Texas judge orders accused man to use his fingerprint to unlock iPhone for evidence

iphone fingerprint unlocking texas 5s touchid
The Fifth Amendment to the Constitution enshrines the right to refuse self-incriminatory searches, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t exceptions. Biometrics are one of them: A judge in Texas has ruled that man accused of prostituting underage girls must unlock his iPhone using his fingerprint.

The written proceedings of the trial of the Dallas, Texas man in question paint a picture of a condemnable abuser. Martavious Banks Keys is alleged to have engaged in the sex trafficking of children over the course of two months, forcing girls as young as 14 to ingest drugs and engage in sexual acts in exchange for $150 “a session.” That’s in addition to a long rap sheet: he was convicted in Mississippi of felony vehicle burglary and is prohibited from possessing firearms.

Keys was indicted on June 7 and his possessions, including a laptop and iPhone 5S, were seized. But authorities encountered difficulty in attempting to unlock his phone, according to a search warrant return recently obtained by Ars Technica. “Unable to obtain forensic acquisition [sic] of the describe device,” a forensic investigator wrote. The report doesn’t go into detail, but the barrier was most likely a default iPhone setting which requires, after 48 hours, the use of both a fingerprint and passcode to unlock it.

It’s unclear whether investigators attempted to extract data from Keys iPhone by some other means first. There’s precedent — the U.S. Justice Department recruited a third party to work around security on an iPhone belonging to the San Bernardino gunman. But whatever the case, Judge Magistrate Judge Irma Ramirez apparently saw merit in the prosecution’s argument. “It is further ordered that Martavious Banks Keys shall cooperate with the Agent selected by the government in providing his fingerprints to aid in unlocking his Apple iPhone Model 5S, currently in the custody of the government,” she wrote in a court order dated May 26.

It’s also unclear whether or not the court compelled Keys to provide his passcode, in addition, or whether or not he complied. Refusal could lead Judge Ramirez to hold him in contempt of court, but, as Ars Technica points out, Keys remains behind bars — in other words, he doesn’t have much motivation to do so.

The Keys case is the latest instance of a lower court ordering defendants to unlock fingerprint-protected devices. In 2014, a judge in Virgina ruled that a man accused of strangling his girlfriend provide use his fingerprint to unlock his iPhone. And more recently in May, a California Judge ordered a woman alleged to have committed identity theft to do the same.

Biometric security is physical evidence

That a fingerprint is less secure than a passcode in the eyes of the law may sound a bit counterintuitive, but the case law is fairly unambiguous. The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Riley v. California and United States v. Wurie that investigators can, with a valid search warrant, can compel suspects to forfeit “physical evidence.” A number of legal experts argue that biometric identifiers — e.g., hair, skin, saliva, and fingerprints — fall into that category. “Unlike disclosing passcodes, you are not compelled to speak or say what’s ‘in your mind’ to law enforcement,” Albert Gidari, Stanford Law School’s director of privacy, told the LA Times. “‘Put your finger here’ is not testimonial.”

But others argue that, as society becomes increasingly dependent on biometric forms of security like Apple’s Touch ID and Microsoft’s Hello on Windows, the Fifth Amendment’s protection against self-incrimination will effectively become meaningless. “[The] government could [eventually] demand that we produce [passwords] without implicating anything we know,” said privacy attorney Marcia Hoffman in a 2013 essay published in Wired. “[That] would make it less likely that a valid privilege against self-incrimination would apply.”

The Supreme Court has yet to hear a case involving the sort of biometric encryption at hand, here. But given the relative consensus among courts thus far — the Supreme Court typically only addresses legal issues which have been interpreted contradictorily by lower courts — a decision in the near future seems unlikely.


Soulja Boy’s ‘new’ console appears to include stolen Nintendo games

Rapper Soulja Boy recently released his SouljaGame console, and it includes several emulated games that appear to be stolen from companies like Nintendo, SNK, and Capcom. A handheld version is also available.
Digital Trends Live

Marshawn Lynch joins Digital Trends Live to talk charity, football

On a special episode of Digital Trends Live, Oakland Raiders running back Marshawn Lynch joined host Greg Nibler to talk about his charitable foundation, Phones for the Homeless, and the Fan Controlled Football League.
Movies & TV

The best shows on Netflix, from 'Haunting of Hill House’ to ‘Twilight Zone’

Looking for a new show to binge? Lucky for you, we've curated a list of the best shows on Netflix, whether you're a fan of outlandish anime, dramatic period pieces, or shows that leave you questioning what lies beyond.

How to use the ECG app, set up irregular rhythm notifications on the Apple Watch

The Apple Watch Series 4 is the best smartwatch iPhone owners can own, and it just got even better with the addition of the ECG app and ability to identify irregular heart rhythms. Here's how to set it all up.
Home Theater

Common AirPods problems, and how to fix them

Apple’s AirPods are among the best fully wireless earbuds we’ve seen, but they’re not perfect. If you’re having trouble, take a look at our guide to the most common problems and what you can do to fix them.

The LG V40 ThinQ, G7 ThinQ, and Watch W7 are discounted for the holidays

LG announced a series of deals for the holiday season where you can buy the company's two flagship phones, the V40 ThinQ and G7 ThinQ, as well as its latest smartwatch, for between $150 and $200 off, depending on the device.

Midrange phones can’t do A.I., but MediaTek’s P90 chip aims to change that

MediaTek has announced the Helio P90 mobile processor, which it says will bring the best A.I. features we see on high-end smartphones, to the mid-range. We spoke to the company about the chip.

5G’s arrival is transforming tech. Here’s everything you need to know to keep up

It has been years in the making, but 5G is finally becoming a reality. While 5G coverage is still extremely limited, expect to see it expand in 2019. Not sure what 5G even is? Here's everything you need to know.

Want to watch Netflix in bed or browse the web? We have a tablet for everyone

There’s so much choice when shopping for a new tablet that it can be hard to pick the right one. From iPads to Android, these are our picks for the best tablets you can buy right now whatever your budget.

McLaren puts the pedal to the metal in special-edition OnePlus 6T

The OnePlus 6T is yet another flagship killer smartphone, bringing powerful specifications to a much lower price than the competition. Now, OnePlus has teamed up with McLaren for the OnePlus 6T McLaren Edition.

G’day, Google: U.S. users can now give Assistant a British or Australian accent

U.S. Google Assistant users can give their Assistant a different voice. Google has updated Assistant with the ability for users to give it either a British or Australian accent, which could make it a little more personal for some.

Tune in to the best internet radio stations for your listening pleasure

Even in the streaming era, radio stations get some of the best exclusives and curate some of the finest handpicked playlists around. Here are the best internet radio stations, for your listening pleasure.

Microsoft’s latest patent paves the way for Andromeda dual-screen mobile device

The latest patent discovery from Microsoft showcases a new hinge design for quickly opening a dual-screen mobile device with a single hand. Could this be additional proof surrounding the rumors of the company's Project Andromeda device?

Need to record calls on an iPhone? Check out our handy guide

Are you wondering how to record calls on your iPhone? It isn't as easy as you might think, but we'll walk you through the process of doing so with Google Voice, and identify several other apps and external voice recorders that can help.