Why can’t Americans stomach unsubsidized phones?

unsubsidized cell phones wireless contractThis week is full of magic and wonder; new possibilities and fun; a complete remake of outward appearances.

Of course, I’m not talking about Halloween. I’m talking about my Mobile Phone Upgrade Day!

It’s been a long two years. I may have once decried the slowing progress of mobile technology, but that was before a new phone was only a few days away from my grasp. Now everything available seems so cool even Han Solo might have it.

North American consumers of all ages look forward to their own Upgrade Days with fervent anticipation, unless they are incredibly patient and mature. But since I don’t know anyone that fits that description, I’m going to generalize.

Notice how I said “North American consumers” back there? That’s because Americans and Canadians are the pretty much the only cell phone consumers who get to experience the wonder that is Upgrade Day.

Don’t worry. This isn’t going to turn into some infomercial about impoverished countries that can’t afford cell phones. It’s actually a cautionary tale about our spending habits, starring me. But first, some market analysis.

As you may know, Americans and Canadians are the only consumers that expect our cell phone companies to subsidize the cost of our handsets. Most consumers in the rest of the world, particularly Europe and Japan, buy their phones outright — what we call “unlocked” phones — and then connect them to whatever mobile carrier they choose under a pre-paid calling and data plan. More than half of European consumers operate this way. In the U.S., only 22 percent of us do. So how much does that $200 iPhone 5 actually cost?

locked phone unsubsidized cell phonesThe people who have been unfortunate enough to break a phone out of warranty know exactly how much it costs — in the case of the iPhone, $650. So where does that extra $450 come from? You, silly! It comes in the form of a two-year contact loaded with exorbitant fees and weird costs. These high monthly fees more than make up for AT&T, Verizon, Sprint, or T-Mobile’s initial $450 investment in your new phone after less than a year. North Americans spend an average of $51.40 monthly on cell service. Europeans spend only $30.83.

Even the Chief Marketing Officer for T-Mobile, Cole Brodman, thinks we’re stupid.

Why have we chosen to put ourselves under indentured cellular servitude? If you haven’t noticed from the past five years of this nation’s history, a vast amount of Americans are simply incapable of saving money. $200 now, plus $450, plus whatever else the company wants to charge over two years sounds a lot better than $650 when you’re standing in that store.

Why don’t more Americans and Canadians ditch to a pre-paid plan? For most, it’s because most of the phones available for our pre-paid carriers tend to … well, suck. That’s because they have to offer cheaper phones, relatively speaking, to even get a modicum of buyer attention. They simply cannot put a price tag of $650 on a phone, although both Apple and Google are dipping their toes in the water. However, the typical American cell consumer simply wasn’t conditioned to behave that way.

As latecomers to wide cellular adoption (PDF) relative to other industrialized markets like Europe, Americans didn’t view cell phones as the high-tech pieces of hardware that they are. We viewed them as roughly the same as our landline phones, which retailed for about $100. Other countries hated their landlines and wanted to escape them as fast as possible, accepting the price of entry for early adoption. Stateside, infant wireless companies knew they had to price their offerings relative to the competition to spur widespread adoption. They figured out a way to make that happen through subsidies and contracts, even if they were trying to sell something that was more akin to a home computer than a home phone.

So here I sit on Upgrade Day, knowing what a responsible person would do. Buying the new phone outright, even on a credit card, can save me roughly $1,000 over two years if I take it over to Virgin Mobile. But I am actually one of the few people who don’t have a problem with AT&T. I’ve been with them for over ten years. They have LTE in my city and anywhere else I would go. The thought of another two-year shotgun marriage to them doesn’t turn my stomach.

So I turn to the great decider. Not Ronald Reagan; my wife.

She’s not very happy at spending $199, but I drop the “noted technology columnist needs the latest technology to stay relevant” card. With this much resistance to $199, I forget about the pre-paid $650 phone idea altogether, including the $1,000 savings. I guess the American preference for subsidized phones isn’t such a mystery after all.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.


Bethesda's sharp new Elder Scrolls mobile game is blunted by microtransactions

Elder Scroll: Blades brings elements of the most popular open-world RPG to mobile phones. It has many of the features fans will expect but, in its current Early Access state, lacks the real charm and depth of its predecessors.

Samsung Galaxy S10 update gives manual control of Bright Night mode

Samsung 2019 flagship smartphone lineup is here, and there aren't just two phones as usual — there are four. There's the Galaxy S10, S10 Plus, as well as a new entry called the S10e, as well as the Galaxy S10 5G.

The OnePlus 3 & 3T both receive an open beta for Android Pie

Android 9.0 Pie has been released. But is your phone getting Android 9.0 Pie, and if so, when? We've done the hard work and asked every device manufacturer to see when their devices would be getting the update.

The black satin Razer Phone 2 is now available for $500

The Razer Phone 2 is finally here, and it's got upgraded specs, that super-smooth 120Hz display, and an updated design. Here's absolutely everything you need to know about the Razer Phone 2.

Sidestep banking fees with the nationwide launch of T-Mobile Money

T-Mobile has launched its Money banking service nationwide in the U.S., and it offers an extremely tempting set of features for everyone, including industry-leading interest rates, a powerful app, and no banking fees.

Charge and sync with the best Lightning cables for your iPhone or iPad

If you’re looking to replace a lightning cable, or in need of something a little longer or tougher, we’ve got you covered. Here are 10 of our favorite cables for the iPhone and other iOS devices.

Selfies are now banned at China’s gigantic Aperture Spherical Telescope

You can't take a selfie with the world's largest single-dish radio telescope anymore, as the Chinese government has banned everything from smartphones to digital cameras in the surrounding 5-kilometer area.

Make some time for the best smartwatch deals for April 2019

Smartwatches make your life easier by sending alerts right on your wrist. Many also provide fitness-tracking features. So if you're ready to take the plunge into wearables and want to save money, read on for the best smartwatch deals.

The dramatic BlackBerry Key2 Red Edition is now available in the U.S.

BlackBerry's Key2 is likely to be the best keyboard-equipped phone in 2019, with a modern look, some powerful specs, and totally revamped features. Here's everything you need to know about it.

Want to make calls across the internet for less? Try these great VOIP services

Voice over IP services are getting more and more popular, but there are still a few that stand above the pack. In this guide, we'll give you a few options for the best VOIP services for home and business users.

The Best iPhone 7 battery cases to give your phone some extra juice

The iPhone 7 doesn't have terrible battery life, but you never know when you'll need to juice up on the go. To help, here are the best iPhone 7 battery cases that can keep your smartphone charged and ready for long-term use.
Digital Trends Live

Digital Trends Live: Samsung Galaxy Fold woes, zombie pigs, and more

Today's topics: Samsung Galaxy Fold, Facebook A.I. voice assistants, YouTube comes to Fire TV, facial recognition on airline flights, the SpaceX DART program, Yale's zombie pigs, and much more!

The excellent Moto G6 is just $99 from Google Fi for a limited time

Getting a cheap smartphone can be a great way to squeeze value out of your dollars. Motorola's Moto G-range has always been good value, but never better than this: Get the Moto G6 for just $99 from Google Fi.

Keep your huge phone beautiful with the best iPhone XS Max cases

Apple's iPhone XS Max might be the best large phone the company has ever released. But a bigger OLED display and body means there's more glass to crack. Keep your massive phone safe with the best iPhone XS Max cases.