Comcast is on our side? ISPs win against porn copyright trolls, civil liberties groups rejoice

isps win one copyright trolls civil liberties groups rejoice
Photo via Shutterstock

The country’s top ISPs have won a mass piracy lawsuit that may weaken the future claims of copyright trolls all over the country. A coalition of broadband providers made up of Verizon, Comcast, AT&T, Cox Communications and Bright House Networks gained a victory on appeal against a studio that sought to obtain the identities of Internet users that allegedly downloaded a pornographic film through BitTorrent.

In his decision, Judge David Tatel mentioned the infamous reputation of porn studio AF Holdings’ counsel, Prenda Law, which was once described by California district court judge Otis Wright II as a “porno-trolling collective.”

“Prenda Law’s general approach was to identify certain unknown persons whose IP addresses were used to download pornographic films, sue them in gigantic multi-defendant suits that minimized filing fees, discover the identities of the persons to whom these IP address were assigned by serving subpoenas on the Internet service providers to which the addresses pertained, then negotiate settlements with the underlying subscribers—a “strategy [that] was highly successful because of statutory- copyright damages, the pornographic subject matter, and the high cost of litigation,” Judge Tatel said in his opinion.

Civil liberties groups applauded the decision, calling it “a crushing blow against a legal linchpin of the copyright troll business model.”

Tatel said that copyright holders may not abuse the legal process for inappropriate purposes: “…sometimes individuals seek to manipulate judicial procedures to serve their own improper ends. This case calls upon us to evaluate—and put a stop to— one litigant’s attempt to do just that,” he said.

AF Holdings won a district court case in Washington two years ago. As a result of the ruling, the court authorized the issuing of subpoenas, ordering the ISPs to provide the names, addresses, telephone numbers and email addresses linked to the IP addresses that the studio had identified. The ISPs refused to comply, citing that the order subjected them to “undue burden.”

The companies said that the cost of following the order imposed undue burden because most of the would-be defendants weren’t even residents of the District of Columbia. Verizon said that only 20 of the 188 subscribers involved in the case lived in the area. With Comcast, it was one in 400. Cox, AT&T and Bright House, on the other hand, don’t even offer services in the federal district.

“If an identified defendant sought to actually litigate, Prenda Law would simply dismiss the case. As Duffy acknowledged at oral argument, of the more than one hundred cases that AF Holdings has initiated, none has proceeded to trial or resulted in any judgment in its favor other than by default.”

Civil liberties groups like the Electronic Frontier Foundation, American Civil Liberties Union, Public Citizen and Public Knowledge applauded the decision, calling it “a crushing blow against a legal linchpin of the copyright troll business model.” 

“This decision is a crucial victory,” said EFF Intellectual Property Director Corynne McSherry, who argued the case in support of the ISPs. “We are thrilled that a higher court has recognized that it is unfair to sue thousands of people at once, in a court far from home, based on nothing more than an allegation that they joined a BitTorrent swarm.”  

The movie in question is called Popular Demand. In its original complaint, AF Holdings attached an assignment agreement through, which it claimed to have received the rights to the movie. Other courts have since concluded that at least one of the signatures in the documents were forged.

Mobile

You can now message businesses straight through Google Maps

Google has been updating Maps with a ton of new features over the past few months, and now it's back with another one -- the ability for users to message businesses directly through the Maps app.
Movies & TV

The best shows on Netflix, from 'The Haunting of Hill House’ to ‘The Good Place’

Looking for a new show to binge? Lucky for you, we've curated a list of the best shows on Netflix, whether you're a fan of outlandish anime, dramatic period pieces, or shows that leave you questioning what lies beyond.
Home Theater

The best movies on Netflix in November, from 'The Witch’ to ‘Dracula’

Save yourself from hours wasted scrolling through Netflix's massive library by checking out our picks for the streamer's best movies available right now, whether you're into explosive action, witty humor, or anything else.
Mobile

No cash. No talking. What goes next? Welcome to your ‘app-tive’ digital life

Bank of America's 2018 Trends in Consumer Mobility Report found mobility has changed our lives. Mobile tech influences how most of us communicate, meet people, build relationships, and handle money as we move toward a cashless society.
Mobile

The Motiv smart ring is coming to 20 more countries and physical stores

Remember Motiv's activity tracking smart ring? It's back with a raft of new features that adds biometric identification and token authentication, all on a device that fits on your finger.
Wearables

Everything you need to know about Garmin’s GPS watches and trackers

Garmin jumped into the GPS smartwatch and fitness tracker market five years ago and has built a portfolio of devices that rivals competitor Fitbit. Here's your guide to the latest and greatest fitness devices that Garmin has to offer.
Mobile

Sharp doubles down on the notch trend with Aquos R2 Compact

As if one notch wasn't enough, Japanese manufacturer Sharp unveiled a new smartphone that has two -- one teardrop style notch at the top, and a bigger notch at the bottom. Here's what the world's first dual-notch smartphone looks like.
Mobile

Verizon has made its first 5G video call … with a phone that’s already out

Verizon has announced that it has successfully made its first video call, using a smartphone that's already available: The Motorola Moto Z3. To make the call, Verizon used the 5G Moto Mod.
Mobile

Samsung patents show what Infinity-O display could look like on Galaxy S10

While we still may be months away from an announcement, there's no doubt about it: Samsung is working hard on its successor to the Galaxy S9. Here's everything we know about the upcoming Samsung Galaxy S10.
Home Theater

Google Chromecast and Chromecast Ultra: Everything you need to know

Google's Chromecast plugs into your TV's HDMI port, allowing you to stream content from your tablet, laptop, or smartphone directly to your TV. Here's what you need to know about all iterations, including the 4K-ready Chromecast Ultra.
Mobile

The best protective iPhone cases to defend against dirt, dings, and drops

If you’re going off-road or work outdoors, it could be a good idea to invest in a tough case. These are our picks of the best protective iPhone cases for all iterations of the iPhone, from the iPhone XS to the 7.
Social Media

Build a wish list and shop videos with Instagram’s latest shopping update

Eyeing a product on Instagram? Now there are more ways to shop from the social network. Instagram just rolled out options to save products in a collection as users can also now shop from videos.
Product Review

With style and feature upgrades, Misfit's next-generation Vapor 2 gets it right

Misfit’s next-generation smartwatch, the Vapor 2, packs built-in GPS, a heart-rate sensor, and more, into a beautiful design that starts from $250. We take a closer look at the company's latest device.
Deals

All the Best Target Black Friday deals for 2018

The mega-retailer opens its doors to the most competitive shoppers at 6 p.m. on Thursday, November 22, and signs indicate that the retailer means business this year. We've sifted through all of the deals, from consumer electronics to small…