Skip to main content

Court gives the NSA permission to continue phone metadata collection for now

court rules nsa resume phone metadata collection building headquarters
Headquarters of the NSA at Fort Meade, Maryland. NSA
In a decision that is sure to irk privacy advocates, the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court ruled that the National Security Agency (NSA) can temporarily resume its once-secret bulk collection of Americans’ phone metadata, reports the New York Times. However, after 180 days, the NSA will still have to end the practice as per the Freedom Act.

The NSA’s phone data collection program originally ended on June 1, when Section 215 of the U.S. Patriot Act expired. President Barack Obama then signed the Freedom Act, which shifted phone data collection from the NSA’s hands to phone companies’, two days later. His administration also applied to restart the program for six months after the bill was signed to give the agency time to transition the program.

The Freedom Act amended Section 215 to require the government to define a “specific selection term,” such as a phone number, to access the phone companies’ records. The law also forbids the collection of “all call detail records” held by phone companies.

All of this was done in response to a ruling by the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, which stated that Section 215 could not be interpreted as allowing any kind of bulk collection. However, the Freedom Act did not include any language to address the ruling, so it remained unclear whether the data collection was legal or not.

Then, in late June, Judge Michael W. Mosman stated that the program could resume for the remaining 180 days granted by the Freedom Act and argued that the Second Circuit was wrong in saying that the program was not authorized to collect that data.

“Second Circuit rulings are not binding on the FISC and this court respectfully disagrees with that court’s analysis, especially in view of the intervening enactment of the U.S.A. Freedom Act,” wrote Judge Mosman in his 26-page decision.

In response, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) stated that it will ask the Second Circuit Court — which initially ruled against the NSA program — to issue a temporary injunction to prevent the resumption of the program. Of course, even if the NSA is forced to stop metadata collection, that doesn’t mean all of its programs will be gone for good.

Even the Freedom Act, which Senator Ron Wyden (D-Or.) hailed as “the most significant victory for Americans’ privacy rights in more than a decade,” still includes questionable provisions, such as the “roving wiretap” and “lone wolf.” These provisions allow local and federal law enforcement to track and tap an individual’s activities and devices, even if there aren’t proven links between the user and any known terrorist organizations.

Editors' Recommendations

Williams Pelegrin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Williams is an avid New York Yankees fan, speaks Spanish, resides in Colorado, and has an affinity for Frosted Flakes. Send…
Quit listening: Snowden calls court ruling against NSA surveillance ‘encouraging’
usa freedom act passes in senate with 67 32 vote nsa computers heartbleed bug

A federal appeals court has brought a case against the National Security Agency's (NSA) phone surveillance program back from the dead. Back in 2013, U.S. District Judge William Pauley dismissed the ACLU lawsuit on the grounds the NSA program was a "counter-punch" from the U.S. government against terrorists. Now, the second U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan has ruled that the NSA's collection of millions of Americans phone records is illegal under federal law, Reuters reports.

Updated on 05-08-2015 by Malarie Gokey: Added Edward Snowden's response to the ruling.
NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden calls the ruling 'encouraging'
Just one day after the appeals court ruled that the NSA's surveillance program is illegal under federal law, the very man who leaked the information to the press -- Edward Snowden -- applauded the ruling, during an interview at the Nordic Media Festival with Forbes' contributor Runa Sandvik.

Read more
New bill proposes 5-year extension of Patriot Act and permission for NSA data collection
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell wants 5 more years of the Patriot Act
patriot act nsa surveillance extension news mitch mcconnell

Section 215 of the Patriot Act, the part of the law that grants the government the ability to collect data en masse, is set to expire on June 1, 2015. However, if Kentucky republican and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has his way, it will continue to be in effect until at least 2020, reports the Washington Post

A new bill brought to the floor of Senate by McConnell proposes extending the Patriot Act and, by extension, the surveillance capabilities of the National Security Agency — specifically, the ability to collect phone data from millions of Americans under the guise of monitoring terrorist activity. The bill is co-sponsored by Senate Intelligence Committee Chairman and North Carolina republican Richard Burr.

Read more
Don’t want to pay the full cost of a phone upfront? Cricket Wireless now gives you options
cricket wireless unlimited data plan

When it comes to buying prepaid phones, the biggest deterrent to doing so would be the high upfront cost. Since the phone isn't subsidized, you'll have to always pay full price for the handset. Cricket Wireless is hoping to curb that deterrent by introducing three new payment options.

Set up as three tiers, these payment options exist so you don't have to pay the full price of your Cricket phone upfront. The first two tiers require credit checks, but for those not exactly high in the good-credit board, the third tier lets you make an initial rental payment of $50 and pay the remaining balance within 90 days.

Read more