Skip to main content

Supreme Court set to make ruling on cell phone searches

supreme court set make ruling cell phone searches
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Do the police have the right to search through your phone without a warrant if you’re detained? It’s an issue that has divided the lower courts in the United States, and now the Supreme Court has announced it will hear two cases that will set the precedents for how mobile devices are treated in the future.

Part of the problem stems from the rapid advancement in smartphone technology in recent years: thumbing through an arrestee’s phone is no longer just about a list of names and numbers. Today’s mobiles contain emails, photos, GPS data, passwords and a wide range of other sensitive information. The Supreme Court’s rulings on these cases, due to take place at some point in April, will determine the police’s level of authority and access in future incidents.

The first case, Riley vs. California, involves a more modern smartphone. After his arrest on charges of attempted murder and assault in 2009, police searched David Riley’s phone: they turned up evidence that identified him as a gang member out to kill members of a rival gang, as well as a photo showing Riley by a car spotted at the scene of the shooting. His lawyers believe the warrantless search of the phone violated Riley’s constitutional rights, and thus should not have been used as evidence.

The second case, United States vs. Wurie, involves an older, basic flip phone — up to this point, judges have considered searching these phones as akin to flipping through an address book discovered on a suspect’s person. Brima Wurie was arrested in 2007 for drug dealing after an incriminating call log linked him to a buyer, but he appealed his conviction on the basis that the phone search violated the Constitution. This appeal was turned down by the First Circuit Court of Appeals.

While the same constitutional issue is raised by both cases, they are expected to be heard separately. The two outcomes will determine whether your phone is fair game if you’re arrested, or if police will first have to obtain a warrant to gain access to it.

Editors' Recommendations

David Nield
Dave is a freelance journalist from Manchester in the north-west of England. He's been writing about technology since the…
How to block a number on iPhones and Android phones
OnePlus 5 soft gold with the phone app open.

There are many reasons to want to block specific numbers on your phone. Whether it's nuisance spam callers, or a particularly persistent ex you no longer want to talk to, the humble Block option is a phone mainstay. It used to be you'd need to contact your carrier to stop a particular number from calling you, but thankfully, it's a lot easier to block numbers in this day and age.

Read more
How to make a contact group on an iPhone to message multiple people
Close-up of the cameras on the iPhone 15 Pro Max.

iPhone has a bunch of cool features, but few are as useful as contact groups. As of iOS 16, Apple lets you pool contacts together into groups, making it easy to spam out messages to family, friends, or colleagues without needing to tinker with a bunch of clunky settings. You don't even need any extra software or apps – as long as you're running iOS 16 or later, you can quickly make a contact group on your iPhone.

Read more
Best iPhone deals: Save on iPhone 15, iPhone 15 Pro Max and more
iPhone 13 Pro in blue.

Even though iPhones are some of the best smartphones on the market, they can get pretty pricey, especially if you're going for some of the latest models. Luckily, while there aren't always a lot of great direct discounts to be had, you can certainly find some great carrier deals even on the best iPhones in Apple's lineup. To that end, we've gone out and found some of the best iPhone deals we could find, whether through carriers or unlocked, and collected them all below so you don't have to do the legwork. That said, if you're on a bit of a budget, then you could check out our list of the best refurbished iPhone deals instead, or you can check out some of these other great Apple deals to pair with your new iPhone.
iPhone 15 (128GB, locked to AT&T) — $730, was $830 (plus up to $700 off w/ trade-in)

The Apple iPhone 15 finally brings with it Dynamic Island which we’ve only previously seen on the Pro range. It’s a real game changer at times and is very convenient. Alongside that, the Apple iPhone 15 has the Ceramic Shield front to keep it more protected while its 6.1-inch Super Retina XDR display promises to be up to two times brighter than the iPhone 14 in the sun. There’s also a 48MP main camera with 2x telephoto lens to help you take great shots. The A16 Bionic chip has plenty of processing power to aid with software adjustments.

Read more