Skip to main content

The Nothing Phone 1’s biggest problem isn’t the lights — it’s something else

The Nothing Phone 1’s Glyph Interface — what Nothing calls the system of lights, sounds, and vibrations that make the Phone 1 unique — is controversial enough that it has already received some hate. Some people can’t see the point of it. They think it’s a gimmick, ugly, or simply sneer and consider it a transparent (sorry) marketing ploy to attract those who will gladly hand over money in exchange for shiny things.

While true to a certain extent, it’s a bit of an overreaction, and the Glyph Interface has more depth to its features than one would expect. The thing is, having now used the Nothing Phone 1 for a while, there is a hint of a far more impactful problem with the phone, but it has nothing (sorry again) to do with the lights on the back. Instead, it’s to do with the software inside.

Great software … right now

At the moment, the Nothing Phone 1’s software is delightfully clean, with no Nothing-specific email app or browser app to hide in a folder, no dubious in-your-face “features” that only appeal to a tiny percentage of owners, and very little in the way of frustrating design. It makes the phone enjoyable to use. It runs so smoothly you almost glide through the menus, which is absurdly satisfying.

Nothing Phone 1 held in hand showing the screen and Nothing's wallpaper.
Andy Boxall/Digital Trends

NothingOS gets a very big tick in our review, and that effortless, uncluttered nature is a big part of the reason why. It’s particularly refreshing when competing operating systems — including the one from Nothing founder Carl Pei’s former company, OnePlus — are only becoming more complex, messy, and frustrating to use. Phones shouldn’t be like that, and happily, it goes against Nothing’s ethos of “making tech feel like nothing.”

The company is paying attention, too. In the latest software update, Nothing made it so the Google search bar on the home screen can be deleted, a change from its earlier version and a correction of a frustration noted in our review, as well as by Nothing beta testers. Well, we’re hoping it’s also listening now, because there’s some evidence Nothing isn’t absolutely committed to keeping NothingOS as a clean, fuss-free operating system.

Teslas, NFTs, oh my!

So what’s the problem? Listed under Experimental Features in the Phone 1’s Settings menu is “Connect to Tesla,” where you can apparently control your Tesla car from the Phone 1. Its presence is very concerning. Why is it there? Isn’t there an app for this already, and what benefit would there be for a Tesla owner to use the Nothing phone instead of it? What percentage of Nothing Phone 1 owners have a Tesla, or what percentage of Tesla owners plan to buy a Phone 1? Or, for that matter, what percentage of Tesla owners would consider a midrange phone at all?

For most Nothing Phone 1 owners, it’s a pointless baked-in feature that can be ignored, but it’s one of two new “features” that threaten to take the Phone 1’s software away from simplicity and toward hateful complication. It’s joined by a new NFT Gallery widget, where you can proudly show your NFTs on the home screen and track prices too. Admittedly, anything overtly promoting NFTs instantly puts me off, but again, like the Tesla app, is there really any real demand for this kind of widget or feature?

Both of these feel like marketing exercises, created to grab headlines because they mention hot topics connected to loud fan bases — not real features that will ever appeal to the masses. They certainly don’t offer anything you can’t get from a third-party, optional app already. Nothing’s software is currently very pleasant to use, and thankfully, neither of these “bonuses” are intrusive right now. But they could be the beginnings of niche feature creep for Nothing, and that’s a step in the wrong direction that could lead it down a path that eventually ruins NothingOS.

Don’t ruin this, Nothing

We’ve seen it many times before, but OnePlus’ OxygenOS is probably the best and most relevant example of what not to do. OxygenOS was once like NothingOS, a flowing operating system that held its own against Android on a Google Pixel phone, but today is a shadow of its former self due to it becoming a facsimile of Oppo’s ColorOS. No one wants endless interruptions, duplicate apps, or dubiously named tools thought up by a marketing team, because they slow everything down.

OnePlus 10 Pro Quick Settings screen.
Andy Boxall/Digital Trends

NothingOS today is not like that, and for a debut phone from a relatively new company, it shows impressive restraint. At least I hope it’s restraint, and not either an inability to have any software fluff ready at launch, or a tempting blank canvas over which it now intends to scribble digital graffiti.

Anyone thinking the Glyph Interface lights are “what’s wrong with the Nothing Phone 1” are sorely mistaken. There’s actually not much wrong with the phone at all, especially for its very competitive price. It’s the threat of pointless non-features being gradually introduced that could become far more of an issue for the Phone 1. Nothing needs to tread carefully as it balances a keenness to leap aboard any hype train with keeping what makes the Nothing Phone 1 so good to use at the moment.

Editors' Recommendations

Andy Boxall
Senior Mobile Writer
Andy is a Senior Writer at Digital Trends, where he concentrates on mobile technology, a subject he has written about for…
iOS 16.3.1 fixes major bugs for your iPhone — and introduces a new one
Lock screen widget for iOS 16.

Apple just released a new iOS update for your iPhone: iOS 16.3.1. There are also updates for iPadOS 16.3.1 and macOS 13.2.1. All of these are relatively minor updates, but they do patch up an actively exploited code execution vulnerability that was found in WebKit/Safari. A second vulnerability was also patched up, though this second one was not known to be actively exploited.

But that’s not all that iOS 16.3.1 brings. This update also fixes an issue with iCloud settings, where it became unresponsive. Another bug fix corrects an issue with using Siri with the Find My feature, where the request would end up failing. If you have a HomePod, there is a HomePod 16.3.2 OS update that will also resolve some Siri issues, where smart home requests would end up failing.

Read more
The Nothing Phone 2 is real, and it’s coming to the U.S. this year
Nothing Phone 1 Glyph Interface lights.

The Nothing Phone 2 will be coming to the U.S. this year, CEO Carl Pei said today. The company previously launched its first entry into the smartphone market in Europe and Asia due to resource constraints.

“We decided to make the U.S. our No. 1 priority in terms of markets,” CEO Carl Pei said in an interview with Inverse. “We couldn't do it earlier because we were only in our second year and our hands were tied building the team as we were building the products. Now as we're on a more solid footing, we can take a step forward.”

Read more
The Nothing Phone 1 has finally launched in the U.S. — kind of
The Nothing Phone 1's camera module.

The Nothing Phone 1 launched globally last year with vague promises of a future U.S. release, but now Nothing fans don't have to wait any longer for the smartphone to make its way stateside. Soft-launching through a "Beta Membership," the Nothing Phone 1 is finally available for Americans who are willing to be a part of Nothing's test program before it officially launches with retailers later in 2023.

While it's certainly exciting for the Nothing Phone 1 to be making its way to the U.S., the release and branding of the membership program are a little odd. It gives fans the opportunity to try out the phone and test Nothing OS 1.5, which is based on Android 13 and represents a major update from Nothing OS 1.0's Android 12 foundation. If you want in, you need to pay $299.

Read more