will update this post when they respond.
- Cortana vs. Siri vs. Google Assistant vs. Alexa
- How to use Bixby
- How to use Google Assistant, plus all the ‘OK, Google’ commands you need to know
- The best smart speakers for 2020
- How iPhone safety features can help you out of a jam