Skip to main content

NYC district attorney says smartphones should be ‘answerable to search warrants’

In Manhattan, there are 423 Apple devices that have been lawfully seized since October 2014. The reason they are sitting around like bricks? New York County’s District Attorney Cyrus Vance Jr. points to Apple’s introduction of default device encryption in iOS 8.

“While terrorism cases like San Bernardino have generated the lion’s share of the media coverage, the impact of default device encryption has been felt most profoundly on the local level, in the investigation of domestic crimes occurring every day across the U.S.,” Vance said in a speech at the Financial Crimes and Cybersecurity Symposium.

Recommended Videos

The district attorney’s office has released an update to its 2015 report on Smartphone Encryption and Public Safety and it highlights the “little progress” made in addressing default encryption.

In 2014, Apple said it would encrypt its devices by default meaning they would be secure enough that even the company would not be able to extract any data. Google quickly followed suit, and the move has been lauded by many security and privacy advocates. Law enforcement, on the other hand, has vigorously come out against it.

“To fight crime effectively in the 21st century, we have to make smartphones answerable to search warrants — just as they were until 2014,” Vance said. “Complying with judges’ warrants for smartphones never involved a government backdoor. It never meant that the government held a key to anybody’s phone. It never enabled access to real-time communications, and it never meant collecting bulk data on anyone. But perhaps most relevant for purposes of today’s symposium, warrant-proof encryption does nothing to protect us from the rising tide of cybercrime.”

Local police departments across the country have been struggling to find a way to unlock devices held in evidence lockers, but the conversation erupted on the national stage after two terrorists killed 14 people in San Bernardino, California, in 2015. One of the shooters, Syed Farook, left behind a locked iPhone. While Apple initially assisted the FBI, the company rejected a court order demanding the creation of a tool, or backdoor, to decrypt iPhone devices.

Vance wants the process to go back to the way things were pre-iOS 8. The report says the data extraction process used in previous iOS versions was not compromised and there was “no lack of security” in iOS 7. The report also concludes that Apple hasn’t “demonstrated that default device encryption materially enhances users’ security.”

The solution, Vance believes, is federal regulation — he points to the controversial bill introduced by Senators Richard Burr and Dianne Feinstein that has failed to gain any traction in Congress. The report says the bill would “address the problem,” but seeing as it may not make much headway, the district attorney’s office has proposed its own bill that would force companies like Google and Apple to make their operating systems “capable of being accessed … in an unencrypted form.”

“The majority of these agencies do not have the resources to train, let alone hire, staff members to ‘lawfully hack’ these devices; thus, any expectation that agencies could build their own in-house cyber labs is unrealistic,” according to the report.

You can read the full report here,and the transcript of Vance’s speech here.

Julian Chokkattu
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Julian is the mobile and wearables editor at Digital Trends, covering smartphones, fitness trackers, smartwatches, and more…
6 surprising reasons you should buy an iPhone instead of Android
iphone 11 pro max vs pixel 4 xl screen

We have heard the same arguments from the Android faithful for so long that they have become accepted wisdom. If you want a cheap phone, you need an Android. If you want to make a phone personally yours, you need Android. If you want the coolest new features, you need Android.

I question these pillars of the pro-Android argument. What if an iPhone actually costs less than an Android? What if customization is also possible on the iPhone? And what if all that Android hardware bragging is just hot air?
The iPhone is a better budget device
You can easily find a great phone on either side for $1,000, but what if you only have $300 to spend, or less? Common wisdom says buy an Android, and big brands like Samsung, Motorola, and LG offer fine phones in that range. At Apple, the cheapest new phone is a $399 iPhone SE.

Read more
Here’s one fella who can’t wait to get his hands on the iPhone Air
Alleged concept render of the iPhone 17 Air in black.

The so-called “iPhone Air” is apparently on the way, despite Apple remaining characteristically tight-lipped about such a device. 

Numerous leaks have suggested that the iPhone Air, which is expected to launch this fall along with the iPhone 17, will be just 5.5mm thick, making it easily Apple’s slimmest handset yet. 

Read more
Best Buy just slashed the price of the Apple iPad Pro M4 by $200
Home Screen of the M4 iPad Pro.

Whenever you see a discount for the latest model of an Apple device, you have to take advantage of the offer right away as it likely won't last long. That's the case with the 13-inch Apple iPad Pro M4, which is on sale from Best Buy. Its 256GB model, usually sold for $1,299, is down to $1,099 for savings of $200, but stocks are probably already flying off the shelves. If you've been looking for tablet deals featuring Apple's premium iPad, you won't want to miss this bargain, so hurry!

Why you should buy the 13-inch Apple iPad Pro M4

Read more