Skip to main content

Canada's Supreme Court rules that Google must block websites worldwide

google canada free speech case gavel flickr
Joe Gratz/Flickr
Google must block certain websites and domains worldwide. That’s the decision handed down by Canada’s Supreme Court on Tuesday, June 27, which upheld a British Columbia ruling that the Mountain View, California-based company was legally obligated to remove listings from search results outside Canada.

Canada’s Supreme Court judges argued that Canadian lower courts had the authority to grant injunctions against “any [company] in the world,” characterizing Google — which controls 70 to 75 percent of all global internet searches, as a “determinitive player.”

“The problem in this case is occurring online and globally,” Justice Rosalie Abella wrote. “The Internet has no borders — its natural habitat is global,” wrote Justice Rosalie Abella. The only way to ensure the injunction worked “was to have it apply where Google operates — globally.”

The decision stems from case Google v. Equustek, which pitted Equustek Solutions Inc., a Vancouver-based network device manufacturer, against Datalink Technologies Gateways Inc, its distributor. The former alleged that Datalink Technologies was re-labeling products and passing them off as its own, and that it acquired some of Equustek’s proprietary technology and began to manufacture copycat products.

Equustek sued Datalink for damages, but the company ducked persecution by relocating outside Canada and continued to sell its products from an undisclosed location.

Google entered the picture when Equustek requested that the search giant drop Datalink from its search engine. Google complied in part, removing — “de-indexing,” in industry parlance — more than 340 web pages. But it only de-indexed listings on Google.ca, not Google.com or its other country-specific search engines, and refused to take down Datalink’s websites.

Datalink worked around Googlee’s blockade by creating new, unblocked pages on its websites.

A subsequent British Columbia court order imposed a broader injunction on Google’s listings of Datalink’s websites anywhere in the world, which the search giant appealed. It lost that challenge on Wednesday, in front of Canada’s Supreme Court.

“This is not an order to remove speech that, on its face, engages freedom of expression values,” Justice Abella wrote. “We have not, to date, accepted that freedom of expression requires the facilitation of the unlawful sale of goods.”

The court’s decision, which cannot be appealed, could have widespread implications “around the world,” lawyer Barry Sookman told The Toronto Star. “[It’s] a statement of general principles about the powers of courts, and will influence common law jurisdictions in Europe, Australia, New Zealand, Singapore, and elsewhere.”

Sookman says it might be used to prosecute parties who violate intellectual property, copyright, and trademark law.

But the ruling’s opponents, including rights organizations like Human Rights Watch, the BC Civil Liberties Association, and the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), disagree, contending that it harms safeguards for free speech and access to information.

“The [decision] largely sidesteps the question of whether such a global order would violate foreign law or intrude on internet users’ free speech rights,” the EFF wrote. “Instead, the court focused on whether or not Google, as a private actor, could legally choose to take down speech and whether that would violate foreign law. This framing results in Google being ordered to remove speech under Canadian law even if no court in the United States could issue a similar order.”

A spokesperson for Google says the company is  “reviewing the court’s findings” and “evaluating its next steps.”

Editors' Recommendations

Kyle Wiggers
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Kyle Wiggers is a writer, Web designer, and podcaster with an acute interest in all things tech. When not reviewing gadgets…
Google Chrome 76 will stop websites from seeing users in Incognito Mode
The Google Chrome logo set against a rocky background image.

Google Chrome 76, scheduled to roll out on July 30, will fix a loophole that allows websites to detect visitors who are Incognito Mode, a move that will affect how publishers implement paywalls for their content.

In a blog post, Google said that some websites have been taking advantage of an unintended loophole involving Chrome's FileSystem API. When in Incognito Mode, the API is disabled so that people will not leave traces of activity. Websites have been checking for the availability of the API, and if they do not find it, they determine that Incognito Mode is activated.

Read more
President Trump is no longer allowed to block people on Twitter, court rules
President Trump blocked you on Twitter illustration

President Donald Trump cannot block critics from viewing his Twitter feed, a federal appeals court ruled on Tuesday.

A three-judge panel from the Second Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Trump violated the First Amendment by blocking people on Twitter who were critical of him and his policies, and that his account is considered a “public forum,” according to the New York Times. The court argued that no member of the American public should be barred from access to the views of the President. 

Read more
With Chrome Portals, Google makes websites feel more like web apps
chrome portal web packages google io 2019

Continuing on the theme that Google is now shifting from a company that helps you find answers to one that helps users get things done, at this year's I/O developer conference, the company's focus on the future of Chrome is centered on making the web more instant, more powerful, and safer. With new tools like Portals and Web Packaging, developers can create web experiences with links that feel as seamless and fluid as a native app.

"What makes the web special in today's landscape is this massive open-scale platform where all of us can freely connect with each other and where new experiences are just a link away," said Google Director of Engineering Dion Almaer and Senior Director of Product Ben Galbraith during a talk on the future of Chrome at I/O.

Read more