Skip to main content

U.S. Marshal smashes woman’s smartphone to avoid being recorded

Occurring recently in an area of Los Angeles County called South Gate, 34-year-old teacher Beatriz Paez was assaulted by an unnamed U.S. Marshal while she was attempting to film a federal law enforcement operation related to a local biker gang. Captured by a mobile smartphone camera from a vantage point across the street, Paez was filming the police with her Samsung smartphone and speaking to a nearby officer when a deputy U.S. Marshal started approaching.

As Paez is stepping away from the scene, the deputy U.S. Marshal lunges at Paez and wrestles away her smartphone. Paez is heard screaming “Oh! No! Don’t do that!” during the scuffle. He then smashes the smartphone on the sidewalk, stomps on the mobile device and kicks the broken phone towards Paez. Of course, the law enforcement agent was unaware that a second camera captured the incident on digital video. Assuming Paez was also taking video at the time, she may have an additional digital file of the incident from her perspective, assuming the file can be recovered from the broken phone.

Releasing a statement about the incident to the L.A. Times, a representative for the U.S. Marshal’s service said “The U.S. Marshals Service is aware of video footage of an incident that took place Sunday in Los Angeles County involving a Deputy U.S. Marshal. The agency is currently reviewing the incident.” The video of the incident was uploaded to YouTube on Sunday and has been viewed more than one million times over the last three days.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

According to Paez’s account of the incident, the law enforcement officers claimed that she was interfering with the investigation. Of course, that’s the main legal reason that a police officer can claim when attempting to halt someone from filming. Otherwise, it’s completely legal to film the police on all 50 states according to U.S. courts. In turn, Paez responded by stating that she was on a public sidewalk and had the right to film the officers.

Yesterday, the ACLU of Southern California released a statement regarding the incident which readThere is no situation in which an officer can intentionally grab and destroy a camera being used to lawfully record law enforcement. The officer’s conduct is a blatant and deliberate violation of the Constitution and his duties as an officer to abide by the law. Members of the public, on a public street, unquestionably have a First Amendment right to record law enforcement officers, acting in the course of their duties. Indeed, as recent events have shown, video recording of law enforcement activity plays a crucial role in holding police accountable for misconduct — particularly in California, where public access to information about officer misconduct is limited by state law.”

An attorney for the National Lawyers Guild, Colleen Flynn, is currently representing Paez and believes that Paez’s constitutional rights were violated on Sunday. Speaking about the incident, Flynn saidWhat they wanted was to make sure that they were not held accountable, that nobody could see what actions they were taking.”

Editors' Recommendations

Mike Flacy
By day, I'm the content and social media manager for High-Def Digest, Steve's Digicams and The CheckOut on Ben's Bargains…
The best Google Pixel 8a screen protectors in 2024
The Google Pixel 8a's screen.

The Google Pixel 8a is Google's latest smartphone. While it's not a match for Google's flagship phones, the Pixel 8 and 8 Pro, it's not meant to be. The Pixel 8a is a midrange powerhouse with the Tensor G3 processor, a showstopping camera, and the advanced smarts of Google's Gemini Nano AI model.

But none of that matters if you can't see it. The display is a vital part of any smartphone, and the Pixel 8a's 6.1-inch OLED panel is a beauty. It has a 120Hz refresh rate and a high brightness, making it comparable to some of the best phones in the midrange market. However, all that tech should be protected. Here are the best Google Pixel 8a screen protectors to keep your phone's screen safe from scratches, dirt, and smudges.

Read more
Your Samsung Galaxy Watch is getting new AI health features
Samsung Galaxy Watch 6 and Watch 6 Classic, in black and silver.

Samsung has already put AI into your Galaxy smartphone, and its next move is to put it inside your Galaxy smartwatch too. The company will introduce Galaxy AI features to the Galaxy Watch range with the One UI 6 Watch update coming in the near future. The benefits all center around health and fitness.

Galaxy AI on wearables will also be part of the Samsung Health app, which is used to keep track of your health, fitness, sleep, and daily activity. What features will it include? At this stage, the company has detailed six key advancements using Galaxy AI in Samsung Health and One UI 6 Watch.

Read more
One missing feature has almost ruined the new iPad Air for me
A person holding the iPad Air M2.

I’m a few days into using the new 11-inch iPad Air (2024), and one single feature decision has annoyed me to the point where I’m questioning why it exists at all.

In Apple’s current iPad range, the iPad Pro (2024) is definitely the professional’s choice, while the regular iPad is the one for the bargain hunter. The iPad Air sits awkwardly in between them. While it seems to offer all the power and ability you could want without paying the iPad Pro’s high price, it doesn’t have the ProMotion 120Hz refresh rate screen — and that’s a serious drawback.

Read more