Skip to main content

U.K. Investigatory Powers Bill, like Feinstein-Burr, is also anti-encryption

cyberattack uk parliament
Image used with permission by copyright holder
If tech giants are worried about the draft of the anti-encryption bill introduced by the heads of the U.S. Select Committee on Intelligence, new revelations from across the pond won’t ease tensions.

Chris Farrimond, the director of the National Crime Agency in the United Kingdom, confirmed that, thanks to the Investigatory Powers Bill, law enforcement can order a company remove encryption from user data, according to a tweet from Silkie Carlo, policy officer for the National Council for Civil Liberties (Liberty). The bill has been locked in debate since it was introduced in November, according to Liberty.

The revelation is quite similar to its U.S. counterpart — the Compliance with Court Orders Act of 2016, which also seeks to force companies to comply with court orders requesting user data, and make it “intelligible.”

Farrimond followed up with Carlo’s tweet, clarifying that authorities would be able to “request” that companies decrypt data, rather than force them to do so.

silkie carlo
Image used with permission by copyright holder

But as Carlo points out, the bill’s current language, which can change, can hardly be called a “request.” Section 218 of the bill states that anyone given a “national security notice” or a “technical capability notice” from authorities “must comply,” and is not allowed to disclose the notice unless permitted by the government. These notices do not need judicial authorization.

“Thus, were an Apple v FBI scenario to occur in the U.K., Apple would not be able to disclose even the fact that it had been served with a notice, let alone challenge it in court,” according to the Liberty’s briefing of the bill.

Section 217 of the bill offers an example, and says, “the removal by a relevant operator of electronic protection applied by or on behalf of that operator to any communications or data,” meaning a company must strip away all encryption from the data requested by the government.

Both the U.S. and U.K. bills are a direct result of law enforcement’s inability to access information that could, but not always, be crucial to criminal and terrorism investigations. The U.S. bill comes after the shooting in San Bernardino, California, that took the lives of 14 people. One of the shooters, Syed Rizwan Farook, left behind a locked iPhone 5C, but Apple refused a court order to create a special tool to weaken the security on the device, fearing that in the wrong hands, it could threaten the security and privacy of all its customers.  The FBI dropped the case as it got access to the phone through to a third-party.

The U.K. and most of Europe are still reeling from recent terror attacks in Brussels and Paris, and while reports say the terrorists are mostly using “burner” phones, anti-encryption legislation is reactionary to the attacks, which have claimed more than a hundred lives.

Editors' Recommendations

Julian Chokkattu
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Julian is the mobile and wearables editor at Digital Trends, covering smartphones, fitness trackers, smartwatches, and more…
Just got an iPhone 15? Get this 6ft fast-charging USB-C cable for $9
The USB-C port on the iPhone 15 Pro Max.

If you've been living in a remote mountain in the Himalayas for the past few months, you may not be aware that the iPhone 15 will now come with a USB-C port. Of course, it's been a long time coming, especially since the European Union mandated that all Manufacturers move to the USB-C port standard. Unfortunately, if you're familiar with and have been using the old port, you might not have a good cable to charge your new iPhone 15. That's where this deal from Monoprice comes in, letting you grab a great type-c to type-c cable for $9 instead of $10, so you can grab a couple and save some extra money.

Why you should buy the Monoprice USB 2.0 Type-C to Type-C Cable
Before we get started, there's an important point we need to clarify. While the new iPhone 15 will have a Type-C port, only the iPhone 15 Pro Max will support the latest USB 3.2 standard with higher data rates. On the other hand, the iPhone 15 and the iPhone 15 Pro will only support the USB 2.0 standard, with PD 18W and 480Mbps data rate, which is a bit slower. Now, while USB 3.2 is backward compatible, it does tend to be a bit more expensive, given the higher standards, which is why, if you have the iPhone 15 or iPhone 15 Pro, it's better to grab a USB 2.0 cable, rather than pay for the more expensive USB 3.2.

Read more
This deal gets you an iPhone 15 Pro Max for free (at Amazon)
An iPhone 15 Pro Max, lying on a wood floor with its display on.

The iPhone 15 Pro Max has been a bit of a divisive device; for some, it's not a big enough upgrade compared to last year's phones, and for others, the switch to USB-C makes this one of the most significant changes to the iPhone since it's inception. Regardless of which camp you lie in, if you want to grab one, Amazon has one of the best sales we've seen on an iPhone 15 Pro Max for a while, and that's saying something, becuase you can get it for free, with caveats. You can get it through Boost with a monthly subscription, so it's locked to them, but besides the subscription fee, taxes and shipping, you can get an iPhone 15 Pro Max without spending several hundred dollars.

Why you should buy the iPhone 15 Pro Max
The iPhone 15 Pro Max has a lot going for it, with the biggest change being the A17 bionic chip, Apple's most advanced, and roughly 20% more powerful than the previous generation. In fact, Apple has claimed that you could run The Division: Resurgence and Resident Evil: Village on the phone, although at what graphical quality and framerate remains to be seen. Another ugprade comes to the cameras, with the most significant one being to the zoom shutter, and the inclusion of an impressive 5x optical zoom, which isn't available in the regular iPhone 15 models. Otherwise, things remain relatively the same, such as the Super Retina XDR OLED running at 120Hz and 2796 x 1290 pixel resolution.

Read more
iPhone 15 Pro Max durability test ends with big surprise
iphone 15 pro max durability tests ends with big surprise test

Zack Nelson of popular YouTube channel JerryRigEverything has been at it again, subjecting yet another phone to the kind of durability test that will leave you wincing in horror.

Be gentle with Apples new Titanium iPhone 15 Pro Max ... Yikes!

Read more