Skip to main content

New video shows Apple designers’ competing early iOS designs

1110296 autosave v1 iphone concept
Image used with permission by copyright holder
The original iPhone was a groundbreaking device when it first launched, and is largely credited with being the first smartphone to really make it into consumer consciousness. Did you know, however, that the original iOS software running on the iPhone could have looked a whole lot different than it does now?

A video has been posted online showing two original iPhone concepts that were created by Apple during development of the phone. The first, called the P1, was created by Tony Fadell and uses the iconic touch-wheel as an on-screen input method, while the second, called the P2, was created Scott Forstall. Both concepts use identical hardware.

During the development process, both phones ran an operating system called Acorn OS, and Apple ended up testing dozens of different variations of what would ultimately become iOS. The P1 and P2 teams were, according to a 9to5Mac article, very competitive during development — they needed to impress the great Steve Jobs.

The battle of the iOS interface iPhone P1 vs P2

In the end, the P2 concept — which used a touchscreen and simply allowed users to tap on icons — won the race, although it ended up looking totally different than it does in the video. According to the video, the P2 concept was the first true touch and app-based phone interface.

Looking back, we’re glad that the iPhone ended up taking a pretty different route than the P1, but at the time those designs made sense. The iPod was a huge hit, and since it used the touch-wheel many people were comfortable with it. Implementing that into a phone would help users more easily control the device.

The iPhone is now 10 years old, so it’s interesting to see the kind of development that was going into a device over a decade ago.

Editors' Recommendations

Christian de Looper
Christian’s interest in technology began as a child in Australia, when he stumbled upon a computer at a garage sale that he…
This could be our first look at iOS 18’s huge redesign
An iPhone 14 Pro Max and iPhone 14 Pro standing upright on a desk.

While iOS 17 fell short on a visual overhaul, Apple is rumored to be working on an updated identity for its next iOS version. Previous reports have claimed that the upcoming iOS 18 will feature visionOS-like elements introduced on the Apple Vision Pro. A new report confirms this with a leaked image of the iOS 18 Camera app.

According to a report from MacRumors, the next version of the Camera app could feature visionOS-style design elements. It is based on an iPhone frame template that the publication received from an anonymous source who claimed to have received it from an iOS engineer. It is said to have been included as part of the Apple Design Resources for iOS 18.

Read more
Everything Apple says is wrong about the DOJ’s iPhone lawsuit
The Apple logo on the iPhone 14 Pro Max.

The antitrust season is in full swing in 2024. This time around, Apple is in the cross-hairs of regulators, bringing back memories of the historic Microsoft antitrust case that unfolded over two decades ago. Back then, the focus was on Windows and web browsers. In Apple’s case, the iPhone is the centerpiece, with a wide ecosystem woven around it.

Experts say the case against Apple, which dives deep into monopolistic conduct, is surprisingly strong. The Department of Justice, in its lawsuit, has targeted everything from the iMessage “green bubble” mess and Apple Watch incompatibility situation to the locked app ecosystem and objectionable practices that Apple has put in place to maintain its alleged monopoly.

Read more
10 reasons you should buy an iPhone in 2024
Purple iPhone 14 (left) and a green iPhone 15 in hand.

The iPhone 15 lineup — which includes the standard iPhone 15 and the iPhone 15 Pro — is the iPhone at its best. It's the latest series of iPhones available today and the default choice if you're buying a new iPhone in 2024.

But it’s not the only choice of iPhones you can purchase. In fact, Apple still sells the iPhone 14, iPhone 13, and the iPhone SE on its website. You could also find other iPhone models available – refurbished or new — from other retailers or carrier stores.

Read more