Qualcomm Spurns Nokia’s $20 Million

Some might argue that a good patent battle is like a good wine: you can get the gist of it with a quick taste, but the true enjoyment comes from savoring the finer points.

Maybe one day the long-running dispute between mobile technology developers Qualcomm and Nokia will get to that stage…but for now it’s still just a ham-handed slap fight as each company accuses the other of wrongdoing and stealing intellectual property.

Readers might recall last week when Nokia offered Qualcomm $20 million to continue licensing key Qualcomm patents related to UMTS technology after April 9, 2007. In doing so, Nokia pointedly noted the money was not payment for use of Qualcomm patents covering CDMA/WCDMA technologies, which it considered to be “paid-up and royalty free.”

Qualcomm is having none of it: the San Diego company has spurned Nokia’s $20 million, characterizing the payment as a “fraction of the royalty to which Nokia agreed” in a 2001 licensing agreement, and accused Nokia of attempting to “mislead the industry and the investment community.” Qualcomm is taking Nokia to arbitration…and that’s on top of Qualcomm’s new litigation against Nokia over GSM technologies.

And Nokia? It isn’t buying any of Qualcomm’s assertions, Nokia issued a statement today claiming Qualcomm uses more than 100 Nokia GSM/WCDMA and CDMA2000 patents in its chipsets and that the San Diego company is the world’s largest user of Nokia technology and patents. Separately, Nokia claims to have paid less than a three percent gross royalty in aggregate license fees on WCDMA handset sales, including all WCDMA royalty payments made to Qualcomm. Qualcomm’s ears perked up at that assertion, and now believes Nokia may owe it even more money, saying that if Nokia’s claims are true, it would mean “Nokia has seriously underpaid royalties owed to Qualcomm under the parties’ 2001 license agreement and is in material breach of the agreement.” We can presume Qualcomm is sharpening up even more lawyers for this patent showdown.

But Qualcomm’s adversaries don’t start and stop with Nokia. Today, semiconductor and chip maker Broadcom charged Qualcomm with violating California law by concealing its patents, reneging on license obligations, engaging in misconduct before standards bodies, and exerting pressure on companies through hidden affiliations. “We now know that Qualcomm has been playing games with industry standards processes for years, leaving both consumers and competitors like Broadcom to pay a heavy price,” said David A. Dull, Broadcom’s senior VP and General Counsel, in a statement. “Our goal is to put a stop to this improper behavior and force Qualcomm to play by the same rules that apply to its competitors as well as its own customers.”

In its complaint, Broadcom cites instances where Qualcomm hid its patents from standards bodies and hiring members of technology working groups who did not disclose their Qualcomm ties. In the first instance, Qualcomm was found to have concealed patents from the organization which developed the H.264 video compression standard; a penalty hearing in that matter is scheduled for May 2, 2007. Separately, Broadcom notes that Qualcomm tried to dominate the IEEE 802.20 working group by covertly hiring several of its members, and neither the company nor the members disclosed their affiliation. The 802.20 standards working group had been working on a 4G wireless communication system; it is now suspended.

Broadcom’s 37-page complaint seeks unspecified compensation and punitive damages, and an injunction which would prevent Qualcomm from trying to enforce particular mobile, video, and cellular patents against Broadcom or its customers.


HMD Global admits Nokia 7 Plus handsets sent user data to China

Nokia could be in some hot water. According to recent reports, Nokia 7 models may be secretly sending data to China without the user knowing about it. Nokia says that the issue was a software bug and that it has been fixed.

Apple patents hint at improved Apple Store and unboxing experiences

It looks like Apple is working on ways to improve the Apple Store and product unboxing experiences. The company has been awarded a few patents, largely for tech that can be used in product packaging to ensure products stay charged.

Apple patent suggests Apple Watch bands could have built-in fitness indicators

Apple may be exploring ways to make Apple Watch bands a little more useful. A new patent has been filed by Apple that suggests Apple Watch bands could eventually have indicators for things like fitness goals.

New Sony patent suggests a wireless PSVR headset could be on the way

Images and documents in the Japan Patent Office appear to suggest that Sony is planning a wireless version of the PlayStation VR headset. It isn't clear which system it will be used for.

Fossil is working on a smartwatch with BMW, and it’s coming next year

Fossil, the watch company that makes smartwatches under its own name and partners with other major brands too, intends to launch a smartwatch with car manufacturer BMW in the future.
Social Media

A Facebook, Instagram bug exposed millions of passwords to its employees

Facebook, Facebook Lite, and Instagram passwords weren't properly encrypted and could be viewed by employees, the company said Thursday. The network estimates millions of users were affected.

Diesel’s denim-inspired smartwatch straps are a casual, colorful must-own

Diesel will release two new versions of the On Full Guard 2.5 smartwatch later this year, with seriously cool, denim-inspired straps in classic Diesel colors. We tried them on at the Baselworld 2019 show.
Movies & TV

Apple’s next big event is set for March 25: Here’s what you can expect

Apple's next big event takes place on March 25 in Cupertino, California. The company is expected to make several announcements related to its services, including Apple TV, so follow our guide to get ready for the big event.

Tips and tricks to get you started with your new Fitbit Inspire HR

The Inspire HR may be an entry-level fitness tracker in Fitbit's lineup, but the device still has plenty of features to explore. These are our favorite tips and tricks to help you use the Inspire HR to its fullest potential.

How three simple words could be the difference between life and death

What3Words’ app-based address system gives a three-word code to every three-meter-square patch on the planet, with its accuracy and ease of use now catching the attention of first responders in the U.K.

The Moto G7 Power, with its massive battery, is now available for purchase

After a number of leaks and rumors, the Motorola Moto G7, Moto G7 Play, and Moto G7 Power are finally here. The devices represent quite a spec bump over the previous-generation Moto G6 phones, yet still come at a reasonable price.

Got gadgets galore? Keep them charged up with the 10 best USB-C cables

We're glad to see that USB-C is quickly becoming the norm. That's why we've rounded up some of the better USB-C cables on the market, whether you're looking to charge or sync your smartphone. We've got USB-C to USB-C and USB-C to USB-A.

Get ready to say goodbye to some IFTTT support in Gmail by March 31

If This Then That, the popular automation service, will drop some of its support for Gmail by March 31. The decision comes as a response to security concerns and is aimed to protect user data.

5G's arrival is transforming tech. Here's everything you need to know to keep up

It has been years in the making, but 5G is finally becoming a reality. While 5G coverage is still extremely limited, expect to see it expand in 2019. Not sure what 5G even is? Here's everything you need to know.