Skip to main content

YouTube Kids app comes under fire from consumer groups over ads

youtube kids comes under fire again
While it’s a safe bet the littl’uns have been happily playing about on YouTube Kids, a number of U.S. consumer groups have evidently been less impressed.

At least eight organizations, among them the Center for Digital Democracy, the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood, and the Consumer Federation of America, are expected to file a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) on Tuesday claiming the mobile app mixes content to such an extent that it’s sometimes hard to tell if it’s genuine programming or advertising.

Related Videos

It’s believed the consumer groups will call for the current regulations, which stipulate how TV ads are presented to children, to be applied to digital media, too.

YouTube Kids, which launched for Android and iOS devices just seven weeks ago, is supposed to be a family-friendly version of the popular video streaming site, offering child-focused content through an easy-to-use interface. But having had a chance to properly evaluate the app, consumer groups have found fault with the service and decided to band together to voice their concerns.

Commenting on Google’s new software, Josh Golin of the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood said that YouTube Kids “exploits children’s developmental vulnerabilities by delivering a steady steam of advertising that masquerades as programming.”


McDonald’s, Mattel, and Hasbro are three big-name companies that’ve so far paid to advertise on YouTube Kids. The consumer groups’ complaint cites McDonald’s content as an example of how the lines are being blurred between paid-for material and normal programming. It claims the fast-food giant is showing regular TV-style ads alongside content slots it says “are really promotions for McDonald’s products.”

Interestingly, groups such as Common Sense Media and the Family Online Safety Institute gave the green light to YouTube Kids when it launched in February, though it’s possible YouTube has since altered the way the app delivers content.

Plans for more child-focused apps

The action is likely to come as a blow to the Mountain View company, not least because it’s the first Google product built from the ground up especially with children in mind. There are plans for more child-focused versions of Google products, but the company will probably feel the need to address these current concerns before it starts thinking about rolling out such apps.

Speaking to the LA Times about the consumer groups’ expected action, a YouTube spokesperson insisted the company had consulted many child advocacy and privacy groups when developing the software, adding, “We are always open to feedback on ways to improve the app.”

[Source: LA Times, Bloomberg]

Editors' Recommendations

WhatsApp follows Facebook and YouTube to over 2 billion monthly users
whatsapp group admin feature telegram

WhatsApp has joined the 2 billion users club. The Facebook-owned messaging company today announced that the 11-year-old app now hosts over 2 billion monthly users -- up from 1.5 billion in 2017 and about 500 million short of Facebook’s 2.5 billion user base. After Facebook and YouTube, WhatsApp is the third app worldwide to have crossed 2 billion users.

"There are so many significant and special moments that take place over WhatsApp and we are humbled and honored to reach this milestone. We know that the more we connect, the more we have to protect. As we conduct more of our lives online, protecting our conversations is more important than ever," WhatsApp wrote in a blog post.

Read more
YouTube Music replaces Google Play Music as default app for tunes in Android 10
youtube music pre installed android 10

Google has completed YouTube Music's replacement of Google Play Music. The YouTube Music app will now come pre-installed on all Android 10 devices, doing away with Google Play Music, which was the previous music-streaming app on Android. The app will also be installed on new devices that ship with Android 9.

Until now, to use YouTube Music, you had to download it separately from the Google Play Store, but now you'll be able to use it out of the box. In other words, the two apps will essentially switch places -- so you'll still be able to download Google Play Music from the Play Store if you so choose.

Read more
Any child who can do basic math can hack YouTube Kids’ parent controls
YouTube Kids

YouTube Kids officially launched Friday on the web. The website offers a similar experience to the YouTube Kids mobile app and allows parents to set limits on what content their children are able to watch on the platform.
The idea is that parents decide what children ages 12 and under and able to watch on the service and then those kids will be essentially locked out of viewing inappropriate content.
However, there’s one big issue with that age lock: to verify that you're a parent, all you need to do is answer a basic math question that children using the service could potentially solve, essentially giving them the ability to unlock it and watch whatever they want anyway.
Independent Journal Review editor Josh Billinson highlighted the issue on Twitter. Essentially, when kids try to unlock YouTube Kid they’re faced with a question “For Parents Only” that is consistently an easy multiplication problem. While that might be slightly challenging for younger kids, children who are toward the older part of YouTube Kids’ demographic, from 8 to 12 years old, should probably be able to handle basic multiplication by now.
Another concern: Even if a child doesn’t know multiplication, and ignoring the fact that calculators exist, making an incorrect guess at the questions doesn't ever lock a child out -- it just produces another math question. In theory, this means a kid could keep trying until they got a question they could actually answer. Or, if they kept typing in the same number, there’s a chance that the number they type will eventually be correct and grant them access.
The launch of YouTube Kids on the web comes the same day that Google agreed to pay between $150 and $200 million to resolve an FTC investigation into YouTube over alleged violations of children’s property law, Politico reports.
That issue stemmed from privacy groups claiming that YouTube collected personal information about minors and then used that information to target them with advertising without their parent’s permission.
The settlement is the largest ever made for a violation of the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act. Previously, the highest settlement ever was $5.7 million, which was paid in February by TikTok competitor
We've reached out to YouTube to see if it has plans to change the authentication tool and will update this post if and when we hear back.

Read more