Skip to main content

How Google Assistant on Google Home is outclassing Amazon’s Alexa

When Google launched Assistant, its artificially intelligent Amazon Alexa competitor, it had hardly any third-party support. Amazon had a yearlong head start, but Google Assistant on Google Home has been superior in offering up results to search queries, as well as following up with contextual searches.

You can ask it, “When does Logan come out,” and follow up with, “Give me showtimes,” and Assistant can understand, without needing you to repeat anything about the film Logan. 

Now — about six months after Google Home’s debut — Amazon may still have more third-party skills, but Google Assistant is matching and outclassing Alexa in all its other features. Here’s how.

You can type to Google Assistant on Android — and iOS

Google’s big advantage over Amazon lies in the mobile market — one that Amazon is slowly creeping into with Alexa integration in phones like the HTC U11 and the Huawei Mate 9.

Android phones running version 6.0 (Marshmallow) or higher that have the Google app installed can use Google Assistant (as long as they have a 720-pixel or higher resolution screen, and more than 1.5GB of RAM). Around 40 percent of active Android devices run Marshmallow and Nougat, and while not all pass those requirements, it’s safe to say that Assistant is on a lot of devices.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Google just brought Assistant to iOS, which now poses a threat not just for Alexa, but for Apple’s Siri as well. Owners of iPhones now have the chance to use Google’s platform — there’s still a barrier because you can’t use it natively like you can use Siri, but it’s still an option.

You can type to Assistant in the iOS app — which so far has been a prime feature of Google’s Allo messaging app. Say you don’t want to announce a reminder you want to set publicly — you can now just type it up like in Allo. Until now, I’ve defaulted to going to Google Search when I didn’t want to speak out to Assistant, but the ability to type to the Assistant allows me to use it more, improving accessibility. It’s a feature Alexa or Siri have yet to incorporate.

Home calling

Just last week, Amazon introduced the ability to call and text people through Alexa. The catch? You can only call and message people with Echo devices (or through the Amazon Alexa app). Google just trumped it with free hands-free calling to any number in the U.S.

Google said the new home calling feature with Google Home will use a private number, but you can add your own number via the Home app. It uses your Google Contacts to place calls, and what’s neat is that its recently implemented multi-user functionality means if your wife says “call my mother,” Google Home will know she means her mother, and not your mother.

Google Home has officially replaced the landline, in a non-clunky way.

Proactive Assistance

Amazon also recently unveiled the ability to get notifications on your phone from Alexa — but these are just opt-in notifications that aren’t contextual. It can’t tell you traffic’s getting bad before you head to work, for example. Google Assistant on Google Home can.

Your Google Assistant: Ready To Help

Google has already been doing this for a long time via Google Now, but the new “Proactive Assistance” features mean Home will light up in a certain pattern — you can then ask Assistant “what’s up,” and it can tell you about a pressing issue like traffic alerts, flight status updates, and reminders.

Scott Hoffman, Google’s vice president of engineering for Assistant, told Digital Trends that the company didn’t want to offer up audible notifications yet, because it didn’t want Google Home to speak if no one was home (which Alexa will do if you opt in). He also said features like Reminders have been a long time coming because Google wanted to figure out a better way to reach the user. Audible notifications will likely come soon, but Google is wary of overloading users with notifications.

Visual responses with Chromecast

Who needs to buy an Amazon Echo Show when you can get better features with a Google Home and a Chromecast for less money? One of the new updates announced for Google Home is the ability to receive visual responses from Google Assistant — the catch is you need a cast-enabled TV (via a Chromecast or Android TV). This means you can ask Google Assistant to show your calendar, and it will pop up on the TV.

Google will still need to make sure developers jump on this feature to maximize its potential. Amazon’s Echo Show is comparable, and its video calling feature has merits — but you can only video call other Echo Show owners, meaning you have a limited pool of users to engage with in that way.

Shortcuts

One of the more underrated announcements at I/O was how you can easily make voice shortcuts straight from the Google Home app. Feeling down? You can ask Google Assistant on Google Home to cheer you up by playing videos of corgis on your TV. Alexa can only do this with third-party integration from IFTTT. With Google, it’s already live in the Google Home app.

There are a variety of shortcuts you can say to trigger actions with the Google Home, and it’s something Amazon really needs to implement natively.

Within six months, Google has caught up and surpassed Amazon’s Alexa with these new features (some of which haven’t rolled out yet). But this is the beauty of competition — Amazon still has far more Echo owners than Google has Google Home owners, Amazon has a growing user base of Prime Video subscribers; Amazon is unmatched in its online marketplace, and the company is continually improving its machine-learning capabilities.

The competition is only going to increase as rumors suggest Apple will release an Echo-competitor, and perhaps Microsoft will follow suit with Cortana.

Editors' Recommendations

Julian Chokkattu
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Julian is the mobile and wearables editor at Digital Trends, covering smartphones, fitness trackers, smartwatches, and more…
The Amazon Echo Hub is almost the whole-home hub I’ve always wanted
Amazon Echo Hub.

I’ve long dreamed about having a proper sort of home hub. One that’s always on, always showing me the things I want to control at any given time. Not huge. Not obtrusive.

The new Amazon Echo Hub, one several new Echo devices announced at Amazon's 2023 devices event at HQ2 in Arlington, Virginia, very much seems to fit that bill. It’s a touchscreen that you’ll use to control all your things.

Read more
At long last, Amazon brings AI features to Alexa
Amazon SVP of Devices and Services Dave Limp demonstrates the Let's Chat feature of Alexa, powered by AI.

Nearly a year after ChatGPT introduced the world to the uncannily human possibilities of generative AI, Amazon has unveiled new Alexa features powered by large language models (LLM). At the annual Amazon Devices Event hosted at its new Arlington, Virginia, headquarters, the company announced some major Alexa improvements that will attempt to make replies much more conversational and lifelike, with less waiting time between your interactions and more meaningful replies.

A new feature called Let's Chat mimics the ChatGPT experience by allowing you to have a fluid conversation with Alexa, asking questions about everything from the voice assistant's football team allegiance to recipes. You can even ask it to write emails for you. In the demo with Dave Limp, outgoing senior vice president of devices and services, Alexa sometimes stalled and needed a second prompt to answer questions, suggesting the feature may still need some polish.

Read more
I abandoned my iPad for an Android tablet and didn’t hate it
A person typing on a keyboard, connected to a Pixel Tablet.

Android tablets aren’t a patch on the Apple iPad, right? I mean, they don’t come close in app compatibility, performance, or versatility — making Android as an operating system good on phones, but disappointing on tablets. That’s the rule, and it’s one I have followed for some time.

At least, that was until I forced myself to live with and use the Google Pixel Tablet just like I do my iPad Pro. Would it change my mind? A bit, yes, but another Android tablet changed it more.
What does my tablet need to do?

Read more