Washington’s plans to ‘end’ NSA telephone metadata collection: What you need to know

Obama ending metadata collection

Nearly 10 months after the Guardian first reported that the National Security Agency (NSA) secretly collects the telephone metadata of virtually every landline call made in the United States, that program is set to undergo dramatic changes. Reports from The New York Times and Wall Street Journal reveal that both the Obama administration and members of Congress plan to push legislation that – if enacted – would, in some ways, “end” the NSA’s bulk telephone metadata collection program, which operates under Section 215 of the Patriot Act. What does this mean for Americans’ privacy? Here’s everything you need to know.

Wait – what is ‘metadata’ again?

Telephone metadata is all the information related to a phone call aside from the contents of the call itself. That means a whole bunch of numbers – outgoing and incoming phone numbers involved in a call, time and duration of a call, sometimes location data of a mobile call, and sometimes the device ID numbers of the phones involved in calls.

This information is used by the NSA to see who is talking to whom (among other things). And while it does not include recordings of what’s said during calls, metadata alone can reveal a vast amount of information about people’s lives.

Obama’s plan

At the moment, there appear to be two plans in the works, and both would effectively do the same thing – the difference, along with the devil, is in the details.

First, the Obama administration reportedly plans to transfer the collection of telephone metadata to the telephone companies (which are already collecting that data anyway). They would not be required to hold the data for longer than the current 18-month maximum. The NSA, by contrast, currently holds telephone metadata for up to five years.

Using this new court order, the NSA would have access to the call history of targeted numbers.

Under President Obama’s new plan, the NSA would obtain metadata about specific phone numbers from telephone companies using a new type of court order. Using this new court order, the NSA would have access to the call history of targeted numbers, as well as continuous access to new calls received or placed by those numbers. Furthermore, the court order would give the NSA access to call records of phone calls up to two “hops” from the targeted number. (The NSA has long had the ability to access records up to three “hops” from a targeted number.) And it would require phone companies to standardize their data.

Here’s the catch for privacy advocates: Most of the telephone metadata the NSA currently collects pertains to calls made on landline phones. Data from calls made from most mobile phones are not collected. The Obama plan would change that, the LA Times reports, by expanding “the universe of calling records the agency can access.” 

This plan, if enacted by Congress, would essentially make good on President Obama’s promise to end the NSA’s bulk telephone metadata collection – but it would still allow the NSA to access that data as it deems necessary, and greatly expand the types of call data it can collect.

Rogers and Ruppersberger plan

Rep. Mike Rogers
Rep. Mike Rogers

The second option is reportedly set to come from leadership of the House Intelligence Committee: Chairman Mike Rogers (R – MI) and ranking Democrat Rep. C.A. “Dutch” Ruppersberger (D – MD). As the Wall Street Journal reports, Obama’s proposal and the forthcoming House bill would do basically the same thing – but the House bill wouldn’t require the government agencies (i.e. the NSA and FBI) to obtain a judge’s approval before obtaining data, something civil liberty advocates are sure to oppose. It would, however, require a court to “promptly” approve the data request once it’s been made to a phone company. If the court rejects the request, any data the government obtains would have to be deleted.

But that’s not all …

While the Obama proposal would apply specifically to telephone metadata collection, the House bill goes much further into our digital lives.

Dubbed the “End Bulk Collection Act of 2014,” the House bill would reform the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act to prevent government collection of “records of any electronic communication without the use of specific identifiers or selection terms,” according to the Guardian, which obtained a copy of the bill. As the Washington Post reports, that means it would end all bulk collection of “any electronic communication,” according to Rogers and Ruppersberger – both of whom have vigorously defended the NSA’s surveillance activities. That likely includes emails, text messages, and Internet activity.

Civil liberties advocates are already calling foul on the House bill.

While preventing bulk electronic communication collection, the House bill would also lower the legal standard for collecting specific information. From the Guardian: “… the bill would allow the government to collect electronic communications records based on ‘reasonable articulable suspicion’, rather than probable cause or relevance to a terrorism investigation, from someone deemed to be an agent of a foreign power, associated with an agent of a foreign power, or ‘in contact with, or known to, a suspected agent of a foreign power.’

Thanks to the retroactive approval of phone metadata collection, the lowered standard for the collection of electronic communications, and the fact that Rogers and Ruppersberger have consistently proposed legislation that increases the government’s ability to collect information from Internet users (remember CISPA?) , civil liberties advocates are already calling foul on the House bill.

“As a general rule, whenever Mike Rogers … claims a bill does something particular – like, say, protect your privacy – it’s actually a fairly safe assumption that the opposite will end up true,” Trevor Timm, executive director of the Freedom of the Press Foundation, writes in the Guardian. “His new bill seems to have the goal of trading government bulk collection for even more NSA power to search Americans’ data while it sits in the hands of the phone companies.”

Two imperfect options

While both of these options appear to effectively end the NSA’s metadata collection, neither are perfect, according to privacy advocates. In a level-headed response to the reported plans, Harley Geiger, Senior Counsel at the Center for Democracy & Technology, summed up the situation thusly:

“While each proposal represents a step forward, each also has a fatal flaw. The Ruppersberger bill would end bulk collection for most types of data, but the bill would allow intelligence agencies to obtain individuals’ data without prior court approval. The President’s proposal, as described, would require intelligence agencies to get court approval before obtaining phone records, but the Obama proposal is only limited to phone records. Combined, these two proposals would get us close to where we need to be, but separately they fall short of what is needed.”

What next?

Obama had originally ordered the Justice Department and intelligence officials to finalize their plan for ending the NSA’s collection of telephone metadata by March 28 – this Friday – which is when the current 90-day order from the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC) that allows the program to continue expires. Seeing as the proposal is reportedly still in the works, however, it’s all but guaranteed that FISC will reauthorize the order for another 90 days. In other words, the NSA’s telephone metadata collection likely won’t stop for at least another three months.

As for the End Bulk Collection Act of 2014 – that’s still in its early stages. (It is set to go public today, March 25, and I’ll update this with a link to the text as soon as it does. Update: Here’s the bill.) Then, of course, it has to go through all the regular avenues of Congress before it can go into effect, as does the Obama plan. So neither are going to come into effect immediately.

(Image © maradonna 8888 via Shutterstock)


‘Final Fantasy VII Remake’ director sets record straight on game’s progress

Final Fantasy VII Remake director Tetsuya Nomura clarified some information about the game's progress. There were earlier reports that the RPG was put on hold in favor of Kingdom Hearts III, but that is apparently not the case.

Dominate in multiplayer with a few of our favorite 'Battlefield 5' weapons

Here are some of the best weapons you can use to get the upper hand in Battlefield 5's multiplayer, including assault rifles, sniper rifles, pistols, and anti-tank tools.
Movies & TV

More cast members join Jordan Peele’s ‘The Twilight Zone’ reboot

Get Out writer and director Jordan Peele is developing and hosting a reboot of the classic sci-fi anthology series The Twilight Zone for CBS All Access, and the cast for the first season is filling out with some familiar faces.

Here’s how to install Windows on a Chromebook

If you want to push the functionality of your new Chromebook to another level, and Linux isn't really your deal, you can try installing Windows on a Chromebook. Here's how to do so, just in case you're looking to nab some Windows-only…

Apple confirms it’s collecting data on foot to improve its Maps app

Apple has been using cars and satellites to improve its Maps app, and it's now confirmed it's also using tech-laden pedestrians to collect data from the streets in a bid to provide better walking directions.
Social Media

Why an American named John Lewis gets lots of Twitter hassle from Brits

Spare a thought for Twitter user John Lewis. When he signed up as @johnlewis soon after the app launched in 2006, little did he know what he was letting himself in for. Clue: There's a U.K. department store called John Lewis.

Selfie-mad Meitu phones are now made by Xiaomi, may be sold globally

Meitu, a Chinese brand best known for its selfie and beautification software, has handed over its smartphone business to Xiaomi. The company now has the global license to produce phones using the Meitu name.

Huawei's folding smartphone reportedly will launch at MWC 2019

Huawei will release a folding smartphone with 5G connectivity in 2019, according to the CEO and executives for the company. Rumors are also spreading to take away some of the mystery surrounding the exciting device.

Keep your Galaxy S8 and S8 Plus free of smudges with a screen protector

The display on Samsung's Galaxy S8 is gorgeous, but it's not exactly rugged. Thankfully, these screen protectors will help you safeguard your new device from unwanted wear and tear.

5G version of upcoming Galaxy S10 may feature 6.7-inch display, six cameras

While we still may be months away from an announcement, there's no doubt about it: Samsung is working hard on its successor to the Galaxy S9. Here's everything we know about the upcoming Samsung Galaxy S10.

Photos attributed to midrange Google Pixel Sargo suggest flagship-quality camera

The Google Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL are considered to be two of the best Android smartphones, but it looks like Google could be prepping a third. A budget Pixel 3 that boasts some of the best features of the other two has been leaked.

T-Mobile OnePlus 6T phones get some improvements in update

The new OnePlus 6T continues OnePlus's tradition, coming with flagship power, camera performance, and the gorgeous design you want -- but for under $600. Here's everything you need to know about the OnePlus 6T.
Smart Home

You can now make Skype calls on Amazon Echo devices

Amazon's Alexa can now make video and voice calls with Microsoft's Skype audio and video calling. Alexa-enabled devices can make voice calls. Alexa devices with video can make video calls to computers, mobile devices, and Xboxes.

Sprint offers holiday buy one, get one free deal for iPhone XR lease

After months of rumors and speculation, Apple has finally taken the wraps off of the new iPhone XS, iPhone XS Max, and iPhone XR. Now that the phones are out, you might be wondering how you can get them for yourself.