Opinion: Carriers will continue to crush consumers until the FCC gets a bigger hammer

fcc board directorsMan, the FCC has sure been on a roll the past few months, hasn’t it? Slapping Comcast with a fine for violating consumer-friendly agreements made, dogging Google for the Street View fiasco, and now, barring Verizon from blocking tethering apps. The FCC is sure showing big business who’s boss, huh?

It definitely is. Unfortunately, the boss isn’t the FCC — it’s the businesses that dare to violate consumer rights and pre-standing agreements.

All the deterrence of a 50-cent parking ticket

“Today’s action demonstrates that compliance with FCC obligations is not optional,” agency Chairman Julius Genachowski said in the wake of the Verizon ruling. Actually, it did the exact opposite.

Let’s take a brief journey back in time: In 2008, Verizon won an auction for a coveted section of wireless spectrum called the C Block from the FCC. The C Block covers a wide swath of the nation and is home to Verizon’s 4G LTE network. Before the bidding even started, the FCC declared that the winner could not artificially restrict its users’ choice of compatible devices or apps on any networks built using the spectrum. Verizon agreed to the terms.

easy tether android google play app cellular data tetheringThen, in 2011, Big Red asked Google to block third-party tethering apps in the Android Market. Why? To get you to pay an extra $20 per month for wireless hotspot capabilities, of course.

It was a giant metaphorical middle finger pointed directly at consumers and the FCC.

The penalty for this disrespect and Verizon’s bold violation of the agreement? After a year and a half of raking in exorbitant tethering fees in defiance of the rules, Verizon has to pay a $1.25 million fine and must allow third-party tethering apps. That’s not even a whisper on the wrist, much less a slap on the wrist.

A million dollar fine would cripple you or me, but it’s chump change to Verizon — the equivalent of around $1.25 per customer, going by the latest numbers. The company made dozens of billions of dollars last quarter with record margins.

Even the free tethering portion of the ruling isn’t all it’s cracked up to be. Verizon’s new Share Everything plans — the only option available for new subscribers — include wireless hotspot capabilities as part of your monthly charge. Basically, in a year or two, everyone will be paying for tethering anyway, just in a lump sum instead of a separate fee, conveniently circumventing the FCC agreement. (The new plans are a trap, too, in case you were wondering.)

The FCC allowed the app-blocking to continue unabated when it mattered the most, and only barred the practice when its significance started to fade.

Weak enforcement encourages anti-consumer shenanigans

Verizon’s whisper on the wrist isn’t a onetime occurrence, either. When Comcast violated an agreement to offer low-cost broadband after its merger with NBC Universal, it received an $800,000 fine. Google’s Safari privacy scandal will likely result in a negotiated $22.5 million fine — with no admittance of wrongdoing. Perhaps most egregious, Google was only fined $25,000 for willfully blocking the FCC’s investigation of Google’s privacy-invading Street View data collection. (What ever happened to Do No Evil, by the way?)

These companies make more than that in a day. Heck, Google’s Street View fine didn’t even amount to an hour’s worth of revenue for the company. Why would a profit-focused company hesitate to step on consumer toes or violate standing agreements if the penalties add up to the equivalent of pocket change?fcc logo on iphone smartphone

It isn’t entirely the FCC’s fault. Julius Genachowski and company are doing the best they can. In fact, today’s FCC is much more engaged in protecting consumers than it has been in the past — but laws and limits on the books prevent the agency from really throwing the book at misbehaving organizations. The $25,000 Street View penalty was actually the maximum amount the FCC is allowed to fine a company for tampering with an agency investigation, which is utterly ludicrous.

The FCC is suffering from the same problem as the patent system; it’s saddled with paperwork-imposed limitations that just aren’t effective in today’s day and age.

Bigger problems call for a bigger hammer

We don’t necessarily need new laws. We just need to enforce the existing ones with enough ferocity to scare off executives that look at the line between profits and proper actions with a thoughtful look on their faces. If a company breaks the rules, it needs to bleed. (Bleed cash, that is.)

Verizon’s accountants probably write $1.25 million checks in their sleep, but I’m guessing a $125 million fine — or a $1.25 billion fine — would be a different matter entirely.

Moving to massive fines won’t even be unprecedented; companies fear the European Union’s wrath much, much more than the FCC’s, in a large part because the EU isn’t afraid to toss out whopping $1 billion-plus dollar fines when it’s appropriate.

In the EU, the European Commission can fine a company up to 10 percent of its yearly turnover. Income-based fines can hurt major companies that can otherwise shrug off the relatively minor penalties imposed by the FCC.

If we want companies to follow the rules, we have to be able to effectively punish companies when they break them. Why stay on the straight and narrow when it’s so financially worthwhile to shrug off the laws and shake the pennies out of your pocket as a penalty?

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.


Google’s updated Santa Tracker entertains and teaches coding throughout December

Google's Santa Tracker is in its fifteenth year and is back again with even more features. You can have fun with more than 20 games, learn about different holiday traditions around the world, and enjoy some festive animations.
Movies & TV

The best shows on Netflix, from 'Haunting of Hill House’ to ‘Twilight Zone’

Looking for a new show to binge? Lucky for you, we've curated a list of the best shows on Netflix, whether you're a fan of outlandish anime, dramatic period pieces, or shows that leave you questioning what lies beyond.

5G’s arrival is transforming tech. Here’s everything you need to know to keep up

It has been years in the making, but 5G is finally becoming a reality. While 5G coverage is still extremely limited, expect to see it expand in 2019. Not sure what 5G even is? Here's everything you need to know.
Movies & TV

From 'GLOW' to 'Haunting of Hill House,' these are the best Netflix Originals

Netflix's stable of content has grown quickly, and the streaming service now boasts dozens of shows produced in-house. Looking for the cream of the crop? These are our picks for the best Netflix Original series.

Free yourself! How to unlock a phone from the icy hands of your wireless carrier

Do you want to know how to unlock a phone through your carrier or a third-party service like DoctorSIM? Regardless of which way you want to go, we've compiled a list of requirements and methods for doing so.

The best weather apps for the iPhone

Don't rely solely on your local meteorologist to stay up to date on the weather. Take matters into your own hands with one of these weather apps, each of which brings something unique to the table.

The $200 TicWatch C2 smartwatch is now being sold in the U.S. and U.K.

Digital well-being and disconnecting from your phone is one of 2018's big trends. Mobvoi wants you to think about its TicWatch C2 smartwatch as a great way to help you use your phone less.

The Palm has been revived, and is now available in the U.S. and U.K.

A reboot of the classic Palm is finally here and it's tiny. It syncs to your phone and acts as a secondary device -- with a feature to help you disconnect from technology. The Palm will be available exclusively through Verizon for $350.

Yes, we really are getting a special McLaren edition of the OnePlus 6T

OnePlus has announced a partnership with McLaren F1, emphasizing a shared interest in speed. The phone company is known for producing special edition devices. Here's what we know about the OnePlus 6T Mclaren Edition.

Simplify your life with one of these wireless smartphone charger deals

Banish nightly cable fumbling with a wireless smartphone charger. If your smartphone is compatible with wireless charging, the simplicity of placing it on a pad is a beautiful thing. Wireless chargers are also excellent gifts for coworkers.

Microsoft Outlook for iOS gets big redesign, with Dark Mode coming soon

Microsoft has deployed a huge redesign for its Outlook for iOS app, which includes new blue branding and some quality-of-life improvements. Dark Mode isn't included, but it's coming soon.

Our favorite Windows apps will help you get the most out of your new PC

Not sure what apps you should be downloading for your newfangled Windows device? Here are the best Windows apps, whether you need something to speed up your machine or access your Netflix queue. Check out our categories and favorite picks.

Car-branded phones need to make a U-turn if they ever want to impress

Your car and your smartphone are becoming one, yet smartphones branded or co-created by car companies are a problem. We look at the history, some examples of the best and worst, then share hopes for the future.

Vanquish lag for good with the best routers for gaming

Finding the best routers for gaming is no easy task. With so many out there, how do you know which to pick? We've looked at the many options available and put together a list of our lag-free favorites.